Tailmouth Trap

Story by punjoke on SoFurry

, , , , , , , , , ,

#2 of Tailmouths

This one is a first for me. It's my first male-on-male story! And pegging, too. Oh my. For my regular readers, skip this one if that sort of stuff doesn't interest you. For my irregular readers, enjoy but don't expect other stories like this, sorry!

Another story inspired by a talk with my friend. It was too interesting a scenario to not write about.

Mute and Noise belongs to a friend!


From the moment he walked into the bar, his eyes were glued to her. The first thing he noticed was that she was a tailmouth, like himself. She already looked ill at ease, as though she were a fish out of water in a place like this, and her grinning pink tail did very little to help her blend in. Simon wondered what she was doing here in the first place. More importantly, he wondered what he'd have to do to get her to leave with him.

"You look lost," he said, sitting down beside her. The pink-haired girl glanced at him in surprise, her panic evident despite the fact that her bangs concealed her eyes. When she didn't respond, Simon continued. "Sorry, let me introduce myself. I'm Simon." With a quick glance, he looked down at his tail. "And that's Quest."

After a long pause, the girl squeaked "Mute. A-and my tail is Noise."

He was going to have fun with this one.

Simon came to this bar to pick up girls regularly, and it was rare that he didn't end up bringing some tipsy broad home for a threesome with his twin sister. Mute seemed to be just his type, and there was no way he was going to let her get away from him. She wasn't very talkative, and her tail stayed silent the whole time, but Simon was undaunted. He bought her a few drinks - not enough to get her drunk, just enough to loosen her up - and she accepted them with some reluctance.

When he felt the time was right, Simon sprung his trap. "It's getting pretty crowded," he said, looking around the room casually. "Why don't we go some place with less people? How about back to my place?"

The shy tailmouth girl glanced down at her drink in an attempt to avoid his gaze. After some deliberation, she stammered "U-ummm... I guess that would be okay."

Almost too easy, Simon thought to himself. He could read her like a book. Once he got her back to his apartment, he was sure it would take only the minimum amount of cajoling to get her out of her skirt. For the time being, however, he continued to act perfect gentleman. Mute clung tightly to his arm as he escorted her across town. From the way she walked, he guessed she was not accustomed to drinking so much - all the better for him.

When they arrived back at the apartment, Autumn was waiting for them. "Mute, this is my sister Autumn, and her tail Rain," Simon said. The shy tailmouth seemed surprised to find another person there, but after the introduction Mute seemed to relax visibly. For her part, Autumn stood and nodded her head politely while Rain gave her a toothy smile.

The relief was short lived, however, as Simon wasted no time in pushing Mute down onto the couch and giving her an aggressive kiss. She struggled vainly to push him away as his hands roamed over her body. Twisting her head, she managed to pant "Wait... your sister..."

Simon smiled. "Don't worry baby, she can watch." Then he pressed his lips to hers again and forced his tongue into her mouth. The girls he brought home were always a little nervous about getting frisky in front of Autumn, but before they knew it they all found themselves in the middle of an incestuous threesome.

But Autumn would have to wait. Mute was so tempting, so vulnerable, he had to have her right now. Pulling away from the kiss, he grabbed her by the the shoulder and said, "Turn over." The girl looked up at him in fright, but she did as she was told. Simon bent her over the back of the couch and unzipped his pants, then pushed his hands up underneath her skirt and pulled her panties down. Despite her partner's obvious trepidation, Noise moved out of the way, giving him full access to her rear, still covered by the short skirt.

Leaning over Mute, Simon whispered in her ear. "Ever been fucked up the ass?" He fumbled blindly to get his cock in position.

"Not that," Mute mewled, but there was no going back now. Simon had found her tight little anus and, without even taking the time for lubrication, penetrated it with a mighty shove.

