Hearts Set Afluttershy

Story by XD385 on SoFurry

, , , , , , ,

#5 of The Lost Element


I awoke to the feel of someone tapping my face gently. The hardness of the object that was touching me made me realize that it was a hoof. When I opened my eyes, I found that the hoof in question had the same opal-studded silver bracelet that I had purchased the previous day clipped on above it. And looking down at me was none other than Rarity.

"James... This bracelet... I know I did not fall asleep while wearing it. Do you know where it came from?" Rarity asked me without taking her big azure eyes' gaze off me.

I smiled shyly, remembering that I had purchased it for her the previous evening as a means to repay her for making such an amazing robe for me to wear to the Grand Galloping Gala in a few months. "You're welcome. I hope opals are OK with you."

Rarity looked back at her bracelet and held it up to look at it from other angles. "Just silver with a ring of opals embedded in it... A simple design, but there's something to be said about keeping silver jewelry simple." She said with a smile.

"My mom told me that once." I replied, recalling the saying about silver jewelry.

She then asked while smiling in gratitude, "Well, I certainly appreciate this fine gift. But may I ask why you got this for me? And was there a particular reason why you chose opals?"

I nodded as I sat up before explaining. "It was to repay you for everything you've given me since I came to Equestria. And I felt bad that I had given you almost nothing in return. Especially for that robe. So I picked that up yesterday evening to return the favor. As for opals, I chose them because they have the same name as your cat. So all you have to do is look at it to think about her."

Rarity blushed slightly before looking at her bracelet once more. "Oh, James... Even after making it clear that I wanted nothing from you, you got me this lovely little item. Such a gentleman you are." She then surprised me with a kiss on the cheek. "I'll wear this all the time. And in return, I'll weave you any clothing you want. Don't be shy about it. I'm not taking no for an answer."

Even after receiving a gift for something valuable she had made for me, Rarity was STILL insisting on giving me something for free. Her generosity truly knows no bounds. "Well...thanks again, Rarity. I'll try to not go overboard." I replied with a uneasy grin.

"Oh, you don't need to hold back. I enjoy the challenge of weaving clothing for the human body. But I really must get busy. Applejack's dress could use quite a bit of patching up!" I watched as Rarity trotted out of my room, leaving me alone.

Now that I was wide-awake, I got dressed in the clothes that Rarity had made for me earlier. She also gave me a new pair of socks she had woven as well. "I forgot how nice it is to have clean clothes everyday." I muttered, grateful that Rarity took my dirty clothes to be cleaned each day.

The first thing I found upon stepping out into the main workroom was Opal batting around a small ball of yarn. A thought occurred to me as I called out, expecting Rarity to be somewhere in the room. "Rarity, has Opal been fed this morning?"

Rarity's voice came from behind me. "Not just yet, but she will be soon! Opalescence! Time for your breakfast!" Opal responded with a purr as she left the ball of yarn alone and walked into the kitchen.

I peeked into the kitchen and found Rarity opening what seemed to be a can of tuna with a can opener by using magic. She then turned it upside-down, shaking the meat inside into a small bowl before setting it on the floor. As Opal started on her meal, I asked, "When should I feed Opal tonight?"

Rarity replied while raising her head to look at me, "Perhaps around 5 or 6. It will take her some time to regain her appetite." I nodded reflexively, making a mental note as I did so.

I turned towards the front door on the far side of the main workroom, but froze when I noticed the bottom half had been left open. "Rarity, did Spike just come in to visit?" I called while looking over my shoulder, not knowing of many short enough to only have to use the bottom half of the door.

My landlord entered the main workroom to see what I was referring to. "Strange... I wasn't expecting any visitors this morning. And Spike always says hello once he comes in."

While we pondered what may have happened, Rarity suddenly let out a yelp. I turned to face her and found Diamond Tiara trying to stand on her back. "I've got you nooowwowww! Whoa... I'm OK... I can do this.... Yah!" The filly seemed to be having great difficulty maintaining her balance just before she leapt at me. She climbed onto my shoulders and started lightly stomping her front hooves onto my head. "Does it hurt yet?! Are you gonna give my cutie mark back?!"

Despite the fact that hooves are quite hard, her stomps lacked impact and my thick hair absorbed most of it to begin with. I smirked while I crossed my arms. "That actually feels kinda good. Could you try rubbing it in a minute?"

Diamond Tiara growled loudly in frustration while she stomped faster. I looked at Rarity and asked, "Are you seeing this?" The unicorn laughed loudly, clearly amused by Diamond Tiara's futile attempts to harm me.

After a moment, I decided to make things tough for the bully. I walked over to a wall, turned around, and leaned against it with my head pressing Diamond Tiara against it. "Oof! Let me go! I can't breathe!" I smirked triumphantly as the filly squirmed behind me, not able to escape.

Rarity giggled while she listened to Diamond Tiara demand that I release her. "Darling, I think it's time you let the little imp be on her way." I shrugged and took a step forward, letting the filly drop to the floor before landing on her rump.

"Ow! You jerk!" Diamond Tiara groaned as she regained her footing. "This isn't over! I'll just keep coming back until you give my cutie mark back! Got it?!"

Rather than be intimidated, I was looking forward to whatever new futile antics Diamond Tiara had in store for me. "Yeah, yeah, whatever. Now get outta here, blank flank. Or do I have to introduce your flanks to my boot?" The filly needed no further encouragement as she dashed out the door. I closed the lower half of the door once she was gone. "She's actually proving to be fairly entertaining, isn't she?"

Rarity grinned with a rather sly expression. "I suppose even lowly bullies can be good for something. But now that you mention it, I should make a pair of boots for you sometime!" I chuckled, knowing that I was not really wearing boots when I made my threat to Diamond Tiara, nor did I really have any intention of striking her. It was just a means to get her to leave me alone for a while.

Remembering my daily job, I was on the verge of walking out the front door to head to Sugarcube Corner, but remembered at the last second that they close at noon on Sundays. And since they are not open long and that Sundays are known to be quiet, it would be unnecessary for me to go in. It was then that I remembered that I was supposed to meet up with Fluttershy in the afternoon to help her with an official.....bunny census? I could not quite recall what she called it at the time, but I was certain it involved working with baby rabbits.

When I turned around, I saw that Rarity was wearing a very exotic hat with a fluffy light blue brim and long peacock feathers. "Whoa, where are you going dressed like that?" I asked, finding the hat's appearance to be like something from a fashion show.

Rarity replied while giggling briefly at my praise, "Oh, I only wear this on occasion. In any case, I'm off to rendezvous with Fluttershy at the local spa. It's that time of the week again."

I nodded in understanding as I bid her goodbye. "OK then. Say hi to Fluttershy for me." I waved goodbye while my landlord headed out the front door.

With only Opal to keep me company, I just decided to look around to help pass the time. I found various unfinished dresses and vests hidden behind curtains that were draped over mannequins. Even though they were not complete, I could tell that they were still of high caliber and was curious of how they would look when finished.

I watched Opal play with a stuffed toy mouse, but soon began to find myself becoming bored. "It's not so fun in Carousel Boutique if you have nothing to do, I guess." I remember muttering out loud. More than anything, I just wanted to go outside and wander around Ponyville. However, I could not leave Rarity's home since there was the possibility of customers arriving at any given time.

"Ugh... What is there to do around here if you can't sew?" I grumbled, just wandering back and forth across the main workroom. Feeling there would be no harm in just going right outside the Carousel Boutique, I shrugged my shoulders and opened the front door for some fresh air.

Much to my surprise, I found a small wooden sign hanging from the upper doorknob on the outside. "Out to lunch. Be back soon?" I shook my head, knowing that Rarity had not left to get lunch. But in hindsight, I doubt stores sell signs that say 'Gone to beauty salon' very often if at all. Even so, if any customers were presented with that sign at the door, they would likely return in a few hours. Certain that it would be fine for me to leave for a while; I closed the door behind me and headed into town.

As I entered Ponyville proper, I found that fairly few ponies were walking the streets compared to other days of the week. Some businesses were still open, but it seems that Sundays in Equestria are generally days of rest like Sundays on Earth. Due to this, I was mildly surprised to see Applejack carting a load of apples to market. "There's no rest during Applebuck Season until every last apple is picked, I guess." I chuckled while I watched the farm pony hauling her produce through the streets.

I decided to say hi and walked over to Applejack, who seemed a bit too tired to notice my approach. "Morning, AJ. How's the applebucking coming along?"

Applejack let out a yawn as she turned to face me. "Oh... Howdy, James. The applebuckin's comin' along just fine. Although...I reckon I didn't sleep enough last night... But I'll manage with Big Macintosh coverin' me."

I patted Applejack on the shoulder, but then examined the cart she was pulling. Thinking I could use some exercise, I attempted to ask if I could pull the cart for her. However, I stopped as I noticed it was too low since it was only as tall as Applejack herself. If I were to try to pull it from the front, it would tilt backwards on an angle and spill some of the apples. Even though I restrained myself from speaking, it seemed that Applejack had noticed me looking at the cart. "What's the matter? Y'all wanna help pull this?"

I nodded and replied, "Yeah... But I realize that I'm too tall. If I pull, the cart will tilt and spill some of the cargo."

Applejack's expression became one of someone thinking deeply. A moment later, she asked, "Well, once I unload all these apples at market, would you like ta pull it back over ta Sweet Apple Acres for me?"

Knowing I would not have to worry about spilling anything while pulling an empty cart, I nodded readily. "Sounds like a plan to me."

The farm pony grinned before retorting, "Then it's settled. I'll leave the cart at the market for ya. It'll probably be ready in about, say, twenty minutes. You know where the market is, right?" I nodded, having visited it two days ago. With the time decided, I saw Applejack off and began to look around some more.

The first thing I did was try asking around for the location of the local spa since I had no knowledge it even existed until this day. Eventually, I noticed a familiar gray pegasus pony going from door to door with a mail satchel over her shoulder. "If she goes to each address everyday, she must know exactly where the spa is."

I walked over to the pegasus and tapped her on the shoulder. "Excuse me, Derpy. I could use some directions." She turned to face me after placing some letters in a mailbox. Once again, her eyes were crossed.

"Oh, hey there! I didn't see you yesterday! Where've you been?" Derpy Hooves asked, clearly happy to see me.

"Oh..... I've been around. But in any case, could you point me towards the spa?" I replied, certain a professional mailmare knew the location of every building in Ponyville by heart. Even someone like Derpy.

The walleyed pegasus grinned and pointed in one direction. "All you gotta do is head over to the town square. You'll find it right next door to the prank parlor."

I thanked Derpy and was about to leave. However, I then asked, "Um... Derpy? Just what exactly are you doing?"

She moved over to the next house and deposited a few letters into the mailbox. "Just doing my job. These letters don't deliver themselves, you know."

I stared in silence for a moment before frowning. "Derpy. I don't know if you've looked at a calendar today, but this is a Sunday. Postal services don't run on Sundays!"

The pegasus stared at me with her goofy eyes for a moment in silence. She then asked briskly, "They don't?" All I could do was facepalm at her response. Once again, I am not certain if that is a real word, but it matches what I did accurately.

Once Derpy went back to work, I headed towards the town square. I had no trouble locating it since I usually pass right through it just after leaving the Carousel Boutique. I first located the prank parlor, its floppy jester hat roof making it easy to spot. I suspected the building on the left was the spa. It had a light fuchsia roof that almost looked like a curtain draped over it. Three needle-like spires jutted up from the roof as well. Two large windows were at the sides of the front door, one of them being open a crack. A mostly sea green banner hung above the door depicting an image of a pony with a flowing golden mane and tail. However, I froze when I noticed Pinkie Pie heading my way. When she noticed me, the pink pony waved at me.

I approached her cautiously, fearing that her 'Pinkie Sense' would soon detect something about to happen. She seemed to notice my wariness since she asked, "What's wrong, James? You sprain your ankle or something?"

