Sweet Tooth

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

#14 of 2023 Shorts

What would you do if you found out the Tooth Fairy was real? One lucky father gets a chance to find out.


This is a work of fiction. Unless otherwise indicated, all the names, characters, businesses, places, events and incidents in this story are either the product of the author's imagination or used in a fictitious manner. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, or actual events is purely coincidental. All characters are of legal and consenting age, likewise if you are reading this story, you should be of legal age in your respective country.

All characters are my own creation, any resemblance to existing characters is purely coincidental and not intentional, please do not use them without permission. If you would like to use them in a story, please feel free to send me a PM either as Inja on SoFurry or TheRealInja on FA. As always, I am open to new story ideas or situations with existing characters as well.

In desperate need of something silly, so here is what my mind came up with. A short dumb idea, enjoy.

**********************************************************************************

The hour grew late and a full moon was high in the midnight sky, casting a silvery glow on all creation below. With the light shining through their bedroom window, casting a silver hue upon his wife's long blond hair, the sight of her curves caused a stirring in her husband's loins. Bill growled seductively into Miranda's ear as he cuddled up behind her, gently nibbling along her neck and shoulder while his hand slipped up inside her nightgown to grope of her breast. He'd always loved her full bust, they fit so perfectly in the palms of his big, strong hands.

"Not tonight, Bill. Kelly will hear and then she'll want to come sleep with us...again" she grumbled while playfully swatting his hand away. It had admittedly been some time since they'd last consummated their marriage, heck even their pulsating shower head saw more action that Bill did these days. Sure, he loved his little girl to the moon and back, but his balls hadn't been this blue since he started dating that Bible thumping cheerleader back in high school.

"I'll be quiet, it's you that needs to try not wail like a banshee while I plow that big behind of yours" Bill teasingly snarled into his wife's ear, while giving her scruff a firm nip and tug in playful dominance. His rounded ears twitching at the sound of her excited gasp and the subtle grinding back of her behind against his bulge. He knew he had her, tonight was going to be his lucky night finally!

"Okay, but make it quick..." Miranda huffed as she finally relented, it had been quite some time since they'd last been intimate thanks to a bout of various sleeping issues with their young daughter. Tonight, seemed to be the first night she didn't ask to sleep in their bed and Bill was going to make good use of it. He eagerly ground himself against his wife's behind while tugging the back of her nightgown up to expose her. Bill next awkwardly tugged his stiffness from the confines of his boxers, wincing as they accidentally slipped from his grasp and the elastic snapped back against his heavy balls. His eagerness would not be so easily deterred however; grasping about the base of his thick cock, the pent-up bear lined himself up with the inviting slick warmth of his wife's tight cunt he'd missed so much. Miranda bit her lip while she wiggled back against him invitingly, gasping softly when she felt him just at the point where he was starting to stretch her opening and threatening to enter her.

"Mommy, my tooth fell out. I put it under my pillow, but I'm afraid the Tooth Fairy will take the rest of my teeth while I sleep...can I sleep with you?" Kelly's sweet little voice called out suddenly from the foot of their bed. Bill stopped moving instantly, resisting the urge to curse in front of his child. Miranda however yelped and jumped; sitting upright immediately and stared down at their wide-eyed little girl.

"Oh, uh...sure honey. Why don't you hop on up" Miranda offered while shooting her husband "the look" the let him know it was pointless to even think of trying to argue. Bill stared back at her with longing, but he'd been married long enough to know that he had no hope of winning that argument. After all, the last time he had won an argument, the result of said victory now was cuddled up behind Miranda and being a cockblock in every sense of the word.

"I'll go sleep in her bed, I have an early morning tomorrow anyway and need a good night's sleep" Bill grumbled and sighed, grabbing his mobile and favorite pillow to head to his daughter's room. If he couldn't get his rocks off with his wife; thanks to little Kelly Cockblock, he'd at least be able to rub one out in private while watching something on his phone.

Bill stumbled down the hallway to the other end of their house where Kelly's room was; both he and his wife had been firm believers in keeping their rooms separate to avoid her hearing any unwanted noises at night, as they were both rather passionate lovers. However, that didn't seem to be an issue as she was still sleeping in their bed nearly every night, meaning there were never any noises for her to hear anyway. Bill grumbled and muttered to himself as he adjusted his bulge while trudging along the carpeted hallway, briefly stopping to empty his bladder before continuing onto the pink frilly bed in his daughter's room.

