Sins at The Cathedral

Story by invisibleBear on SoFurry

, , , , , , , , ,

Fave the original: https://www.furaffinity.net/view/13669841/

Show the panda some love!

Its based off this old rp we did involving a chubby bunny priest and a lizard, it was his first time doing a rp with a bunny at that time which made it very fun. I mention it in the story but just so we're clear, the choir boy lizard is in fact 18 years old so the age of consent is there. I wouldn't make it weird like that anyway X3

On to the next story!

P.S: Don't be afraid to get a story commission from him. http://www.furaffinity.net/journal/5767796/


Sins at the Cathedral

In St. Augustine's Catholic Church, everyone had grown to love the father that resided there. Jeremy Papenbrook was a kind father in the church, a rotund and jovial man who would always listen to the troubles of those who needed someone talk to. The chubby rabbit was his town's best priest and respected gratefully, even though he was single nobody seemed to ask why for believing he was a strong man of chastity.

One day after Sunday preaching, one of Father Jeremy's duties was to listen to the people's sins in the confession booth. There was nothing he didn't know about his fellow townspeople and their sins forgiving each one of them so they could be forgiven by god as well, but today was much different; as he sat in his separate stall, Jeremy sat in wait before he heard the sound of a door opening at the other stall. Looking through the small window he noticed a yellow scaled reptile with black messy hair in a red and white gown worn by the church. It was young Felix, who was one of the boys in the church choir, the boy was a senior at high school at eighteen and was about to go to a good college in a matter of months. The young lizard would always come to Jeremy for advice and was a good catholic, so what kind of sins could he have possibly done?

"Forgive me father... for I have sinned." Felix stated with nervousness in his voice. "I've done something... truly sinful..."

"Do not let it pain you anymore my son, tell me your sins." The father replied.

"I'm sorry, it all started one day in school..." Felix sighed as he continued his story. "It was football practice, we were getting ready for our next game and were working our hardest for when we win. When it was time to go, the team went off to the locker room to shower. I'm always the last to go cause I clean and pack up the equipment we use for next time, I usually take a shower by myself but..."

"Go on son, you can tell me anything." Jeremy assured. "Nothing you tell me will step foot out of this booth. I promise you that."

"T-Thank you father... this time was different because... my coach was there." Felix explained. "He was a big guy, strict like a drill sergeant but was fun to talk to and helped a lot when we were new. He reminded me a lot of you actually, more so because he was also a bunny..." The father couldn't help but smile listening to how much respect the young man had for him. "Since it was just the two of us, he suggested that we shower together, but... but I..." The lizard slowly whimpered tearing up as the mere thought of it came to mind. "Father... please don't think bad of me I... I..."

"Felix please, please talk to me." Seeing the boy begin to cry only worried Father Jeremy more by the minute, he had to get him to talk somehow. "I swear nothing would ever make me think badly of you."

"..." Felix sighed softly and continued his story. "You see, I never felt comfortable showering with the other guys but not because I was uncomfortable. You see... I think... I think I'm attracted to men..." The bunny was about to gasp, but he knew he had to hold it in. If Felix heard he might overreact. "I thought it was just me imagining things, but the more I thought about it... the more I imagined what it must've been like. Showering with the guys, seeing each other naked and seeing each their... penises. I found myself getting attracted to their bodies in general, I couldn't stop thinking about them at all. Seeing their toned body, muscular sometimes even chubby frames, I found myself becoming aroused thinking about it."

Father Jeremy wasn't appalled, nor was he disgusted by the boy's confession. He cared for young Felix, even as a priest he was open to new things and never thought badly to those who had different sexuality. It was one of the many reasons people loved him, but lately that open mindedness had grown to be much more than that; even now as he heard the boy talk, Jeremy could feel his loins begin to tighten. He was becoming aroused from listening to the boy's story, but he had to endure and not let his growing lust overwhelm him. "Continue on Felix, what happened between you and your coach?"