Once I was right next to Pinkie Pie, I replied, "No. I'm just minding my step in case your tail starts twitching. Wouldn't want an anvil to crush my skull and send my brains oozing all over the ground while scaring the living daylights out of everyone who sees it."

Pinkie Pie giggled with a reassuring grin. "My tail's not twitching, silly! Though my shoulder is a bit achy... That means there's an alligator in the tub!"

I stared at Pinkie Pie after hearing the most absurd prediction I had ever heard in my life. "An alligator? In a bathtub? And just where are you gonna find that?! Who would be taking a bath outside?!" As if to answer my question, a scream was heard from the open window of the spa behind me.

"Was that...Rarity?" I asked quickly. Fearing for my landlord's safety, I rushed through the spa's front door. Upon entering, I found an earth pony seated at what was likely the front desk. Her coat was cyan while her mane was a bright pink. I could not see her tail from my location, but I assumed it was also pink. She was also wearing a white headband and a white collar with a pink button keeping it in place. After glancing around to make certain Rarity was not in the room, I turned to the receptionist and asked, "Excuse me, but is a Miss Rarity here?"

The receptionist replied with a very strong accent that seemed to be European. Possibly Scandinavian or Greek, I could not honestly say. Do not worry about what those places are if you have no idea what I am referring to. "Why yes, she and Miss Fluttershy are resting in the hot tub. Are you here to make an appointment?"

I did not reply as I rushed into the spa. I found a large hot tub in the center of the main room, Rarity splashing about while shrieking in panic. The tub was fairly tall for ponies, but I found it to be just below my shoulders in height. Rather than run up the stairs, I reached out to Rarity and asked, "What's wrong? Is there a gator in the tub?"

The panicking unicorn replied without really looking at me, "I don't know! Something has my tail and it won't let go!" I reached down into the tub and felt around. Sure enough, I soon felt something bumpy and slick. I grabbed hold and yanked it out of the tub.

"I'll be darned... There really WAS an alligator in the tub." Gummy was dangling from my hand by his tail, his big purple eyes staring at nothing in particular. I made him face me before raising my finger to his face. "Listen, Gumball. You really shouldn't go swimming in other pony's bathtubs. Besides, hot tubs are too hot for cold-blooded critters like you. You could've ended up..." I stopped as Gummy snapped his jaws over my hand. The baby alligator was now dangling from the end of my arm.

"You're like a bear trap without barbs." I grumbled, doubting Gummy was going to release his grip anytime soon. I turned to leave, but suddenly felt Rarity tap me on the shoulder. "Yes, Rarity?" I asked, curious of what she needed.

My landlord replied with a very grateful smile, "Well, when you see Pinkie Pie again, tell her that I would appreciate it if she keeps Gummy on a leash when out and about." I looked out of the corner of my eye, seeing Fluttershy giggle at me from the opposite side of the tub. After making a mental note, I stroked Rarity's face gently to help calm her further from that unnerving ordeal and left the spa with Gummy still clamped onto my hand.

I did not have to go far to find Pinkie Pie since she was browsing a food stall right outside the spa. "Looks like your 'Pinkie Sense' proved correct again, Pinkie Pie. The only alligator in Ponyville was munching on Rarity's tail in a hot tub." I spoke as I held her pet out to her.

When Pinkie Pie turned to face me, she giggled goofily. "Wow, this is the first time he ended up in a bathtub that isn't mine! I wonder how he got this far away from me." She then approached Gummy and shook her poofy mane at him. Gummy responded by suddenly letting go of my hand and clamping his jaws onto Pinkie Pie's mane. "He won't be letting go anytime soon! Thanks again for finding him for me, James! See ya around!" I watched with a bemused smirk while shaking my head as Pinkie Pie trotted away while singing a casual song. Mostly just la la la and the like. However, I then snapped my fingers as I remembered that I had forgotten to forward Rarity's complaint to her. Oh well. Perhaps another time.

It was then that I remembered I had promised to pull Applejack's cart home and started to head towards the market. When I arrived, only a handful of stalls lined the streets. My eyes scanned the area, looking for any apple stalls. I soon spotted what I was looking for. An apple stall filled to the brim with red and yellowish apples while an empty cart stood next to it. An earth pony with a cutie mark depicting three wrapped candies who I had come to know as Bon Bon was standing near the stall while waving at me, probably to get my attention.

I approached the apple stall while weaving around other wandering ponies. "Applejack told me everything. I'm leaving the cart to you." Bon Bon said with a smile. I stood between the two handles and gripped them both firmly. I then thanked Bon Bon and headed on my way.

As I pulled the cart, I noticed that it seemed unusually heavy for something so small. I looked over my shoulder and found the harness Applejack had been wearing resting in the cart's empty body. I did not mind much. The extra weight would make for a harsher workout.

The trek to Sweet Apple Acres took longer than usual due to being careful to not let the cart tip over. When I arrived, I found Big Macintosh hauling a pair of bushels of apples towards the barn. I approached the burly red stallion and asked, "Just returning the cart. Where do you want it?"

Big Macintosh tilted his head towards the front of the barn and spoke briefly, "Right over there's fine." I nodded and released the cart where instructed.

I glanced around, expecting to see Applejack carrying a few bushels of apples as well. But there was no sign of the mare. I turned to Big Macintosh and asked, "Where's Applejack? Taking a nap somewhere?"

He replied with one word. "Eyup." I was hardly surprised, remembering how sleepy she seemed that morning.

I chuckled lightly before asking, "You don't say much if a simple 'yes' will suffice, do you?"

"Eyup." Big Macintosh replied once again. I found his brevity to be rather likeable. He is probably quite popular with the fillies in Ponyville.

"Well, I'm just gonna take a look around. Is that OK with you, Mac?" I asked, curious of what I would find out in the vast forest of apple trees.

"Eyup." Big Macintosh said again. I had to restrain myself from laughing since it was the third time he had said that in a row. Wanting to get out of earshot so as to not offend him, I ran off in one direction before allowing myself to laugh.

I wandered fairly far from the main area of Sweet Apple Acres. No matter where I looked, every single tree was an apple tree. "I'm amazed they don't get sick of apples. I'd probably be unable to stomach them if I had to live around them all year round." I muttered out loud to myself. And as you may have noticed by now, I do have a habit of talking to myself when no one is around me.

After a good deal of wandering, I came to a secluded spot on the orchard that caught my eye. In a rather stout apple tree ahead of me was what seemed to be a tree house. It was rather small as the ponies who constructed it are smaller than humans. The design was more like that of a real house complete with a slanted roof. A ramp led up to it with a small deck extending out to the side. A single window was on the side with two shutters open. Since I rarely saw tree houses back home, I was naturally curious about it.

I carefully walked up the ramp, worried that it would not support my weight. The door to the house was shut, so I went around to the side to look through the window. I found that it was open and bent down low to peek inside. Inside were three familiar fillies chatting with each other while looking over what seemed to be a book of activities.

"OK then. What should we try out next? One of these is bound to lead to one of us finding our talents!" The small pegasus pony spoke up while her tiny wings fluttered. I immediately recognized her as Scootaloo.

"We've tried comedy, scuba divin', mountain climbin', makin' taffy, hairdressin', psychic trainin', pig sloppin', bein' librarians... What else can we try?" The earth pony filly with a large pink bow on her mane asked. The southern accent made me remember her as being Apple Bloom. She then gasped and spoke up, "Ooh! I know! We can try skydivin'!"

The unicorn filly, who I recognized as Sweetie Belle, seemed hesitant about Apple Bloom's suggestion. "Um... That sounds kinda dangerous... How about we try painting or hula hoops?" I understood Sweetie Belle's unwillingness to try skydiving. That sport is too extreme for any kind of children.

After listening to the Cutie Mark Crusaders discuss a few other professions they could try out, I finally spoke up. "Sounds to me like you crusaders have been busy lately. I'm surprised that brainstorming doesn't qualify as a talent."

The three fillies turned to face me abruptly, apparently not expecting someone to be eavesdropping on them. But their expressions of surprise turned into gazes of glee. "Hey, James! It's great to see you!" Scootaloo shouted before she ran out the door, looped around the deck, and leapt into my arms. It was then I recalled from the previous day on how she commented that I was almost like a big brother to her.

"Howdy, James! Whatcha doin' out here?" Apple Bloom asked when she came to the window.

"Oh, just looking around." I replied while stroking Scootaloo's mane.

Sweetie Belle walked over to the window as well and asked, "How'd you find this place? Only Applejack and Big Macintosh know where our clubhouse is."

In response, I asked, "Clubhouse? This place belongs to you three?"

Scootaloo grinned while she looked up at me. "It's more than just our clubhouse. You could say that it's the Cutie Mark Crusaders headquarters!" Curious, I peeked in through the window while Apple Bloom and Sweetie Belle stepped out of the way. Pink curtains with a reddish floral pattern hung over the window itself. I could see a small table holding a vase of flowers with a couple of framed pictures hanging near it. On another wall was what seemed to be a hand...or rather hoof drawn map showing some familiar locations in Ponyville. There also seemed to be a small sewing machine with a rolled up sheet of dark red fabric near it. Aside from a box that seemed to contain a variety of snacks in a far corner and a desk against the far wall, the rest of the tree house was relatively bare.

"Pretty sweet pad you girls have here. And this is your base of operations?" I spoke with a smile on my face.

Apple Bloom grinned brightly while I turned to face her. "Yup! This is where we come up with new things to try ta find our hidden talents!"

I reached out and stroked the farm filly's head, prompting a faint giggle from her. "Sounds like things are never dull with you three. Are there other members in your club?"

Sweetie Belle replied while looking somewhat unhappy before quickly brightening her expression. "Um... Not right now. It's just us. But we're always accepting new members! Anypony without a cutie mark can join!" However, she then began to gaze at me while circling me after climbing out the window. "Mr. James, don't you have a cutie mark too? Why are you keeping your flanks covered?"

I winced at the thought of dropping my pants. "Girls, humans don't have 'flanks', per se. Besides, it's considered indecent for humans to walk around in public without anything covering the lower body." The three fillies only stared at me with blank expressions, clearly not understanding what I was getting at. With a sigh, I grumbled, "OK, I admit I don't have a cutie mark."

The three fillies gasped loudly in unison. Apple Bloom frowned as she too jumped through the open window, "You don't have one?! But yer all grown up! Don't all adults have cutie marks?!"

Scootaloo stomped her hoof in determination. "Well, if you don't have one yet, we'll just have to help you figure out what your special talent is! Come on, James! You're more than welcome to join!"

I was flattered to be invited to join the Cutie Mark Crusaders, even though I would normally be considered to be well over the age limit. "Girls... From what I know, humans DON'T get cutie marks. I'm not sure if we would..."

I was interrupted when Scootaloo ran up to me, reared up on her hind legs, and planted her forelegs against my chest while gazing up at me with her big adorable purple eyes. "Come on! It'll be fun! Whaddya say, big brother? Huh? Huh? Huh?"

Once again, I felt myself blush as Scootaloo compared me to being a big brother...no. She did not just compare me to one. She actually called me 'big brother' out loud. I lowered my glasses to look over them and asked, "Scootaloo... What did you call me?"

Apple Bloom and Sweetie Belle also seemed to be looking on in anticipation. However, Scootaloo continued to smile up at me with an uneasy grin. "I called you 'big brother'. Um... Is that OK with you? I'll stop if you want..." Her grin dissolved into an ashamed frown as she tried to avoid eye contact with me.

I closed my eyes for a moment while I thought it over. In actuality, having such an adorable pegasus filly for a little sister sounded like a likeable position to me. I snatched up Scootaloo in my arms and embraced her with her head against my cheek. "I've never had a little sister before. Especially one so cute and cool." I can remember Scootaloo giggle excitedly as she threw her forelegs around my neck.

The other two fillies applauded together, apparently displaying their approval of me as a big brother figure. Sweetie Belle then asked, "So, will you join?"