Closing and locking the door behind himself for a bit of privacy, ensuring he would at least be able to rub one out in peace, Bill picked his way through the minefield of toys scattered around his little girl's bedroom floor. Once he'd safely navigated the multitude of dangers, both seen and unseen in the carpet, the large bear lay back on the small pink bed, causing it to creak dangerously under his weight. The large bear got into a comfortable position, after propping his phone up against the bedside lamp, and with his hands now free to do the deed, Bill queued up his favorite video. A large male and a small female were going at it, he was tossing her around like a ragdoll and she was loving it. Being a big bruin himself, Bill often fantasized about nailing a cute little bitch like that. Sure, he loved his big buxom wife to death; sure, she could take a pounding too, but there was just something so enticing about being able to body your lover like it was nothing. With how pent up he was, it didn't take long for Bill to make a mess all over his hand and belly; thankfully there was an abundance of baby wipes for cleaning various spills and messes in Kelly's room. In short order he was clean and smelling like a clean baby's behind, with his balls now a little lighter, Bill rolled onto his side and fell into an easy slumber. Or as easy as he could, having to curl up on his daughter's little pink princess bed.

"Ow, fuck! Shit!" A voice yelped in the dark, Bill's eyes popping open instantly and seeing the outline of someone moving around in the room. "Goddamn spoiled, snot nosed, little brats leaving all their shitty toys everywhere...teach your semen demons to pick up after themselves, goddamn!" the feminine voice grumbled as it tripped over a couple of Kelly's spelling blocks, scattering them across the floor with a clatter.

Bill remained motionless as the small figure carefully picked her way through the debris of toys scattered around the room, until eventually she stood right beside the bed. He could smell an odd sweetness about her, it almost reminded him of cotton candy when she leaned in close and began searching beneath the pillow his head was resting on for something.

"No wonder you're losing your teeth you little shit, look how fat that ass is! Eat a vegetable some time, oinker!" she mocked while feeling around for her prize. "Aha...oh shit!" the voice yelped when Bill suddenly reached up and grabbed her by the wrist, at the same time flicking on the bedside lamp to illuminate the small figure before him.

"Who the fuck are you and why are you in my daughter's bedroom?" Bill growled as he slowly rose up to his nearly seven-foot stance, glowering down at a rather frightened looking little bunny now caught in his grasp.

"I'm Belinda, I'm just a trainee...might I say, you're awfully big and manly for a three-year-old named Kelly by the way..." Belinda the bunny replied, still staring up at the massive black bear lifting her off her feet by his grip at her dainty wrist.

"Trainee, for what? You're too fucking noisy for a criminal" Bill scoffed as he turned Belinda about in his grasp to get a better look at her. She was nice and small, a little over half his height, rather curvy too if he was being honest, but she was wearing a very cheap glittery imitation fairy costume. Her fur looked soft and pink, just like the cotton candy he'd smelled on her earlier. Her eyes were big and blue, her nose was a cute little pink twitching thing as she stared up at him with only a hint of fear, but mostly she just seemed annoyed or rather pissed off she'd been caught so easily. His free hand reached out to grab one of her shiny wings to give it a little curious tug, more than expecting them to simply detach from her body by how cheaply made they looked.

"Ow, that hurts fucker! Those are real, dickhead...you wouldn't like it if I pulled like that on your nutsack, would you?" the small rabbit yelped and growled up at him. "That's it, where's my wand?" Belinda sighed in exasperation while she patted herself down while looking for something.

"You mean that wand?" Bill asked curiously as he pointed over at the far side of the room, to where a sparkling golden star sat atop a thin and intricately carved silver rod handle.

"Shit...uh, I don't suppose you'd be willing to let me go and forget this ever happened? My boss has been on my ass lately, one more screw up and it's back to being the Easter Bunnies assistant. He shits candy...do you know how hard that is to clean out of his ass fur?" Belinda asked with her best puppy dog eyed expression.

"What's in it for me?" Bill asked with a lecherous grin while he looked the small rabbit in her skimpy outfit over. His free hand subconsciously groping at his once again growing bulge, normally he wasn't into the whole cosplay stuff, but he had to admit that Belinda did look rather sexy in her short glittery skirt.

"Dude, you're married...I can see the fucking wedding ring on your finger from here" Belinda spat, the expression she wore making it plain to see that she was not even remotely impressed by his insinuation.