The poor girl gripped the couch and cried out in pain at the sudden intrusion, but her distress only enflamed Simon's passion. There was nothing quite like forcing a submissive girl into anal sex. Holding onto her shoulders, he pounded her tender ass with no regards for her comfort. She felt so tight and warm that he probably could have cum right then and there, but in a stroke of sadistic pleasure, he held back to prolong the experience as much as possible.

"It hurts," said Mute between gasps.

Simon licked one of her pink ears. "Just relax and take it," he commanded. His fingers dug into her shoulders.

Autumn stood pressed up against the wall, watching her brother have his way with the pretty tailmouth girl. He'd done the same to her many times, although her reluctance had been feigned. Seeing him use another girl made her both jealous and excited at the same time. Sensing Autumn's arousal, Rain licked her hand. When her tail's tongue receded, Autumn stealthily slipped her damp hand down her pants and began to rub her pussy.

With each rough thrust into her ass, Mute let out a loud yelp. The sound was music to Simon's ears, and he slammed her faster and harder until the girl was making quite a racket. Reaching out, he grabbed a fist full of her pink hair and yanked it savagely. She bawled as he used her; if he'd been in a more calm state of mind, Simon may have worried that Noise would try to stop him, but the tail did not intervene.

"Coming back to a stranger's house with him and then letting him fuck you in the ass," Simon growled, as though Mute had been given a choice in the matter. "I knew you were nothing but a slut."

He wasn't going to last much longer, despite his best efforts. The girl was too tight, and the situation was too intense. Finally he decided to just let go; there would be plenty of time for him to go a second and even third round with the girl, and he wanted to get Autumn in on the fun too. Grunting and moaning, Simon gave Mute's rear a few more hard thrusts, then buried himself as deep as he could in the girl's abused asshole. A knot had formed at the base of his cock, but despite his best efforts he couldn't fit the bulge into her tiny hole. Regardless, he felt the girl seize up underneath him as he began to pump his thick, warm load into her butt. When he was done, he slumped down on top of her and kissed her neck.

"Mmmmmmmm, perrrrrfect," a deep and unfamiliar voice hummed. "So rough with my beloved little Mute!"

Still clouded by post-orgasmic bliss, Simon didn't realize at first that a stranger had spoken. Instead, he sighed contentedly, then pulled his cock out of Mute's ass and stepped back. Wanting to survey the aftermath of his latest conquest, Simon flipped the tailmouth girl's skirt up and got his first look at her cute little butt.

What he saw made his heart skip a beat.

Her asshole winked back at him, the ravaged hole oozing cum. Below it, however, was a pair of testicles, and below them Simon could see that Mute had a very large and very erect blue cock. The girl wasn't a girl at all.

"You're... a boy?!" Simon sputtered in shock and disbelief.

Mute turned around to face him and shyly pushed her - his - skirt back down in an ineffective attempt to cover his huge hard-on. It poked up from beneath his skirt. "Y-yes..." the crossdresser uttered.

"Baaahahahahahaha," Rain burst out laughing from the other side of the room where Autumn now stood petrified. "He sure had you fooled, didn't he Simon?"

Simon shot her an angry glare. "Shut up, it's not funny." Then he looked back at Mute, his cheeks burning in embarrassment. "Why didn't you say anything?"

But Noise answered him instead. "Awww, don't be mad," the tail teased him with a sly grin. "You enjoyed fucking him up the ass, didn't you?"

That was the worst part of it - up until this point, Mute had been one of the best fucks he'd ever brought home. And now...

Fumbling with his zipper, Simon hurriedly tried to tuck his cock, knot and all, back into his pants. Without another word, he turned and rushed out of the apartment, slamming the door behind him and running down the hall. His head was spinning; he couldn't believe this had happened to him.

This left Mute and Autumn alone together. The femboy fussed with his skirt, but he only succeeded in drawing attention to the tent sticking up out of his lap. Autumn stood with her back pressed to the wall next to the door, her hands folded in front of her. They both did their best to avoid looking at each other.