I began to fluster while stroking Scootaloo's mane. "Well...I'm not... I think I'm too... Is it really OK for... Ah, what the heck. Sure, I'll sign up to be a 'crusader' with you girls." The three fillies cheered in unison, clearly ecstatic that they had a new member.

"All right! Our first human member!" Scootaloo jumped out of my grasp and started hopping around the deck. Apple Bloom and Sweetie Belle cheered loudly too while they effectively started prancing about. All things considered, I am amazed they did not jump off the deck in the process.

"Now that you're a member of the Cutie Mark Crusader's, you get your own cape!" Sweetie Belle spoke with a smile before she ran back inside the clubhouse. I cocked my head to one side while I watched her through the window, wondering why I would need a cape. The unicorn filly reached into the desk and pulled out a cape that was made of the same dark red fabric leaning against the sewing machine. On each side near the corners was a blue emblem sewn into the fabric that depicted a rearing caped foal. Sweetie Belle then trotted out to me with it hanging from her mouth. But as she looked up at me, she glanced down at the cape. "Um... I think I need to make you a custom one..." I chuckled in response, the cape being several sizes too small for me. I probably could have used it as a reusable napkin.

As Sweetie Belle trotted over to the sewing machine, Apple Bloom tugged on my pants leg. "C'mon, Mr. James! Let's get ta work on thinkin' of what ta try next!"

I followed her and Scootaloo into the clubhouse while ducking through the surprisingly low door. "You don't have to use honorifics with me. I'm not your boss or a stranger." But when I stood up once inside, I bashed the top of my head against the ceiling. "Ow! Dang it!" I grumbled loudly while rubbing my scalp. The ceiling was so low; I could not even stand up straight.

Scootaloo stayed by my side while I took a seat in the middle of the floor. "You OK, James? I guess the clubhouse is a bit small for humans."

I grumbled in response while still rubbing my head, "Hopefully this will make me remember to mind my head. In any case, what do you have so far on the list of stuff to try?"

Apple Bloom dragged over a notebook with a list of activities to try out. Around three dozen had been crossed out. One activity made me wince. "What the... Hydra wrestling? Are you outta your minds?!" The very thought of hydras existing in Equestria made me feel that this land is not nearly as safe as I had originally suspected.

Scootaloo chuckled nervously at my reaction. "Heheh... Uh...yeah. That one didn't even make it off the ground. None of us had the guts to go into the Everfree Forest. That's the closest place we know of where a hydra lives."

Until then, I had never heard of the Everfree Forest before. "Everfree? Never heard of it."

Apple Bloom proceeded to explain. "It's that big forest ta the west of Ponyville. It's kinda creepy, so most ponies never go there. But Zecora lives there, so it can't be all that bad."

I have hiked through forests a few times in my life and not one of them struck me as creepy. Although I am sure any heavily forested area can be frightening at night when the canopy prevents any light from the stars and moon from reaching the forest floor. "Doesn't sound like a place I'd want to steer clear of...unless that hydra wanders it."

Scootaloo chuckled reassuringly, "Oh, you'll only find that hydra around Froggy Bottom Bog. If you stay away from there, I don't think it'll bother you. But anyway, whatcha think we should try next on the list?"

I turned my gaze to the notebook on the floor and read through the list of activities that had not yet been crossed out. "Um... How about trying out selling food at the local market?"

Apple Bloom gulped nervously for some reason while trying to avert her eyes. "Um... Just as long as it's not apples. Last time I tried that, Applejack had ta give away freebies." I felt it was wise not to ask for the details of what she was talking about.

"I didn't mean just one product. It might be best if you try selling a variety of goods. That way, you'll end up selling at least one product." I explained to the fillies.

Scootaloo grinned as she comprehended my words. "Ooh! I never thought of that! Sounds like a good idea too!" But before we could discuss it further, Sweetie Belle trotted over to us while dragging what seemed to be a large cape.

"I finished your cape, James. Is it the right size?" She asked while I took the cape in hand. It was then that I realized that she had never measured my height. When I asked her about it, the unicorn filly replied, "I just measured the distance between the floor and ceiling! Since you hit your head on the ceiling, the cape just had to be a little shorter than that." The overall design of the cape was the same as the smaller ones, but there was only a single large emblem on the backside right in the middle. I stood up to put it on, but ended up bumping my head on the ceiling again.

"For the love of..." I growled while I made my way to the door, the fillies giggling behind me. Once outside, I tied the cape around my neck. The cape reached fairly low, stopping just above my ankles. A breeze began to blow; lifting my cape and making it wave in the air.

"Whoa... You look much better in a cape than we do! Kinda like a superhero!" Scootaloo exclaimed as she came outside. I suspected that Equestria publishes comic books if 'superhero' can be in a pony's vocabulary.

"It's that good?" I asked, not really thinking I looked all that impressive.

"Yeah! You look awesome standin' tall with that cape wavin' behind ya!" Apple Bloom exclaimed while emphasizing my height by reaching high with her hooves.

Flattered by the fillies and their admiration, I crossed my arms to take a more heroic stance with two fingers gripping the rim encircling one of my glasses' lenses. Sweetie Belle let out a giggle and spoke, "That looks beyond amazing! I wish Rarity could see this!"

At the mention of my landlord's name, I remembered that she was likely still at the spa. In an attempt to dazzle my fellow crusaders, I jumped the railing on the deck and dropped down to the ground below. I could hear the three fillies cheer at my stunt. While they looked down at me, I grinned back at them. "Thanks again for allowing me to join and for making this awesome cape. But I have some things to do with Fluttershy at her place pretty soon. I'd also like to check up on Rarity before she leaves the spa. Could we meet up again sometime later?"

Sweetie Belle nodded with a bit of a dreamy smile on her face. "With Rarity? Are you asking her out to a candlelight dinner today? Or are you going to...um..."

Scootaloo interrupted the unicorn filly's train of thought with a disdainful groan. "Ewww! Don't bring up mushy stuff like that! You know I don't like that kinda thing!" I snickered at Scootaloo's response, realizing that she is more of a tomboy than even Rainbow Dash.

"Oh, sorry. It's just that I got kinda excited when I thought about that." Sweetie Belle spoke apologetically.

"Thought about what?" Apple Bloom asked while looking quite curious. I gazed up at the fillies, as I was also curious of what Sweetie Belle was referring to.

"It's just that... If Mr. James and Rarity were to get married, he would be my uncle!" Sweetie Belle explained while she hopped in place a few times with an excited grin.

I felt myself become hot when I heard Sweetie Belle's words. A human and a pony? Getting MARRIED? The idea sounded impossible, but at the same time, I could feel a slight crooked smile creep across my face. "Well...uh... That's a very tender thought, Sweetie Belle... But I really should be going now. Later!" I waved and ran off as quickly as I could. Before I was out of earshot, the fillies called out as they watched my cape wave in the wind while I ran.

Once I felt I was out of sight, I slowed to a walk. "Uncle James..... Heh... Has a nice ring to it, I guess." I muttered to myself out loud while I walked through the great apple orchard, although I would actually become Sweetie Belle's brother-in-law instead of uncle if I married her sister. I did indeed find Sweetie Belle to be adorable and likeable, and the thought of having her as a niece or even sister-in-law made me chuckle under my breath. But when I thought about her sister, Rarity, I also thought about my five other friends.

The more I thought about the six mares who had come into my life, the more I pondered if it was possible for one of them to become more than just a friend to me. There is Applejack, the hard-working earth pony with a country girl's charm. Then there is Twilight Sparkle, the wise and knowledgeable unicorn who I could always count on for sound advice. There is also Pinkie Pie, the lively party lover whose crazy antics are just plain cute and entertaining. There is also Rainbow Dash, known for being athletic and tough while still being surprisingly attractive. Of course, there is also my landlord, Rarity. Generous to a fault and quite beautiful and elegant too. And then there is Fluttershy, the timid pegasus pony with a heart of gold and looks to match.

While I walked, I considered my options. "Pinkie Pie is fun, but she's a little too crazy for me. If I somehow got involved with Applejack, I'd have to work myself to the bone on a daily basis... Ugh. That doesn't sound like a lifestyle I want. Rainbow Dash... I'd have to be an adrenaline junkie to win her heart. Not my style. Twilight Sparkle does sound like a good match.....but she's probably frequently too busy with her studies from Celestia to have time for a relationship. Not sure if it would work. I know it won't work with Rarity. She'll only settle for a prince. That leaves..." I then came to a stop. "Fluttershy..."

The thought of Fluttershy made me think deeply about her as a person. I recall speaking to her by the pond in the local park and on the bridge near her home. Her personality is fairly similar to mine, although I am not quite as soft-spoken as her. But I then remembered that she was the first pony in Equestria to come to my aid when I was under extreme mental duress when I first arrived in Ponyville. In my state of confusion and fear, she became my first friend. Perhaps she and I could.....

My train of thought was interrupted when I walked headlong into a tree. The impact snapped me out of my trance. However, I then pondered if such a relationship would ever work. Is it even legal for a human and a pony to have that kind of relationship? What was more, Fluttershy is extremely timid and shy. If I were to ever try to ask her out on a date or confess my feelings for her, she would probably turn me down. But no matter how many times I thought over my six friends, I kept coming back to Fluttershy. Of the six, she was the one I felt closest to.

I paused, uncertain of what to do. I certainly adore Fluttershy and cherish her friendship with me, but I also felt she would be a very sweet girlfriend. But I was also afraid of what the rest of Equestria would do if we.....

There was only one pony who could have the answer I needed. I then set a course for Ponyville's library.

As I approached the main area of Sweet Apple Acres, I noticed Applejack leaving the barn. I suppose she had just woken up from her nap and had delivered a few bushels to the barn. I called out, "Hey there, AJ! Just woke up?"

The farm pony turned to face me and opened her mouth to speak, but she froze as she stared at me. "What in tarnation... Where'd ya get that?!"

I glanced at my cape. "Oh, this? Sweetie Belle made it for me. I was told all members of the Cutie Mark Crusaders get one."

Applejack laughed wholeheartedly at my response. "Member?! Aren't you a little old for bein' part of a kids' gang?!"

I blushed at Applejack's remark. "Well... I'm a special case. I don't have a cutie mark, so they insisted that I join. Although I doubt I'll ever get one..."

The farm pony managed to stop herself from laughing any further. "Heheh... Well, that's all fine and dandy ta me. Might do the fillies some good to have a man in their ranks."

I chuckled, knowing full well that I am the only male member of the Cutie Mark Crusaders at this time. "Yeah, I'm surprised all the other members are girls. You'd think that there would be a few colts mixed in."

Applejack grinned while letting out a brief chuckle. "You got a point there, pardner. But in any case, I need ta get back to applebuckin'. See y'all later!" I waved goodbye while Applejack hauled a pair of empty bushels out into the forest of apple trees.

As I headed back into Ponyville, I noticed that quite a few ponies were staring in my direction. More than likely 'admiring' my new cape. However, I hardly paid them any mind while I shuffled about while thinking to myself. A part of me was still telling me that I should go with Fluttershy. To escalate our bond. Yet at the same time, another part of my mind was holding me back. Afraid that her timid nature would reject me. But more than anything, we were vastly different. Would such a relationship even work?

I eventually passed by the library. Looking at it, a feeling of hope built up inside me. Twilight Sparkle is a very knowledgeable sort and could surely provide me with sound advice. Hoping she could help put my fears to rest, I walked inside. But not before peeking through the nearest window and making certain Spike was not about to slam the front door into me again.

Much to my surprise, I found that Spike was nowhere to be seen. On the other side of the first floor was Twilight with her back turned. She seemed to be reading a book that was resting on a podium. I then stepped inside and asked, "Excuse me, Twilight... Do you have a moment?"