"Technically you don't even exist, so I'm not sure this'd count as cheating" the big bear rumbled while he palmed her behind with a firm squeeze. "You help me out and I'll help you out, sounds fair to me" Bill pressed on, shamelessly groping the small curvy pink bunny, even pressing her down against his bulge invitingly.

"My good sir, you're at least twice my size!" Belinda tried to reason with the bear, panic starting to set in as she felt the heft of the bulge currently grinding against her.

"Aren't you supposed to be magical or some shit?" Bill pressed on with a healthy dose of skepticism, he wouldn't be so easily deterred from a once in a lifetime opportunity such as this.

"Yeah, but that's more to prevent workplace injuries. Not taking dick bigger than my forearm..." She grumbled; though truth be told, even she didn't quite know how that side of her magic worked. She had managed to squeeze through a keyhole before, but her fitting into tight spaces was very different from something big fitting into her tight places.

"Won't know until you try it" Bill offered with a grin while he sat down on Kelly's bed, pulling the small rabbit into his lap and placing her right down on his bulge again. This time he held her firmly about the waist, subtly directing her to wriggle and grind in his lap.

"Alright, fine. Just this one time, never again!" She finally relented, partly just to earn her freedom, but also because she was somewhat curious about the situation as well. Once she was released and allowed to move about freely, the bunny shuffled over when Bill turned to lay back on the small bed and part his thighs. With a leering grin, he watched as the winged rabbit tugged his boxers down to expose his eager flesh, which promptly jumped free and slapped her on the nose, hard enough to make her eyes water. "Ow, fuck sake!" the rabbit yelped while she wiped tears from her eyes, suddenly going wide eyed once she saw what she was dealing with. "You've got to be fucking kidding me...are you part horse or something? That shit can't be natural!" Despite her annoyed tone however, Belinda was staring at his cock with a look of wonder, perhaps even desire. Her small soft hands reached out to grasp his shaft, finding she was unable to make her fingers touch around the thick base of it.

"Well?" Bill huffed with a cocky grin, his hands resting behind his head as the Tooth Fairy fondled his junk with a look of pure amazement etched on her pretty face.

"Well, what?" She asked absently, not quite paying attention to him and seemingly focused on his junk in her hands instead. Her long silver hair slipping from behind an ear to partially cover her face, only to be brushed back as she finally managed to raise her eyes to meet his and instantly bursting into a blush visible even through her pink fur.

"Don't just stare at it, it isn't going to suck itself" Bill offered, flexing his pelvic muscles to make his rod pulse and jump in her gentle grasp.

"Listen asshole I'mnnghff!" Belinda started to protest, but was quickly silenced by an annoyed snort from Bill when he impatiently shoved her open maw down onto the blunt tip of his cock. With his hands gripping one of her long ears in each big mitt, Bill started to buck up into the protesting lapine's maw. Surprisingly, he managed to force her down all the way until her cute little pink nose was rubbing against the coarse fur of his crotch. Bill loved the way her throat flexed and squeezed around his flesh while she fought for breath, even when he held her down for longer than even the most skilled free diver could manage, somehow Belinda remained conscious. Oh, how he loved the pissed of glare she gave him while her lips were stretched around the thick base of his cock. Even Miranda wasn't able to deepthroat him like this and she was almost the same size as he was! Bill huffed and grunted as he worked the small rabbits mouth up and down his cock, pausing only briefly to hold her down in place before resuming his rough fucking. For as small and delicate as she looked, Belinda really could take a pounding, which only gave him ideas of how best to utilize her in other ways.

After a few long minutes of rough face fucking, Belinda once again found her nose being ground into the coarse crotchfuzz of the eager bear, feeling the twitches and pulses of his cock right before his hot seed erupted against the back of her throat. She tried her best to swallow it down, but it was too much. Soon he had her coughing and gagging, her ears aching from how tightly they were being gripped while she fought to pull her maw back and off his cock. Eventually he'd let go so she could pull off his length, falling backward onto the bed as she gasped for breath and tried to wipe his cum from her muzzle.

"Dude! You made it come out my nose!" Belinda snarled cutely as she coughed and gasped for breath, wiping the backs of her hands across her muzzle and nose. Now sitting on her behind as she glared up at the bear, whom was still smirking at her, she noticed that his cock was still unfortunately hard. "What're you looking at? You had your fun..."