Suddenly Mute sprang up and hurriedly made his way towards the exit. Before he could reach the doorknob, however, he found his path barred by a big brown tail. "Leaving so soon?" Rain chided him. "Autumn and I haven't had any fun yet!" The aggressive tail butted against Mute, pushing him back towards the couch.

"Please, I... I should go," Mute said, falling back into his seat.

Noise had other ideas. "Let's have some fun with them, Mute," he said with a grin. Turning to Autumn, he continued. "Come over here little lady."

Like a deer caught in headlights Autumn stood there, unsure of what to do, until Rain urged her to comply. At her tail's command, the girl approached Mute and timidly sank to her knees in front of him. Looking up at the femboy, she caught a glimpse of his blue eyes hidden beneath his pink bangs; he almost looked frightened.

"Lift up his skirt," Autumn's tail instructed her from over her shoulder, and she did. Mute's blue cock sprang free of its confines immediately, the tip glistening with pre-cum. "Verrrrry nice," purred Rain. The tail drifted forward and, extending her long tongue, gave the shaft a big slurp. After she's lathered up Mute's cock with saliva, she pulled back and told Autumn, "Your turn. Suck it."

Autumn leaned forward and took the cock into her mouth dutifully. Her head bobbed up and down as she put years of practice to use on the well-endowed femboy. The submissive girl was used to being told what to do, however, and without further prompting from Mute she found herself holding back, swallowing barely a quarter of his full length.

Luckily, Noise came to the rescue. "Push her head down, Mute," he told his partner.

Mute shook his head. "I can't..."

"Grab her and shove it down her throat," Noise insisted. "Now."

cringing slightly, Mute reached down and grabbed the back of Autumn's head. With strength that surprised even him, he forced Autumn to go down deeper on his cock. Before he knew it, the girl's nose was pressed against his pubic region and he could feel the velvety walls of her throat squeezing around his shaft. Autumn struggled to breathe and tried to pull back, but Mute wouldn't let her.

"Such a good little slut," Rain said. The tail rubbed against her partner's face, then stuck her tongue out and licked her bulging throat. Autumn gagged and her eyes began to water, but she could not escape.

"Enough," Noise finally said, and with a sigh of relief Mute released Autumn. She sprang back, coughing and gasping for breath, a thick rope of saliva still connecting her chin to the femboy's cock. As she recovered, Noise asked Mute "How did it feel?"

"G-good," Mute answered weakly.

"Do it again," Rain said with glee. "Use her hot little mouth, make her choke on it until she begs!"

Pressured by the two sadistic tails, Mute grabbed Autumn again and forced her to deepthroat him again. He held her down for as long he dared while she squirmed and moaned helplessly, then allowed her to a moment to breathe before shoving her right back down. Each time the deepthroat lasted a little longer. Autumn tried to hold out as best she could, but eventually she felt vision going dim; she was going to black out. When Mute let her up again, she gasped "Please, wait."

Rain grinned. "Good girl," she said to Autumn. The tail moved in and ran her tongue along the bedraggled girl's face, licking up the drool that matted her chin. Then she shoved her tongue into her partner's mouth and kissed her deeply. Autumn submitted, allowing her tail to ravage her. Mute wasn't the only one who was hiding a secret: Autumn was incredibly aroused by the rough treatment.

Meanwhile, Noise attended to Mute. The femboy's tail brushed against his bulging erection sensuously, his blue tongue flicking out along the wet shaft. "The last time someone fucked you in the ass you came right away. You must be desperate to blow your load," Noise teased. Mute dropped his head, too embarrassed to confirm that it was true.

"I have a wonderful idea!" said Rain. "Autumn, the toy box." With a nod, Autumn leaned down and dragged an inconspicuous brown box from underneath the coffee table and opened it. Inside were an assortment of naughty sex toys. Simon left them there in case he ever wanted to spice up their sordid trysts. Rain grabbed the item she had been thinking of in her mouth and held it up for everyone to see - it was a large strap on dildo.