The unicorn looked over her shoulder at me and smiled. "Oh, hello! Good afternoon, James!" As she approached me, she grinned brightly. "I saw the bracelet you got for Rarity. Very nice choice in jewelry. She's been showing it off to everypony today."

I chuckled shyly; surprised that my landlord would show off a gift from me to anyone she met. "I didn't think it would be that big a deal. But seriously, I came here to ask you for some advice." I took a seat on a stool while Twilight followed me. "I...need some advice regarding.....romance."

It seemed that my request surprised Twilight, since she seemed mildly shocked. "Romance...? Well...I can't say I'm an expert on that subject... But I'll do anything I can to help. What exactly do you need to know?" My friend took a seat before me, waiting for my question.

I took a moment to find the right words. "Well... How do I put this... Do you think it's possible for a human and a pony to develop a true lasting bond? Even though they are vastly different? And even if they can, would the rest of Equestria respect that bond?"

Twilight seemed to take a moment to think over her response. "Um... Well, love is a difficult thing to describe. It's not really something you can learn about from research. But...in my honest opinion...I do think that such a bond is possible. As for the rest of Equestria... I don't think that needs explaining. We've already accepted you as a resident here. I'm sure other ponies would respect it if you fell in love with a pony."

Twilight's words helped soothe some of my worries. But I still had a few questions left to ask. "OK... Next question... If such a bond was formed..." I began to sweat as my body temperature spiked, the thought entering my mind.

"What's wrong? You can ask me. I don't mind giving advice." Twilight asked, apparently noticing my distress.

With some hesitation, I muttered, "This is a difficult question to ask... But do you think...a human and a pony could..." I covered my face with one hand as I spoke quietly, "Re...reproduce..."

When Twilight did not offer an immediate reply, I peeked between my fingers. Her face was frozen in surprise, a very deep blush on her face. Eventually, she muttered, "You mean.....having children together? Starting a family?" I am not sure why, but I am certain I heard a hint of excitement in her voice. In any case, I nodded. She then replied, "Well... I honestly don't know about that. Humans and ponies can certainly bond, but I don't know if their genetic code would be compatible. I mean...we both have the same level of intellect, but as for the rest..." She then let out a long sigh. "I'm sorry... I can't really answer that question. There has never been an attempt like that, so no information has ever been recorded that could explain this..."

I sighed in disappointment, not really surprised that even Twilight could not answer my question. "It's OK, Twi... I wasn't expecting a real answer. Humans have never existed in Equestria before me, so I'm not surprised at all."

Before I could stand up, I noticed that Twilight was blushing once more. "James... May I ask you something?"

There was a nagging feeling in my gut telling me to be cautious as I nodded. Twilight then asked, "Um... Why were you curious about those subjects in the first place? Is there...somepony you like?"

As I stated earlier, I had developed an attraction towards Fluttershy. So I would be lying if I denied that I did. "Well... They were only hypothetical questions I've had on my mind for a while."

The unicorn nodded with a satisfied smile. "All right then. If you have anymore questions on your mind, I'd be glad to provide you with advice. Oh, and one more thing?" She blushed slightly while she spoke after a brief delay, "Don't worry too much about bonding with ponies, James. Who knows? Somepony right here in Ponyville just might have their eyes on you."

I saw the wisdom in Twilight's words. There was no sense in worrying about developing a romantic bond with someone. Such things only occur gradually over time and should not be rushed. I could only be patient and wait for the time to arrive. "Thank you, Twilight. I'll be sure and stop by if I need advice about something."

I said my goodbyes and headed out the front door. But before I could close the door, I heard Twilight say, "And one last thing. Nice cape." All I could do was chuckle lightly as I closed the door behind me.

I immediately headed towards the spa to check on Rarity and Fluttershy. Along the way, quite a few ponies continued to gawk and stare at me. The only explanation I could think of was my cape. (What's next? They gonna expect me to go airborne and fly?) I thought to myself, starting to become more annoyed than nervous from the unwanted attention.

Before I could reach the town square, I noticed a shadow pass over me. When I glanced up, I saw the soaring form of Rainbow Dash curving back towards me. She swooped down before me and landed with a clop. "What's up, James?" Before I could reply, she noticed my cape. "Whoa, love the cape! Makes ya look pretty heroic!"

I smiled awkwardly while glancing at the cape on my back. "I guess so... Sweetie Belle made it for me." I had stopped paying attention to the ponies who were staring now that I was in the company of a familiar face.

Rainbow Dash walked behind me to examine the cape up close. "Isn't that the Cutie Mark Crusaders' emblem? Did they actually let you join?"

With a snicker, I explained, "They kinda talked me into it. Since I don't have a cutie mark, they said I was eligible to be recruited. Although it was really Scootaloo who convinced me to join."

The pegasus let out a laugh. "Man, Scootaloo sure does seem to like you after what you did to Diamond Tiara on the playground and at the park! I wonder what she's gonna tell me next time I see her?"

At the mention of Rainbow Dash knowing Scootaloo personally, I took a closer look at my friend. Her mane and tail's styling was somewhat reminiscent of Scootaloo's, even though the coloration was completely different. "Rainbow Dash, I need to ask you something. Is Scootaloo your sister?"

I was not expecting Rainbow's reaction. She laughed loudly, "You're not the first to guess that!" I then waited for her to catch her breath before she could continue. "Phew... Man, that always cracks me up. But seriously, no. Scootaloo isn't related to me at all. She's just kinda... How do I say this... She just looks up to me. Ya know, like a role model! So we hang out every now and then."

I crossed my arms as I replied, "Hero worship, huh? Can't say I blame her. You two have a lot in common, it seems."

"Yep, you can say that again. I can't wait for her wings to grow so we can go flying together. But in any case, whatcha up to today?" Rainbow Dash asked while she hovered before me.

"Well, I was on my way over to the spa to check up on Fluttershy and Rarity. Gummy got into the hot tub and gave Rarity a good scare, so I just want to see if she's feeling better by now." I explained, still wondering if Rarity was truly fine after that incident and if Fluttershy had been hurt either.

Rainbow Dash snickered in response, "Gators in the tub again, huh? I'm glad I never have to worry about that." She then asked, "I'm gonna go check on Scootaloo. Do you know where she might be?"

I replied after taking a moment to think of their current location, "If memory serves, she and the other crusaders are going to try their hands...er...hooves at being produce merchants. They'll probably be set up in the market soon."

The pegasus nodded before asking, "Thanks for the tip. Oh, and would you like to meet me at the café for lunch in an hour? It'll be on me."

Remembering what had happened the previous day during my lunch break, I gave her a stern glare. "Under the condition that you do not pull any pranks on me, sure."

Rainbow Dash gulped while seeming rather nervous. "You don't forget stuff like that, huh? I know you were mad about that. And I promised to never prank you again. Don't worry. But anyway, see ya there, James!" I watched as the pegasus took off at her trademark speed, making me wonder if she is capable of breaking the sound barrier.

I entered the spa as soon as I returned to the town square. Seated at the desk was the same cyan and pink pony I had met before. She seemed to remember me since she asked, "Oh, welcome back, sir. Can I help you?"

I replied promptly while removing my cape and hanging it on a hat rack nearby. "I'm here to see Miss Rarity and Miss Fluttershy. Have they left yet?" I was hoping that I had not missed them after returning Gummy to Pinkie Pie.

"Oh no, not yet. They are currently getting the facial treatment and a horn filing. Right this way." I then followed the pony into the main chamber. Along the way, I saw that her cutie mark was a blooming lotus flower with a pinkish hue to the petals. She then led me over to a pair of risen platforms where Rarity and Fluttershy were relaxing while another pony was using a file on the unicorn's horn. She had the same eyes as my escort, but the rest of her colors were swapped with hers. Where my escort had a cyan coat and a pink mane and tail, the one who was tending to Rarity had a pink coat and a cyan mane and tail. Her cutie mark was identical too, being a blooming lotus flower. However, it had a faint bluish hue to it as opposed to pink. Since their eyes, bodies, hairstyles, and clothing were identical to each other's, I assumed that the two 'spa ponies' are twin sisters.

I was about to speak up, but paused when I saw Rarity's face. It had been covered with a thick pale green goop while two cucumber slices were placed over her eyes. I was literally at a loss for words as I could only stare at the bizarre state of her face. My escort spoke, "Miss Rarity, Miss Fluttershy, this gentleman wishes to see you."

My landlord replied, her mouth's movements unaffected by the goopy mask she was wearing. "Ah yes, Hoity Toity. I have not forgotten our appointment today, but you are a few hours early. Can we rendezvous at 3 PM as scheduled?"

I had no knowledge of who this 'Hoity Toity' fellow could be, but I replied regardless. "Actually...it's me, Rarity." Fluttershy let out a giggle at the case of mistaken identity.

"J-James?! Oh dear, I'm sorry! I could not see you through these slices!" Rarity gasped as she realized that she had mistook me for someone else.

"It's OK, Rarity. I didn't think you could see me through those pickles anyway." I replied with a suppressed chuckle.

"Pickles?! I thought these were fresh cucumber slices! Aloe, please replace these with cucumber slices!" Rarity pleaded while waving her hoof at nothing in particular. I shook my head, not expecting her to take what I said literally.

The pink spa pony spoke through the file she grasped in her teeth, "Miss Rarity, those ARE fresh cucumber slices. We never use pickled cucumbers." Her voice had the same accent I had heard from the other pony.

"Really...? Oh... Never mind then..." Rarity sighed in a defeated tone, probably blushing under the cream on her face.

While Rarity remained quiet for the duration of her...hornicure or whatever you call the trimming of a unicorn's horn, I noticed that Fluttershy only had two spots of the green goop on her face right under the eyes. She also did not have any pillows under her forelegs while Rarity had two. Judging by the expression of her face, she seemed rather disappointed by the lesser treatment. I turned to the pony who had escorted me in and asked, "Excuse me, Miss...um..."

The spa pony smiled while she spoke, "Lotus, sir. I am Lotus and my sister is Aloe."

I nodded and continued, "OK. Miss Lotus, would you mind applying more of that facial cream to Fluttershy's face? The amount you've used so far seems.....inadequate."

Lotus looked over at Fluttershy for a brief second before speaking, "Oh, I see. So sorry, Miss Fluttershy. I will get to you right away." While she went over to a cabinet to fetch the cream, I slid a pair of pillows under Fluttershy's forelegs.

Fluttershy whispered while smiling at me, "Thank you, James. I almost never get the full treatment since they tend to focus on Rarity more than me."

I attempted to stroke her mane, but found that it was wrapped up in a towel. "No problem, Fluttershy. They shouldn't skimp on quality for someone as beautiful as you."

My words seemed to unnerve Fluttershy somewhat since she let out an adorable squeak while a very deep blush shone through her yellow coat. She stared at me constantly until Lotus returned and covered her face in the pale green cream. She did not look away until Lotus placed two cucumber slices over her eyes. "Um... Sorry?"

As Aloe continued to file away at Rarity's horn, I took a seat between Fluttershy and my landlord. I then noticed Rarity was still wearing the bracelet I had purchased for her the previous day. "I hear you've been showing that off to just about everyone today." I spoke while I patted her on the back. She was clad in a white bathrobe with golden yellow frills around the collar, cuffs, and bottom. Fluttershy was wearing the same thing with the only difference being that the frills were purple.

Rarity giggled despite being unable to see me at the time. "Oh, how could I not? This is a most darling gift you got for me. I only take it off to bathe so I don't tarnish its brilliance." I could hear Lotus and Fluttershy giggling behind me, making me uneasy. However, I think I heard Fluttershy let out a sigh.

While we chatted, I felt very relaxed in the presence of Fluttershy. A feeling of peace came over me that I had felt when she came to my aid when I took shelter in Sugarcube Corner after Rainbow Dash had fallen on me when I first arrived in Ponyville. She is just so precious. I did not see how it would be possible for anyone to dislike her. As I looked at her, I felt a desire to be with her. And more than anything, I wanted to protect her from anyone who would try to take advantage of her. If there is an angel in Ponyville, it is she.