"Well, since I had no choice... I joined him in the showers." Felix continued. "I was worried what would happen if I looked at him, so I tried to keep a few feet away. It was still hard not to look, especially when my coach kept pulling me with a hearty speech. He'd wrap me under his arm pulling me closer to his body, his furry chest was all over my face and my hand kept squeezing at his fat belly like it was a pillow." The priest could feel the lust growing as he imagined the scene, the big strong arms, that soft plushy belly pressing onto Felix's body only made his member stiff in his pants. "Coach was someone I found very attractive, and when I was close I got to see his crotch... I couldn't believe how well endowed he was. I couldn't stop imagining what I saw even after I went home, when I did I um... Father is it really ok for me to continue?"

"Y-Yes please, you need to tell everything in order to cleanse yourself of your sin." Father Jeremy was being truthful, but in the back of his mind he really wanted to listen to more while his paw began to tease the throbbing bulge in his trousers. "N-Now go on son..."

"Well, when I was home... that night I took off my clothes and began to stroke myself." Felix blushed embarrassed at admitting this. "I just imagined seeing the coach's body again. That chubby muscular build of his, the way his muscles looked so profound in the water, that round belly cushioning my head, the top of my head hair brushing against his soft yet firm chest..."

Father Jeremy was soon controlled by his lust, as the boy reminisced about his time pleasuring himself the older bunny began to reach down and pleasure himself through his own robes. Oh how sinful the whole thing was, but it was extremely erotic to him as well; to be here stroking himself from the tale of the young man explaining his own sexual tale in great detail had to have been the most sinful thing he could ever do in his life. But it only became more arousing as he began to imagine the boy sitting next to him, the thought of seeing Felix so nude and vulnerable, to see his smooth scaled body... to even touch it. And to see the boy stroking throbbing cock was too much for the priest to handle, he covered his mouth but even then his muffled moans were still easy to hear as he came.

"Father are you alright?" Felix was worried after hearing the muffled moans from the priest. "I-I didn't upset you did I?"

"Oh n-no don't worry, everything is just fine." He nervously assured hiding his exhausted breath. "Listen son, I know what you must feel now has left you confused. But I want you to know that you have nothing to be ashamed of, I know you may think that god disagrees with the idea of homosexuality but that is not true. The lord is accepting of many things so do not forget that."

"W-What about my parents they'll-!"

"Give it time, you don't have to tell them right now." He quickly assured the young man before he could feel any more depressed. "You can wait a few years until you are ready, just know that whenever you need it... I'll be here for you when you want to talk."

"Thank you for listening father... thank you for everything." Felix finally let out a sigh he had been holding in, relieved that he at least had one person he could find solace with. "I feel a bit better now that I know you're someone I can talk to, Im happy to know a great person like you."

"I-I feel the same way my boy... now go on and get on home before your parents worry." Seeing the smile on Felix's face through the small screen gave the bunny a sign of relief, but his mind began to wander back to the incident that occurred. He held onto the cum soaked spot of his robe and feared what he had just done. "Oh god... please forgive me for my sins."


It seemed like Felix wasn't the only one beginning to question his sexuality, Father Jeremy never questioned it before but it seemed that he slowly began to feel an attraction to the young choir boy; the days went by and he continued to remember the scenario again and again, fantasizing of being able to touch that young lizard and caress his scaled body with his hands. 'Oh god what is wrong with me? I've caused the most terrible of sins in the church. But for some reason I can't help but feel like I'm...embracing a part of me that was locked away for such a long time. I have no problems with homosexuals and accept them as well. Oh but why must I have such arousing feelings from Felix of all people?'

Nervous to the brink, the bunny priest found himself unable to even do his usual chores around the church. He tried not to act like it was there, but as Felix stayed at his side to help him he became more enamored with the boy; why did the boy have to be so sweet and kind, why did he have to be so attractive to him? Jeremy's strange clumsiness began to worry the young choir boy. "Is everything ok Father?"