Noise laughed. "A tail after my own heart!" he exclaimed. "Aren't you glad you let me talk you into going out tonight, Mute?" Eyeing the latex phallus, Mute shivered in equal parts trepidation and anticipation.

Without further instruction, Autumn began to undress - she knew what Rain wanted her to do. Feigning modesty, the tailmouth girl turned away from Mute and pulled her shirt over her head, then unbuttoned her pants and shimmied out of them. She was not wearing any underwear, as was usual; Simon frequently told her not to. Only when she'd taken the strap on from Rain's mouth and put it on did she turn towards the femboy and allow him to feast his eyes on her naked body. She was drop-dead gorgeous, but Mute couldn't pry his gaze away from the shaft now sticking out from between her legs.

"Show her where you want it," Noise commanded.

Mute slid forward and raised his legs up into the air, presenting his asshole to the girl. Grabbing his white legs and spreading them wider, Autumn positioned the tip of the dildo at his anus. Unlike earlier, it appeared to be lubricated now - her brother's cum was still smeared around the tight hole.

Noise growled in her ear. "Don't be gentle with him."

"Give it to him hard," Rain said in her other ear. "Maybe when he's done, he'll do the same to you..."

Autumn wasn't used to being the one in control, but the thought of Mute returning the favor and fucking her brains out was excellent motivation. The tailmouth girl took a deep breath, then plunged the fake cock all the way into Mute's ass. Surprising even herself, she hammered him again and again, willing herself to fuck him as violently as she could in the hope that she would soon be in his place.

From the sounds he was making, anyone listening in could have easily come to the conclusion that Mute was being taken against his will. The femboy's cock was still rock hard, however, and he pumped it furiously with his fist as Autumn penetrated him. Meanwhile, Rain and Noise egged them both on, rubbing up against them and licking them provocatively, first urging Autumn to be more forceful, then telling Mute what a slut he was. "Two strange cocks in one night," hissed Noise. "And you love it!"

Shaking his head and panting heavily, Mute said "I... I'm not...!" His protests turned into a cry of unrestrained pleasure, however, and suddenly he was cumming. A stream of thick semen squirted high up into the air, spattering against Autumn's chest and belly. The next shot was just as strong, but this time it arced, hitting Mute square in his own face and chest. The femboy gasped in surprise as he tasted his own seed on his tongue; cum dripped down into his mouth from where it hung from his bangs, and he swallowed it. Autumn gave Mute's ass a few more harsh pounds before coming to a stop with the strap on buried deep inside him; then she reached for the femboy's cock and helped him stroke it.

When the streams of cum had finally come to a stop, Mute had made a total mess of himself. The two tails attacked him immediately, lapping the cum up from the front of his stained dress and off of his cheeks and mouth. Mute opened his mouth wide and allowed first Noise and then Rain to probe the insides, swapping spit and cum in a torrent of wet tongue kisses. Autumn let go of Mute's softening shaft and raised her hands to her mouth to lick the cum off of her fingers. When they were clean, she slid her hands down her supple body and rubbed the cum on her breasts and belly into her fur.

Noise licked his lips and swallowed the salty load he had been rolling around on his tongue. "I hope your brother will forgive us," he said merrily. "We were only having a bit of fun with him!"

Running her tongue along Mute's furry cheek, Rain snickered. "He'll get over it. He's just mad at himself because he had so much fun."

With a wet pop, Autumn pulled the latex dildo out of Mute's ass; it was smeared with her brother's leftover cum. She looked down at the shaft and stroked it, contemplating what it felt like to be the one in charge. Then she undid the strap and let the sex toy fall down onto the floor; her pussy was soaking wet. As she fingered herself slowly, she looked up at the femboy.

"When you're ready..." she said timidly. "Do it like that to me. Please?"

Noise and Rain licked Mute's face. "Yes, do it. Take her," they both cooed to him. He shuddered and looked down at his cock as it slowly began to rise up again.

One thing was for sure, everyone had gotten into a lot more than they had bargained for.