After several minutes of chatting, Aloe set the file down. Rarity's horn was perfectly smooth with not the slightest hint of uneven surfaces on it. Rarity then asked, "Is Quake here? I'm ready for my massage."

Aloe replied with a slight frown, "Oh, I'm afraid she is currently on vacation. She won't be back for a few more days."

Rather than being disappointed, Rarity sounded rather thoughtful at the revelation. "Is that so? Hmmm..." She then smiled while looking in my general direction. "James, would you be so kind as to be my masseuse today?"

I was not expecting her request at all. Even Aloe seemed shocked by it. "Miss Rarity, he is not trained to be..."

Rarity then proceeded to interrupt the spa pony. "Oh, my intuition tells me that he is qualified for the job."

Even though Rarity had faith in me, I had no professional experience in giving massages. Granted I have given a few amateur ones to elders in my family, but I digress. "I don't think I'll be able to satisfy you, Rarity... I have no real experience in the field."

My words did nothing to discourage my landlord since she then pleaded, "Please?"

I glanced over my shoulder and saw that even Lotus and Fluttershy were looking in our direction. I could not make out Fluttershy's expression under the facial cream, but I am sure she was intrigued. "Um... I really don't think that's a good idea... I might do more harm than good." I explained again in the hopes of getting her to back down.

"Please, James? For me?" Rarity once again pleaded, sounding all the more insistent.

Before I could refuse again, Rarity asked, "Aloe, I think now would be a good time to remove this cream." The pink spa pony nodded and fetched a warm wet towel and began to rub her client's face with it.

"Sorry, Rarity. I'd like to, but I don't think I..." I stopped short of what I was going to say as Rarity's unobstructed face smiled at me.

"Please please please please!" She said quickly while holding her hooves together. Her mouth was curved into a toothy grin as her eyes pleaded with me.

I was utterly baffled by Rarity's insistence that I massage her instead of using the professional skills of the spa sisters. Regardless, that pleading gaze was difficult for me to say no to. "Oh... All right, I'll do it. Just don't complain if I pinch a nerve." I said with a sigh, hoping I would not regret going along with my landlord's wishes.

"Oh, don't be so modest! I'm sure those delicate flexible fingers of yours will do the job just fine." Rarity said while she stood up and led me over to a few massage tables that were right next to the hot tub.

"I'll be able to do a better job if you remove your robe, Rarity." I said, knowing the fabric would absorb some of the pressure.

"Oh, of course. Wouldn't want to miss anything, would we?" Rarity replied with an excited giggle as her horn was covered in a billowing aura. She stood on her hind legs while she 'pulled' her bathrobe off over her head. She then removed the towel that covered her mane and shook her head a few times. Her mane fell back into place, almost completely dry. Even the elegant curls were intact. I watched as my landlord climbed atop one of the tables and rested her head on the raised end where a few pillows sat. "I'm ready, darling." She spoke to me while giving me an unnervingly inviting gaze.

I pondered what would be the best way to massage the delicate pony. I normally have the easiest time from behind, but a pony's posture is different from a human's. "Don't move, Rarity. I need to try something." I climbed onto the table and straddled her on my knees, being careful to not apply any weight to her.

"Do whatever you have to, James. I'm certain you'll do just fine." Rarity replied, her forelegs stretched out for easy access.

I hesitated for a moment, as I had no knowledge of a pony's anatomy. Where should I start? What spots needed attention? Unsure of what was the best choice, I decided that I should focus on the joints. I placed both hands on the base of Rarity's neck and began to knead it as firmly as possible without being too harsh. I dug my fingers into her silky smooth white coat, amazed by how silken it felt at the touch.

"Mmmm... This is a new sensation..." I heard Rarity mutter with a sigh. There was a small clock on the wall nearby. I glanced at it every now and then to keep track of how long I was tending to one spot. Once three minutes had passed, I reached forward and began to massage Rarity's cheekbones.

I heard Rarity gasp lightly at my touch, probably because she had never received a massage on her face. "My jaw joints? I never thought it was possible to reach that spot."

"I guess not. At least when you have hooves." I replied while kneading her flesh and muscles as tenderly as possible. I heard Rarity giggle in response.

Once another three minutes had passed, I moved back down to Rarity's shoulders. As I applied pressure to them, she let out a sigh. "Now that's the spot that needs it most. Could you focus on those a little longer this time?"

I glanced back over to the clock before replying, "Sure thing, Rarity." I decided to go for five minutes on the shoulders instead of three. They felt particularly tense, possibly having something to do with her profession and having to constantly use just her forelegs to work a sewing machine. It must put a fair amount of strain on her shoulders due to having to prop herself up with them. I made certain to apply extra pressure on them. Every now and then, I would feel Rarity shiver harshly.

"Is that long enough?" I asked once five minutes had passed.

"Oh, much better. Thank you, darling." Rarity replied with a groan of release while she slightly flexed her shoulders. I then moved down to her knees. It was a fairly long reach, but I had little trouble. I made certain to get both sides. Once another three minutes had passed, I climbed down from the table and began to knead the center of her back. Her vertebrae were quite strong and the muscle around it was very firm, which I suppose I should have expected from an equine.

I spent a good five minutes on Rarity's vertebrae due to its length. Once finished, I straddled her once again. Only this time I was facing the opposite direction so I could reach her flanks and hind legs. I started on her flanks first, my hands gripping each one firmly. But I heard her loudly gasp and shudder under me when my fingertips dug into her cutie marks. "Ooh...! What... What are you doing?!"

Rarity's sudden outburst startled me, prompting me to release my grip on her immediately. "I was just starting on your flanks. Did I do something wrong?"

I watched while Rarity looked back at me. A faint blush was on her face as she watched my every move. "I... I don't know. I've never felt such a thing before. What did you touch?" I reached out and poked one of her cutie marks, prompting another gasp from the unicorn. "Oh...my..."

Worried that I may have hit a pressure point, I asked, "Does it hurt?"

Rarity's response puzzled me greatly. "No, there was no pain.... It's just... Please refrain from touching that spot unless I request it. Which I doubt I will. All right, dear?" I raised an eyebrow at her request. Unless she requested it? Was it a ticklish spot? Regardless, I agreed and started massaging her flanks again while taking care to not touch her cutie marks.

Once I had finished with her flanks, all that remained were her hind knees. As I started on them, Rarity sighed, "James, you truly are a natural at this... I've never had a massage that balances firmness with gentleness so well."

I replied while I kneaded the flesh around her knees, "Really? I have hardly any experience. Am I really that good?"

Rarity giggled softly in response. "More than good. You are simply marvelous." I think I may have blushed at her compliment.

Once I climbed down from the table, Rarity stood up and stretched. "Mmmmm! Such relief! I can't remember the last time I felt this limber!"

I took a step back as she hopped down from the table. "James, that was a most fabulous massage debut. You really should consider working here. I'm certain many ponies will come around to feel your magic touch." I snickered in embarrassment, flattered by her praise.

Before I could do anything else, Fluttershy walked over to the massage tables. The facial cream had been removed from her face while her hair had been let down. She smiled shyly and asked, "I overheard Rarity's praise for you, James. If it's not too much trouble, could you give me a massage too? Um... If that's all right with you, that is..."

I smiled warmly at Fluttershy's timidity and modesty. "It would be my pleasure, Fluttershy. Remove your robe and we'll get started."

Fluttershy grinned widely before she slid out of her bathrobe and hopped up onto the massage table. Rarity levitated both robes with her magic and smiled at us. "I'll take care of your robe, Fluttershy. Now, I must be getting back to Carousel Boutique. I have a few appointments that begin soon. Same time next week, dear?"

The timid pegasus looked over at my landlord and nodded with a grin on her face. "Definitely. Take care, Rarity." I waved goodbye with her as Rarity moved out of sight.

I climbed onto the table and straddled Fluttershy the same way I had positioned myself above Rarity. "Just relax, Fluttershy." Like before, I started on her neck before moving to her cheeks. Fluttershy did not seem to be accustomed to others touching her face since she winced slightly at my touch. "I'm just being thorough, Fluttershy. Don't panic." I spoke softly, trying to keep her calm. It was a struggle for me to resist the urge to be more affectionate to her.

"I... I know. I trust you, James..." She replied with a whisper. I felt her relax again as I started on her shoulders. But once I had climbed down from the table and started on her back, I took note of Fluttershy's folded wings.

"Fluttershy, would you like me to do your wings next?" I asked, wondering what a pegasus' wings felt like.

She replied while glancing at her right wing, "Oh... That sounds lovely. Go right ahead, please."

Once I finished massaging her back, I spoke, "OK. Right wing, please." She responded by extending her right wing only. I felt along the top of the wing, feeling the bone structure under the skin. There were two joints in all. I started on the one closest to the body, being very careful to not apply much pressure since I suspected the bones in Fluttershy's wings are hollow and fragile.

"You don't have to hold back, James. Pegasus wing bones are much denser than bird bones. They don't break easily." Fluttershy spoke up, likely detecting the lack of firmness in my kneading. I took her words to heart and began to apply the same amount of firmness as before. I heard Fluttershy let out a sigh as she muttered, "Rarity is right... You really are amazing at this."

Once I had finished with both joints, I walked over to the other side of the table. "OK. Left wing now, please." Fluttershy responded by folding her right wing while extending her left. I started by kneading the joint closest to the body for three minutes before moving onto the next. Once the left wing had been tended to, I climbed atop the table and straddled Fluttershy again while facing her rear. I was certain that Fluttershy's cutie marks were not as sensitive as Rarity's. It would be highly unlikely that two ponies have the same ticklish spot.....right?

My guess proved false since Fluttershy let out a suppressed gasp when my fingertips dug into her flanks. "J-J-James...! N-not there!" Fluttershy squeaked as I kneaded her flanks and the cutie marks on them.

I released my grip at once. "What's wrong? Did it hurt? Are you ticklish there?" I asked, fearful that I may have hurt her in some way.

Fluttershy looked over her shoulder at me, her face flushed red with the deepest blush I had ever seen on her. "N-no, it doesn't hurt. And I'm not ticklish there... It's just a... Um...I'm not comfortable saying it out loud..."

Judging by her hesitation and the blush on her face, I began to fear that the cutie marks of some ponies are sensitive enough to function as a pleasure point. I began to feel my body temperature spike as I began to sweat. "Oh man... So sorry, Fluttershy..." I then went back to massaging her flanks, weaving my fingers around her butterfly cutie marks without letting a single word escape my lips for the rest of the massage. After that incident, I was very certain that Fluttershy would never accept me for a potential boyfriend. I even felt disappointed in myself that I had offended her in front of the spa sisters.

Once I had finished with her flanks and hind knees, I climbed down from the table. "I think I got everything..." When Fluttershy stood up and turned to face me, I froze as she gazed at me with an uneasy expression. "Did I...make any mistakes?"

To my surprise, Fluttershy smiled at me. "Not at all. Rarity was right. That was the most delicate and soothing massage I've ever had. You really have skill at this." I think I blushed when she reached out to me with her head and nuzzled my face. "Thank you again, James. You're sweet."

I saw Fluttershy out the front door. "See you again in an hour or two." I said while I waved goodbye. Now alone with just the spa sisters, I turned to find Lotus seated at the front desk again. "Excuse me, Miss Lotus. Are you hiring?"

The spa pony replied with a wide grin. "Oh, I was hoping you would say that. Aloe and I saw everything. Your fingers have the kind of precision and tenderness that our hooves do not. What would be the best days for you to work here?"

Since I already have a job at Sugarcube Corner, I had to think up a way to balance two jobs. "Well... How do Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Saturdays sound?" I asked, hoping I could work out a deal with the Cake couple to work Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays.