"Oh! Yes I'm just fine of course." He hurriedly lied; the lizard boy wasn't really buying it though. "So tell me Felix, how have you been since then? Has everything been alright for you?"

"Yes Father I have, it took a while but the past month has really helped." Felix smiled as he grabbed a broom and helped in sweeping the church. "I went to my school's LGBT club and though I was nervous... I've actually gotten to accept who I am more. I was able to make new friends who helped me as well. T-Though you're still someone I really appreciate to have as a friend of course!"

"Hehe, well I'm happy to hear that at least." He chuckled softly. "I'm happy to have you in the church choir as well my boy; your voice is beautiful and is always a treasure to listen to. Not only that but you always take the time after church is over to help me clean up. I don't know how I can truly thank you sometime."

"Oh father its ok... I'm just happy to get to be with you..." The lizard seemed to sound disappointed as he replied to the priest. "I'm always happy to be there for you..."

"Is everything alright Felix, you sound troubled." Jeremy noticed the sad look in the boy's eyes and gave him a comforting hand on his shoulder. "You know you can always talk to me son, you don't have to worry."

"Father I... I feel like I've sinned again just now." He muttered silently gripping the bunny's hand.

"Just now? I don't understand what could you have possibly sinned for?" Jeremy pressed both hands on the boy's shoulder looking into his wandering eyes. "Tell me what's wrong."

"I have sinned father... for this..." Felix's head slowly edged closer until their lips finally pressed together, he gently kissed the older priest gripping onto his sleeves to keep them together before pulling away from the soft white furred lips. He quickly turned away from Jeremy's sight before he could see his expression. "Forgive me father... I-I..."

"Felix how... why would you do this?" The father asked blushing fiercely through his fur.

"I'm sorry; I never told you this before but..." Felix whimpered softly, every word slowly brining water to his eyes. "Back then... when I told you that I thought about my coach as I pleasured myself, in actuality... I was really thinking about you."

The priest had been in shock even before the boy admitted his feelings to him, though in his mind he knew that had to be the reason Felix had always been there to assist; his chest felt as if it was full of butterflies fluttering about, how could he react to this without hurting the sweet boy's feelings? Jeremy felt the sins piling up on his back more and more, but for once in his life he came to a decision... he would follow his heart than follow his faith.

"Felix, my dear boy... you have no reason to feel upset." Jeremy turned around and ruffled the red hair on the lizard's head. His hand caressing the soft scales before resting it on the reptile's cheek. "As I told you before, God forgives those who asks for it. But now... I believe it's time we partake in something more than prayer in the church's guest room."


Upstairs in the church's attic, the two slowly began to embrace in amorous bliss. The room lit with sweet scented candles as the two kissed deeply on the large master bed, Felix laid on top of the chubby priest's belly as he continued to ravage the inside of his mouth. Their tongues wrestled and twirled around with the other while their hands gave the occasional grope to their bodies. Jeremy trembled and moaned as the reptile turned and began to lick his fat shaft, it was a modest 6 inches but its girth was at least as thick as a beer can.

"Ohhh gods..." He said in sweated pants, the lizard's tongue was so broad and long that it actually wrapped around his cock like it was nothing. Jeremy's moans grew louder as he felt those soft scaled lips wrap around his head. "Oh my god F-Felix! How... h-how did you learn to do such a thing?"

"Mmmpff..." Felix mumbled and murred around the large shaft, the bunny trembling from his sweet mouth and practically whimpering as he moved away from his well lubed dick. "I always wanted to do this to you father, I wanted to make you feel great so... I practiced with some toys I brought a couple weeks ago."

"T-That's quite the *ahhh* amazing skills you... *oooh* attained in the last few weeks." Jeremy's words were covered by his constant moaning which only transformed into a pleasured scream as he felt the thick lizard tongue trail down under his cum filled orbs and made their way to tickle at the unused taint between his rump's round cheeks. "OH GOD FELIX!"