"That would do nicely. Just fill out this application and we will see you on Tuesday, Mr. James." Lotus said in her strong accent. She then gave me a job application that was surprisingly simple in comparison to those used by American businesses. There were only a few things to fill out. I signed my name at the end, handed the sheet back to Lotus, and then retrieved my cape from the corner of the room before heading on my way to get some lunch.

I went straight to the local café as promised, hoping to find Rainbow Dash waiting for me. For the first time, my dining partner had beaten me to the location as I saw her looking through a menu. I approached her and took a seat at the opposite end of the table after borrowing a small stool from nearby. "Let me guess. You got from the market to this table in ten seconds flat?" I asked while trying to be witty to the athletic mare.

Rainbow Dash looked over her menu and smiled at me. "Hey there, James! And you're right! Ten. Seconds. Flat." The two of us chuckled in unison. Is that a catch phrase of hers?

"So, how were the crusaders doing? Any sales?" I asked, wondering if they had made any progress in the activity I had suggested that day.

"Ya know, they surprised me! They're actually doing pretty well! They had only just set up shop when I got there. But they started making sales in only a few minutes. I guess having such a wide variety of stuff really does catch customers' eyes." Rainbow Dash replied while showing a grin.

"I guess my suggestion paid off." I spoke softly while I adjusted the cape around my neck. I had almost forgotten I was wearing it.

After a moment, Rainbow Dash closed her menu after having apparently decided on what to order. She then looked at me and spoke, "Scootaloo wouldn't stop talking about you. Even said you're like a brother to her. You two hit it off or what?"

I blushed at her remark and replied, "She told you, huh? Well...yeah. She even started calling me 'big brother' today for some reason. Can't say I'm not flattered though."

Rainbow Dash snickered briefly before she spoke up. "She told me about how cool you were when you stole Diamond Tiara's cutie mark. And how you made her look like a joke in the park yesterday. I never knew you could be tough too."

I did not think too highly of my actions and replied bluntly, "I was not being tough. I was just giving a pathetic bully what she deserved. That's all there was to it. Nothing more."

Despite my claims, Rainbow Dash smirked at me. "Yeah, I hear ya. But that still sounds like you were being tough when you needed to be. And you remember what I said about dating you if you were a bit more assertive, right?"

I froze while I looked over my menu at Rainbow Dash. She was giving me a sly smirk, making me sweat as I felt myself becoming extremely nervous. However, she suddenly burst into laughter. "Bwahaha! Gotcha! Sorry, I just had to do that. It was worth it to see the look on your face."

Despite Rainbow's attempt at humor, I was not amused. I glared at her for a moment before looking through the menu again. "Good thing you were kidding. I have my eye on someone else anyway."

Rainbow Dash stopped snickering abruptly. She gazed at me with an expression that seemed to have 'Wait... Seriously?' written all over it. All I could do was nod.

"So... You actually have feelings for somepony? And that's a pony and not a human?" Rainbow Dash asked, clearly interested in the unlikely idea of a human developing feelings for a pony.

I sighed before I explained, "Yeah... Only problem is I know it won't work out... She's too shy and would probably turn me down... What's more, I think I offended her today at the spa. So we can only just be friends."

Rainbow Dash inched over to my side of the table and glanced around for a second. "Can you tell me who she is? I promise I'll keep it a secret. Cross my heart, hope to fly, stick a cupcake in my eye."

I glanced at Rainbow Dash and asked, "Stick a...CUPCAKE in your eye?"

Rainbow shrugged her shoulders before replying, "Pinkie Pie came up with it. But you know what I mean. So, can you tell me?"

After a moment of hesitation, I lowered my head and muttered, "Fl...Fluttershy..."

Rainbow Dash stared at me with a look of silent shock for a moment. "Whoa... Fluttershy? Really?" I nodded silently, somewhat embarrassed from revealing my crush to her. She then asked, "Um... I don't want to sound like I think that's a bad idea, but what do you see in her exactly? She never seemed like the kind of pony who's looking for a sweetheart. To me, at least."

I sighed and looked away. "I'm not sure if I can explain this very well... I guess it started just after I came to Ponyville when you crashed onto me."

The rainbow-maned pegasus mare winced as she recalled that day. "Oh... Sorry about that. I really didn't mean to fall on you... But anyway, what happened?"

I went on while still browsing my menu. "She was very supportive in my time of need... I think she was my very first friend in Ponyville... Heck, maybe even in Equestria as a whole."

Rainbow Dash smiled in understanding. "Ya know, she normally has a very hard time opening up to ponies.....I mean people she's not familiar with. Did she really not have any trouble opening up to you?"

That sounded just like Fluttershy to me since she had even confessed to me that she is wary around ponies she does not trust or know well. And yet, she came right over to me with little hesitation. "No... She walked over to me and took a seat at my side. But maybe the reason she wasn't that nervous was because I'm not a pony... And that I was far too distressed to really pay any mind to her..." I explained, knowing that she had never met a human before, let alone be hurt by one.

Rainbow Dash nodded before replying. "Yeah, I see whatcha mean. First impressions are really important to Fluttershy." She then placed an elbow on the table and asked, "So, it started there? Like she was your first friend in Ponyville? What else draws you to her?"

Her question was not easy for me to answer. But I tried. "I... When... I'll put it like this. Whenever I think of her, I feel...a warm tingly feeling inside me... She's so sweet, yet so beautiful. I don't think I've ever met a girl as sweet as her in my life. Even before I ended up in Equestria..... Sorry. That's the best I can describe myself."

I looked over at Rainbow Dash, who was looking back at me. She then muttered, "Well... I'm no expert in this kinda thing... I've never had a crush in my life, so I can't relate. But...I know Fluttershy really likes you. I mean, she likes all of her friends, but she really likes you for sure. I guess what I'm saying is to just be careful to not rush it. And another thing..." She placed a hoof on my shoulder before speaking uncharacteristically softly, "She could really use somepony like you. Someone who can always be there to support her."

I could see the wisdom in Rainbow's words, which is weird coming from a jock like her. Fluttershy had told me she had always been wary of ponies she is not familiar with. This led me to believe she has been bullied in the past. Rather than feel pity for the timid pegasus, I felt my desire to support her increase as I felt the urge to help soothe the pain she had endured in her earlier years. "I will, Rainbow... I won't ever leave her."

My friend patted me on the back. "Awesome. Don't forget those words, OK? She needs you." The two of us shared a hug before she moved back over to her side of the table just as the waiter arrived.

"Welcome back, sir. Have you made your decision?" The waiter asked, apparently having come to recognize me.

"Yes, I will have the house salad with French dressing and an order of spaghetti and...meat...balls?" I could hardly believe that there was actual meat on a menu in a town of herbivorous ponies.

The waiter turned to Rainbow Dash, who spoke, "I'll go for the sub. Extra tomatoes." The waiter nodded and walked back inside the café.

"Rainbow... Are the meatballs in the pasta made of REAL meat?" I asked, wondering if Equestrian ponies are actually omnivores.

The pegasus snickered at my apparent bewilderment. "Nah. It's not real meat. Just fake meat made of soy bean stuff." I chuckled for a second, having completely forgotten about the likes of tofu hotdogs and veggie burgers.

It did not take long for our orders to arrive. The meatballs in my spaghetti appeared to be made out of actual meat and probably tasted the part too, but I was certain they were not what they seemed. A layer of tomato sauce covered the whole dish. Rainbow Dash's order was a long submarine sandwich with various vegetables clamped between the slices of bread. "Aw yeah, let's chow down."

I watched while Rainbow Dash planted her hooves at the sides of the sandwich and lifted it before taking a bite. Not wanting to be left out, I started on my food. The tomato sauce was zesty and had just a hint of spiciness to it.

Not surprisingly, Rainbow Dash finished her meal first. "Mmm. Good stuff. You almost done, James?" I had finished my salad and was halfway done with my entrée.

"I should be another minute or two. And sorry that I can't finish all this in ten seconds flat." I replied, not wanting to scarf down my food. Rainbow Dash could only snicker at the reference I made to her speed record.

Once we had finished, Rainbow Dash flew away suddenly and returned less than a minute later with a stack of bits in her mouth. Once she set them down on the table, she turned to me and explained, "As promised, I'll handle the bill." I nodded, but then reached into my pocket and pulled out a few bits of my own.

"A tip for the waiter." I explained while I set the money down.

Rainbow Dash began to hover while I put the stool I was sitting on back where I found it. "I'm gonna go check on Scootaloo and the other crusaders. Say hi to Fluttershy for me!" I waved goodbye as the pegasus took to the sky and flew south. Remembering what I had promised to do, I started to head west towards Fluttershy's cottage.

When I began to press into the meadow that bordered Fluttershy's home, I noticed an unusually high number of rabbits milling about. There were various hues of white, black, brown, gray, and the like. They would often watch me as I passed by, probably because they had never seen a human before. "I guess it's rabbit season. Or is it duck season?" I could not help muttering out loud.

When Fluttershy's cottage came into view, I found the timid pegasus resting upon the bridge that crossed the creek in front of her house. Once she saw me coming, Fluttershy stood up trotted right over to me. "Hello again, James. You're right on time. And thanks again for that wonderful massage today."

I stroked Fluttershy's mane with a smile while replying, "Next time you come in, try to make it a Tuesday, Thursday, or Saturday. Those are the days I work there now."

Fluttershy smiled softly and nodded. "I'm glad to hear that. Next time Rarity and I meet up at the spa, I'll ask for you by name. But now that you're here, shall we get started?" I followed Fluttershy a short distance away from her home, finding many of the same rabbits I had seen on my way in still milling about.

"Fluttershy... Are all of these rabbits just babies?" I asked, finding their close proximity to be making me mildly giddy.

"Oh yes. These are the baby bunnies I need help rounding up. But remember, they're a timid bunch and need to be handled gently." She replied with her soft voice.

I have caught wild baby rabbits before with just my hands without being forceful, so I have experience in handling young rabbits. Only this time, it seemed that they would not have any fear of me. "OK then. Where should I set them as I gather them up?"

Fluttershy pointed towards a partially fenced-in area that was bordered by a very low white wooden fence. "Just place them over there. I'll keep them from wandering off."

Eager to get started, I calmly approached a trio of grazing baby rabbits and got down on one knee. They looked at me when I drew near, their big adorable eyes showing curiosity instead of wariness. "Hello there, little guys." I spoke softly while slowly outstretching my hand. I ran one finger between one rabbit's ears. That area seemed to be a soft spot since the baby bunny immediately warmed up to me by nuzzling my finger. The other two also drew closer.

"OK, little fellas. Just hold still." I spoke before I carefully scooped them up in my arms. The rabbits seemed very calm in my grasp as they nuzzled my chest. This was one such experience I would never forget and hopefully would not be the last.

"Very good, James. Just set them down right here." Fluttershy tapped her hoof in one spot as I approached her with the bunnies in my arms. I carefully released them from my grasp as low to the ground as I could get. I petted each bunny on the head to reassure them before going off to find some more.

I repeated the same process over and over for the next thirty minutes at least. But I never got bored. In fact, I cherished every minute with the baby bunnies. After making one last trip to the bundle of bunnies I had rounded up, I made a quick sweep of the area to see if I had overlooked anyone. When I found that no baby bunnies had been left behind, I returned to Fluttershy. "I think that's everyone."

Fluttershy nodded with a pleased grin. "Thank you again, James. Will you do the honors?" I smiled and gazed down at the many baby bunnies at my feet. I silently counted them while Fluttershy did everything she could to keep them from moving.

"Whoa... Sixty bunnies. That's quite a few." I spoke out loud as I finished counting them in my head.

"Sixty? Wow... We seldom have that many in one season." Fluttershy remarked while the bunnies looked up at us. But when I looked down at them, a thought popped into my head.

"Fluttershy, could you keep them all together for a bit longer? I'd like to get a picture of this." I asked before I pulled my DSi game system out of my pocket and turned it on.

"James, what is that? I've never seen anything like it." Fluttershy asked me while trying to not get too excited.