Hearing his words of pleasure, Felix continued his advancements as his tongue encircled and teased the rabbit's hole. Having his new lover pleasure him in such a way made him forget that he had to do the same, the lizard had a slit hiding his privates but through their making out he could feel the fleshy knob throbbing and leaking pre on his chest. He pulled the meaty cock back to his lips, shocked and excited that it stood at an amazing 8 inches. Jeremy licked at the shaft, suckling softly while his lover's tongue probed deeper into his anal passage. He couldn't take it anymore, the bunny had fantasized countless times the past month and if he didn't do it now he would undoubtedly lose it... he needed to be filled with that massive shaft before him. "Felix I... I can't take not feeling it anymore. Oh god I don't know how to say it without being vulgar b-but..." The priest's moan formed into another scream as his lover's tongue touched a very sensitive spot inside of him. "Oh fuck, please do it Felix... take your amazing cock and fuck my ass!"

Felix was shocked and aroused by the priest begging and whimpering in such a slutty tone, he had expected to be the one to bottom for him but it looked like the bunny had the same fantasies as he did; not wanting to displease Jeremy, he lifted himself from the comfy belly and stood in front of the priest letting their pre coat each other's head before he trailed down and slipped his cock between those ample furred cheeks. The whimpering priest shuddered in anticipation as he felt that felt head press against his winking pucker lubed in pre, slowly Felix began to edge his way in inch by inch.

"Please don't tease me anymore, I can't bear it for so long... put it all the way in!" Jeremy pleaded to his lover who nodded and plunged his way with a powerful thrust. The chubby bunny became such a moaning wreck as the massive cock spread him wide hiding his prostate hard; he bucked and arched into the air as thick wads of bunny jizz rocketed outward over his head coating his milk white fur in seed. Felix was surprised to see how many ropes fly out of the beer can that was the father's cock, only to be more surprised as it still stood hard and proud ready to fire again. "Fuck me... please do it... I need it... oh god Felix I want you to ram into me constantly!"

"Oh Father!" How could he say no to his lover's needs? The young reptile took clutched onto his hips and began to fiercely and rapidly pound into the bunny's fat rump. The cushiony cheeks slapping against his crotch each time while he watched as his massive cock pulled out and back into his lover's tunnel. Jeremy moaning out as the bed began to shake and bang against the wall, he knelt down and clamped his lips suckling eagerly at the rabbit's hard nipple. His tit nursed while his hole's sweet spot became impaled every time driving the bunny mad, it made Felix's heart racing. "Father... oh Father Jeremy, I love you... I love you so much!"

"I love you my dear boy... fill me up... give the father your seed of life!" The priest begged for it, pleaded like a shameless whore wanting more and more until he came again with another pleasurable scream. Felix moaned out in synch with his lover as the hole tightened around his cock like a vice, hot cum filling Jeremy to the brim while more bunny cum flew into the air like fireworks. "Ohhh god yes... yes my dear, dear boy... so goooood..."

"Father..." Through panted breaths, Felix pulled away from the warm hole and sat himself on top of the soft cum stained belly to kiss his lover deeply. Moaning into each other's mouths as their bodies felt extremely sensitive. "Father... a-are you ok with what happened? I just... don't want you to feel ashamed after all of this."

"Ashamed... for whatever reason would I be ashamed of experiencing such a labor of love by my beloved?" Jeremy caressed the boy's back, trailing down to teasingly grope his scaly rump. "I'm hoping to have more moments like this very soon."

"Oh father..." He moaned softly feeling the furred hand against his skin, slightly hoping on the bunny's belly as he felt that member behind him throbbing for yet another chance of release between his cheeks to press at his pucker. "Hehe, it looks like you want to have another moment right now Father Jeremy. It looks like we'll be here for a good long time."

"Oh my lord in heaven..." The bunny chuckled nervously. "Please grant me strength for the trials I'm about to take."

"Amen Father..." On that day on, the church had become filled with the smell of scented candles... and lust filled musk.