"It's a camera. Well, it's more than just a camera, but I'm using it as a camera for now." I replied as I activated the camera feature. I got down on one knee while adjusting the top half of the DSi to get the best angle.

"If you're going to take a picture, make sure the flash is turned off. It might scare them... Oh? Hello, Angel." Fluttershy spoke before apparently being distracted by something. In actuality, the DSi's camera does not have a flash function. But at the mention of Angel, I looked behind me to find the same white rabbit I had seen resting in the 'dog' house next to Fluttershy's cottage.

Before I could say anything, Fluttershy gasped lightly. "Oh, I know! Angel, could you take the picture so James could be in the shot too?" As ridiculous as it sounded, the rabbit nodded his head in agreement. I froze for a moment as I tried to comprehend how a rabbit could use such a complex gadget. I was also hesitant to let someone other than myself use my DSi, but it was the only way I could be in the picture too.

When Angel came over to me, I set the DSi down and adjusted the top half, as well as the camera lens on it, so that it was standing up on a ninety-degree angle. "Thanks, Angel. Just press this button here to take the picture when we're ready. And watch the top screen to see how we look before the picture is taken." I explained, hoping he would understand. I then approached the pile of baby bunnies and got down on one knee beside them while Fluttershy stood at the other side. The two of us smiled while Angel seemed to adjust the DSi's location to try and get us all in the shot.

Eventually, I heard a familiar click when Angel pressed the button. I then stood up and went over to see how the picture had turned out. There was no motion blur and the lighting was just right. It also captured us all at just the right angle. For the DSi, it was of the highest quality. "Thank you, Angel." I spoke as I saved the picture and returned the DSi to my pocket. I then scratched Angel between the ears, coaxing a content smile from him.

"May I see the picture before you go?" Fluttershy asked while she approached me, the baby bunnies beginning to wander off behind her. I nodded and pulled the DSi back out, opened the photo album, and brought up the picture before turning the screen to her. "Oh my... That turned out lovely. Now we have something to remember this day by." Fluttershy spoke softly while she observed the photo.

I stood up before I returned my DSi to my pocket. "Thanks again for inviting me to help you with this. Just interacting with baby bunnies is a treat in itself." I smiled while I stroked Fluttershy's mane.

"Hehee... You're very welcome, James. Feel free to stop by if you're ever in the area. You're always welcome here." Fluttershy spoke before we embraced each other gently in a tender cuddle.

A moment passed, as I did not let go of my friend. While we embraced, I ran my fingers through her beautiful flowing pink mane. I heard Fluttershy sigh happily, clearly enjoying my touch. But we both froze when Angel momentarily tapped Fluttershy's leg with one foot. We both looked down to see him giving her a stern gaze.

"Something wrong, Angel?" I asked while I let Fluttershy down.

Fluttershy meekly replied, "Oh, it's nothing important. He just wants a snack." For some reason, the white rabbit glared at her as he tapped her on the leg again several times.

What was this rabbit doing? Was he trying to persuade Fluttershy to say something? Fluttershy then lowered her head down to him and whispered, "I can't tell him, Angel. I want to...but I can't..."

I suspect Fluttershy thought I would not hear her. But I was close enough to hear every word. I then asked, "Tell me what?"

Fluttershy blushed as her head jerked up suddenly. "You... You heard that? Oh dear... Um... Well..." I crossed my arms while looking down at her, puzzled by what it was Angel was trying to get her to say.

After a minute of stammering and incoherent muttering, Fluttershy finally asked, "Um... Well... May I ask you for some advice, James?" She was shyly looking at me from between her long bangs with one eye, a gesture I found utterly adorable.

"Sure thing, Fluttershy. Whatcha need help with?" I replied earnestly. I noticed that Angel had raised his paws and was shaking his head as if to say 'Close enough'.

The timid pegasus blushed while she spoke, "Well... There's this boy... I mean stallion... I mean... There's somepony I really...like... But I don't have the courage to tell him... What would be a good way to...confess my feelings to him?"

I felt immense disappointment upon finding that Fluttershy had already developed feelings for another person... Or rather, another pony. However, in my heart, all I really wanted was for Fluttershy to be happy. Even if it meant being happy without me. And if that meant losing her to someone else, so be it.

I was careful to hide my disappointment as I thought over a response. "You have a crush on someone and are afraid to tell the guy in person? Well... Why not just write him a love letter?"

My suggestion seemed to surprise my friend since she stared blankly at me for a moment. "A love letter...? I'm surprised I didn't think of that earlier..." She then smiled faintly and spoke softly with a very deep blush. "Tha... Thank you, James... That's all I needed. See you later. I have a letter to write." I watched while she trotted up towards her cottage and went inside. I looked down at Angel, who seemed to sigh in disappointment while looking at the ground and shaking his head. With nothing else to do, I said goodbye to Fluttershy's pet and headed back towards Ponyville.

I was fairly tired from all the walking I had done that day and decided to return home. It was late in the afternoon at the time. When I entered the Carousel Boutique through the front door, I found Rarity talking to Twilight Sparkle. "Yeah, what a coincidence. I guess we all got a little messy at the end of the Grand Galloping Gala, didn't we?" Twilight spoke before letting out a chuckle. Near her was a pony mannequin with a dazzling dress draped over it that was mostly shades of blue with many stars embroidered into it. However, it had rips and tears here and there.

"Oh yes, and it certainly wouldn't do for your lovely gown to be in this state when the next Gala arrives! I will make certain it is back to normal within the week." Rarity replied with some enthusiasm. It was then that she noticed me at the door and trotted over to me. "Hello, James! Still looking dashing in that cape. Is there anything I can get you?"

"No thanks. I'm good. Just a bit tired from all the walking around I did today. All I wanna do is relax on the sofa and read some more of that encyclopedia." I replied, remembering that I had borrowed the book from the library.

Twilight approached me with a smile. "Hey there, James. I was just dropping off my dress for some fixing. And I saw your robe. Very impressive. I can't wait to see you in it at the Gala!"

I replied while trying to hide my real mood, "Thanks, Twilight. It was more than I expected too. But come to think of it, where's Spike? I haven't seen him all day."

The purple unicorn giggled while she replied, "Oh, he's been busy with his chores. That's why he wasn't home when you visited today. Although I think he was a little jealous when Rarity showed us that bracelet you bought for her. Probably because he wanted to eat it. I think I even saw him drool a little." I could only chuckle while wondering if he would have been able to digest the silver as well.

Once we said our goodbyes, Twilight headed out for home. But I then turned to Rarity and asked, "Excuse me, Rarity. May I ask you something about Fluttershy?"

My landlord smiled wholeheartedly. "But of course! Since she's my best friend, I'm sure I can answer anything you want to know."

While making certain to hide my emotions, I then asked, "Well... She told me today that there is this guy she has a crush on. Do you know who it is?"

Rarity brought a hoof to her chin and seemed to ponder my words for a few seconds. "Hmmm... Fluttershy has found love? That's odd... She never once mentioned such a thing to me. Are you certain it was not a joke?"

I shook my head before replying, "I think she was serious. She asked me for advice on how to confess to him, so I suggested she write a love letter to him."

At my claim, Rarity nodded with a rather serious expression. "Yes, writing a letter is certainly more like Fluttershy's style. But who is this dashing gent who could've won Fluttershy's heart? I must remember to ask her tomorrow." I nodded in agreement, still feeling an unpleasant bitterness in my heart from being rejected. With nothing else to ask, I went to my room to read some more articles from the encyclopedia I had borrowed from Twilight.

"OK... Next page..." I muttered to myself as I removed the bookmark. "Ponyville..... Founded by earth ponies long ago. Now home to all three species of ponies... Canterlot... Capitol of Equestria... Home of unicorns... Like Ponyville, has become home to all three pony types over time... Cloudsdale... Home of pegasus ponies... Made entirely out of clouds, unicorn and earth ponies cannot reside there..." Each description included illustrations of the locations described in the articles.

The next article contained details on various flora and fauna of Equestria. As it turned out, many animal species that could be found on Earth also resided in Equestria. With a few notable exceptions. The first to be mentioned was the cockatrice, having the body of a snake and the head of a rooster. As I expected, its gaze could turn whoever it looked at into stone. Another was the hydra, but I had already heard of it from the Cutie Mark Crusaders. Next was the manticore, a creature with the body of a lion, a pair of wings, and a scorpion's tail complete with a stinger. Another entry mentioned the Ursa, colossal bear-like creatures with bodies that share the coloration of the night sky dotted with stars. But the last entry on the page puzzled me. "Parasprites...? Tiny and cuddly, but have ravenous appetites... Infestations can lead to catastrophic food shortages..." An illustration was provided, showing me a round insect of sorts with big eyes. Like the article claimed, it seemed to be quite adorable and far from menacing.

By the time I looked up from what I had been reading, it was nearly 8 PM. "Whoa... Time sure flies when wrapped up in a good book." I muttered out loud. Outside the window, I could see that the sun was setting over the horizon. I was still feeling full from lunch, so I decided to skip dinner. But as I looked back at the encyclopedia, I remembered that while it did offer great detail about some of the more colorful creatures of Equestria, it was a bit lacking in other areas of flora and fauna. I decided to head back to the library to borrow another book that may have more information on the subject. As I headed to the front door, I found Rarity 'in the zone', as she likes to say it, while working on repairing Twilight's dress. Rather than interrupt her, I left as quietly as I could.

It got dark out fairly quickly while I walked through Ponyville. I had not been out this late since my first night in Equestria. The cicadas were hissing loudly all around me, lending a familiar atmosphere to the moment. Few ponies were out and about at the time, which was not surprising to me. I was only hoping that Twilight was not asleep yet.

To my relief, I found that there were still lights on inside Twilight's house when I arrived. I peeked in the window and found Twilight tidying up on the first floor. I knocked on the door gently to let her know I was coming in.

Twilight turned to face me as I closed the door behind me. "Good evening, James! I wasn't expecting to see you this late." She spoke while trotting over to me with a smile.

"Well, when I looked up from reading, it was almost 8. I'm sure you can relate." I replied with a shrug of my shoulders. Twilight chuckled heartily since she is an avid reader too. But before I could ask for her help in finding a certain kind of book, there was a thumping sound at the door.

"Another visitor at this hour?" Twilight asked as she used her magic to open the front door from a distance. Once it was open, Angel ran inside with a scroll in his mouth.

"Angel? What're you doing out here?" I asked, puzzled why Fluttershy's pet would come all the way into Ponyville without her. He looked up at me with a gaze that seemed to show irritation. Whether it was to me or someone else, I could not say.

Twilight spoke while pointing with her hoof, "I think that scroll's for you, James. Should I let you read it first?" I nodded in agreement while I took the scroll from the white rabbit. Twilight went back to straightening up the library as I leaned against the wall to read it.

"Let's see here..." I muttered before I opened the scroll. I began to read it silently, but I soon began to sweat as I beheld its contents.

The note read, "To my beloved James. I'm sorry for not telling you this in person, but I can at least express my true feelings to you with this scroll. I have never met anypony like you. Somepony who never judges or shuns others despite their flaws. Whenever I see your face, I feel as if I am standing on a cloud of butterflies. And when I hear your voice, I feel as if I just heard an angel sing. I wish I could tell you just how much I adore you, but words alone can't describe it. It goes beyond just mere friendship. But please believe me when I say this. I love you, James. And I hope you will continue to remain in my life for the rest of our lives. With love, Fluttershy."

I felt somewhat dizzy by the time I finished reading the scroll. Was this for real? Was it a prank? I could hardly even think straight. "Twilight..." I stammered out.

My friend looked over at me before asking, "Something wrong, James? And why is your face red?"

I held out the scroll as she approached me. "Is this...a prank from Pinkie Pie or Rainbow Dash?"

Twilight's horn was engulfed in a billowing aura as the scroll floated over to her. "Let's see... Beloved James.....express my true feelings.... Oh...my..." Twilight said with an unusually loud tone as she blushed deeply. She read in silence for a moment before speaking, "This is...just so poetic! And it's in Fluttershy's handwriting! She didn't hold back when she wrote this!"

I could hardly believe it. The pony I have a crush on is actually in love with me. Or is she? I had my doubts if this love letter was real or forged. But it is far easier to express one's feelings through text than through voice, so I am certain even Fluttershy could get quite expressive in written form.

"If that's really Fluttershy's handwriting..." I muttered lightly. I then looked down at Angel and asked, "Did Fluttershy really write that?" The white rabbit nodded in response. It was real. Fluttershy...was...is in love with me.

Twilight rolled up the scroll and gave it back to me. "Wow... I never knew Fluttershy could be so artistic with love letters... But are you all right?"

I took the scroll in hand and nodded. "Yeah... Just a little dizzy and overheated... It's a lot to take in."

I then looked down at Angel again. "Did Fluttershy ask you to deliver this to me?" To my surprise, he shook his head with an annoyed expression. It was then that I suspected that Fluttershy had finished writing the scroll hours ago but had chickened out on sending it to me. Certainly something I would expect from her. Angel must have snuck it out of her cottage without her noticing.

Twilight asked quietly, "James... What are you going to do about this?" She almost sounded afraid.

I replied while I approached the front door with Angel, "I'm gonna ask her about this. Can I come back tomorrow for the book I was looking for?"

The purple unicorn nodded with a frown. "Sure... Have a nice night, James." I had never seen Twilight look so sad before. Probably because she was worried that the confrontation with Fluttershy would not end well. Regardless, I said my goodbyes and followed Angel back towards Fluttershy's home.

By the time Fluttershy's cottage came into view, the sun had very nearly vanished over the horizon for the night. While I walked up the slope to the front door of her house, I could hear Fluttershy's voice from an open window. Out of curiosity, I walked over to it and peered inside. Curtains were hanging in the way, but they were sheer enough for me to see through. But since that meant she could see through it too, I remained still to avoid detection.

Fluttershy was frantically looking about for something while constantly talking to herself. "Ooooh, where is it? I know I left it on that desk when I was done writing! I hope it didn't somehow make its way to James... Did I put it in the mailbox? Hopefully the mailmare didn't stop by after I did... I better go check." As she ran to the front door, I hurried over to it to meet her. As soon as the door opened, Fluttershy yelped in a surprisingly high pitched tone. "Ah! James!" I had to restrain myself from laughing at her skittish reaction to my unexpected presence.

"Uh... Good evening, Fluttershy. Expecting anyone?" I asked, trying not to sound like I knew what she was searching for.

Fluttershy blushed while trying to regain her composure. "Um... No, not really... I was just looking for a..... Oh...my..." Her gaze rested upon my hand. In my grasp was the love letter she had written. "You... You didn't happen to read that...did you?"

I could not bring myself to lie towards someone as tender as Fluttershy, so I replied honestly. "Yeah... I'm the guy you wanted advice on confessing to, right? So... Is this real? Or did you just send it to me as a test to see how well you could convey your feelings in text? And please be honest."

I watched as Fluttershy backed away from me with a very deep blush on her face. I could see tears welling up in her eyes. "That scroll... I wrote it... The guy I like... I love..." She curled up in a corner in the room and covered her face with her hooves as she sobbed, "It's you, James... Please don't hate me..."

The sight of Fluttershy sobbing in fear and shame was truly one of the most pathetic sights I have ever seen. She looked so miserable, I felt sorry for her. Hoping to put her fears to rest, I slowly approached her and ran my fingers through her beautiful pink mane once I dropped to my knees. "I don't hate you, Fluttershy. Please don't cry. It hurts when I see you this scared."

Ever so slowly, the timid pegasus removed her hooves from her face. I slowly stroked her face just under the eyes to wipe away her tears. "You... You're not angry? Not offended at all? Not even a little?" She asked shyly in her signature quiet tone.

I nodded with the softest smile I can make. "I could never hate you. I can't even see any real flaws in your behavior. If there is someone in this world who doesn't like you, then there's something wrong with that person."

Fluttershy sighed while she leaned against the hand that was stroking her mane. "There are a few...but many more do like me..."

With a smile, I spoke, "Only I like you the most."

I watched as Fluttershy blushed deeply while she let out a light squeak. Her modesty and shyness made my heart melt. I wanted to protect her. To always be there for her. I helped her climb to her feet before I lifted her up in my arms. "You look tired. Let's get you somewhere to rest." I carried her over to a green sofa of sorts and lied down on it with Fluttershy atop me. The length was fairly short, so I had to raise one leg over the back while letting the other hang off the side.

Fluttershy rested her head next to mine as she lay upon my chest. I held her against me with my hands on her back. "Have you stopped crying?" I asked softly.

"Yes... I'm OK now..." Fluttershy replied with a whisper.

I continued to stroke my friend's mane. At my touch, Fluttershy cooed softly, "I love it when you do that..."

"Is that why you came to love me?" I asked, curious of how she came to develop feelings for me.

Fluttershy blushed deeply while she muttered, "I don't know...if I can put it into words... You've just...always been so kind to me... You showed me how gentle you are with animals... And... And..." She began to tear up once again while pausing briefly. "I'm sorry... That's the best I've got... I can't describe it anymore than that..."

She was probably expecting me to reject her feelings if she could not explain them properly. But I understand that love is not something that can always be explained. I could tell that her feelings were sincere. And I wanted to be with her always. Because she...was... No. She IS the girl I love.

Fluttershy closed her eyes, afraid to look at me. However, I brought my lips to her ear and whispered, "I love you, Fluttershy."

Her eyes shot open instantly at my words. She gazed at me with a deep blush on her face. "You mean... Re...really?"

I replied with a question of my own. "May I kiss you?"

Fluttershy's blush only deepened further. But she soon smiled meekly and whispered, "Ye...yes... I would like that."

I stroked her face before I brought my lips to hers. When they touched, I felt a tear drip onto my neck. Our kiss was brief as Fluttershy began to sob quietly. She was likely overwhelmed with emotion since she had never received love of this magnitude before. "Fluttershy...?" I asked while I placed my hand over her hoof.

She gasped for breath as she sobbed, "Please... Hold me..." She threw her forelegs around my neck as she held her face against the side of my head as she wept quietly. For all I know, she was likely releasing years of pent-up loneliness from being so withdrawn.

I gently caressed the pegasus pony's back, trying to make her know that she was loved. "Don't cry, Fluttershy... I won't ever leave you... I promise."

To my surprise, Fluttershy muttered, "I'm not...hurt. I'm just...so happy to have...somepony like you..." After a moment more, she asked, "James... May I...kiss you? If that's all right with you..."

Even though I had expressed my feelings towards her, I was flattered by Fluttershy's modesty. I had her look at me before I smiled and whispered, "You don't ever have to ask me that, Fluttershy. You may kiss me whenever you want."

Fluttershy smiled timidly before pressing her lips against mine. We both closed our eyes, my hand behind her head. Before I knew it, we had parted our lips and allowed our tongues to touch. This more intimate kiss did not last long since Fluttershy soon pulled away from me suddenly. "What's wrong? Did I...go too far?" I asked, seeing that she appeared a little dazed.

"N... No... I just...felt a sudden rush when we..." Fluttershy muttered as she shook her head to get her bearings. But she then asked with a blush, "May we do that again?" I nodded and we began to kiss again. Fluttershy made the first move to make the kiss more intimate. I felt her tongue touch my lips before I could open them for her. The strange sensation of our tongues touching was new to me, but I enjoyed every second of it. By the time we broke the kiss, I think we were both blushing while lightly panting from a spike in body temperature.

"Did you like it?" I asked, somewhat concerned for my lover.

Fluttershy groggily replied, "I...loved it..." She then surprised me by nuzzling my face, "But I love you most of all..."

Her words touched me deeply. To me, Fluttershy was the most precious and loveable pony in Ponyville. Maybe even in all of Equestria. To know that she had chosen me over all others made me feel like the luckiest man alive. I held her in my arms tightly as I whispered, "And I love you more than anything, Fluttershy..."

The two of us just continued to cuddle and kiss for... I do not know. Forty minutes? An hour? Regardless, by the time we looked out the window, it was nightfall. The moon was high in the sky and the stars could be seen.

"Time flies when you're with someone you love, huh?" I muttered, surprised by just how late it had gotten.

Fluttershy blushed as she whispered, "Um... I'm sorry if I kept you..."

Sweet little Fluttershy. Always so modest and submissive. It only made me love her more. I stroked her mane while I smiled. "Don't be. I don't have anything planned for tonight. I loved every minute with you."

My words did the trick since Fluttershy smiled brightly. "So did I... I'm so glad to have you as my boyfriend, James."

I felt a very warm sensation come over me when I heard that word. Boyfriend. She had actually acknowledged me as her lover. It felt as if nothing could go wrong. I then placed my hand over Fluttershy's hoof and asked, "Fluttershy. If it's all right with you, may I move in with you tomorrow?"

I expected Fluttershy to be nervous. Instead, she beamed brightly at me. "You mean... Us living together? Like a couple?" She went airborne while flapping her wings as she smiled, "That sounds...so wonderful... I'd love to have you here with me!"

Looking forward to tomorrow, I sat up from the sofa and climbed to my feet. "Then I'll pack my bags as soon as I get home from work tomorrow."

I stepped outside Fluttershy's cottage and looked around at the untouched natural landscape bathed in moonlight. Many fireflies would glow every few seconds. I was already looking forward to living with Fluttershy while surrounded by nature. "I'm gonna love it here." I remember muttering out loud.

"Do you think it would be OK for me to visit you while you're on the job tomorrow?" Fluttershy asked while she closed the bottom half of the front door behind me.

I thought over my response for a moment before replying, "Actually, how about you meet me during my lunch break? I think I'll take it at a little past noon."

Fluttershy smiled and gave me a nod. "Some time for just us? That sounds lovely. How does the café sound for a place to meet up at?"

"That's where I always go for lunch on work days. So it's decided?" I asked, looking forward to our first meal together.

"Absolutely." Fluttershy said with a smile. However, she then frowned and spoke with a rather disappointed tone. "I...guess this is goodbye then..."

I could understand why Fluttershy seemed unhappy. I did not want to leave her either, even if it was just for one night. But I placed my hand on her cheek and smiled. "Yeah... But just for tonight. Starting tomorrow, we'll be living together. So please be patient. All right, honey?"

Fluttershy blushed deeply when I called her 'honey' just then. It was clearly the first time she had ever been called something so tender before. "O...K... I hope I dream about you tonight. Have a safe walk back to Rarity's place, James." She then gave me a kiss on the cheek, prompting me to smile as she had learned that she did not have to ask permission to do so.

I casually walked along the path that led from Fluttershy's cottage out into the meadow that separated it from Ponyville. But every moment, I would look over my shoulder to see if Fluttershy had gone to bed. To my pleasant surprise, she was still standing at the doorway while watching me. Just before I was completely out of view, I waved back at her. She clearly must have seen me since she raised one of her forelegs and waved back. With a spring in my step, I hurried on through Ponyville to return to Carousel Boutique.

When I arrived, I found that no light was shining through the windows. I suspected that Rarity had gone to bed and locked me out before doing so. Fortunately, I found that the back door was unlocked. "Thanks, Rarity." I muttered, grateful that she had left a way back inside for me.

I am writing this from the sofa in the room where I sleep. I have just finished bathing for the night and am happier than I have been in a long time. I have found my very first girlfriend in the unlikeliest of ponies. Fluttershy. While I do have some doubts about the future, I still feel the desire to protect and support her however I can. Tomorrow will be our first day as lovers. I wonder if I will have enough time when I wake up to visit her before work.

Thank you, Fluttershy. Thank you for coming into my life. I love you.