"That was just the beginning, besides...I'm curious to see how tight that cute little cunt of yours is" Bill explained as he stared down between her spread thighs, finding out that fairies didn't in fact wear underwear. Bill was getting an eyeful of her snug looking little pink slit, her flesh a brighter pink than the surrounding fur, looking rather inviting. Before she could protest, the bear was on her again and Belinda found herself quickly resting back on her shoulders, with her knees folded almost up by her ears.

"Ow, Goddammit! Small rabbit, big dick...be careful fer Chris'sakes!" she yelped when Bill easily folded her in half, before lodging what felt like his forearm inside her. Even though she wasn't a virgin, none of her lovers was ever quite this big, not even Santa. She swore her pussylips were stretched so taut around the base of the fat bear cock in her that they'd sound like a guitar chord if she so much as touched them. That didn't stop the eager bear however, he simply grinned and stared down at the bump now showing at her belly from where he was buried in her.

"Seems you can take my dick just fine" Bill mocked before drawing his hips back, slowly and steadily dragging nearly every inch out of the panting and gasping rabbit below. He watched in awe as her snug little pink pussylips gripped about his cock as he pulled back, it was even more erotic than he ever thought it could be.

"Wait, wait, wait, wait!" Belinda tried to plead with the eager male, but it was useless. Bill let his hips drop heavily back down, his large balls tapping against her behind while he sheathed himself in the tightest cunt he'd ever felt. The rabbit reached up to grasp at him, wherever she could, clawing and scratching at the big brute as he started to hammer down into her. Try as she might, Bill would not so much as slow down, let alone stop his almost savage fucking. Despite the rough treatment, Belinda felt something starting to build up inside her. Her eyes closed and brows furrowed while she tried to fight off the feeling, until it all became too much. With a squeak, she started to shudder and shake through her first reluctant climax. Her toes curled hard enough for her joints to pop as she clawed at the large bears strong upper arms and shoulders desperately.

"Fu...uck, too tight!" Bill yelped as the small rabbit climaxed beneath him without warning, soon sending him over the edge into his next climax as well. His heavy balls jumped and twitched as he flooded her with another load of his seed. The rabbits body however, was too small to accommodate his cock as well as his load, soon making a mess of the pretty princess bed covers beneath her behind. With a lewd wet schlurp, Bill finally withdrew his cock from the well fucked bunny and sat back with a pant, grinning as he admired his handywork. With her thighs parted, he could see his white mess spilling from her well fucked pussy and trickling down between her rump cheeks to pool at the underside of her puffball tail.

"Asshole..." Belinda mumbled as she rolled over and tried to crawl off the bed to retrieve her wand finally.

"I'm not done with you yet and that sounds like a great idea too..." Bill laughed from somewhere behind her. His large hands clapping down about her hips and behind as he hauled her back onto the bed, forcing her to her knees while he jammed a thick thumb under her cotton puff of a tail, using his own seed as makeshift lubrication while pumping his thick digit in and out of her behind.

"Ow! Hey, watch it dickhead. I'm not Tinkerbell, ain't no one going to my Neverland!" She growled back at the bear as she tried to kick him. The bruin simply laughed, grabbing her by the offending ankle and hauling her back into his lap.

"Says who?" Bill rumbled into her ear after he scooped Belinda up off the bed, pulling her back against his chest while she slowly lowered her behind down onto his waiting spear.

"Wait, no!" Belinda whined as the ursine forced his thickness under her twitching puffball tail, his girth spreading her cheeks as he grabbed beneath her knees and once again forced her downward, while folding her over again. At first there was a burning pain between her cheeks, glowing white hot until suddenly nothing but an incredibly full feeling overtook her. As the thundering of her heart pounding in her ears faded finally, Belinda heard a series of curious squeaks and yips, briefly confused as to where they were coming from. Suddenly she became aware of the room bouncing before her; she was being lifted and dropped down onto Bills turgid member, over and over again as he slowly walked her over toward a mirror on the far side of the room. Belinda was forced to watch herself getting fucked by the big bear, her cheeks once again burning red hot as she watched his thickness vanish up inside her again and again. Her legs bounced limply in his grasp while she reached up and behind herself to cling about his neck for support. Slowly it dawned on her that those odd little sounds she'd heard were coming from her, almost as if the thick cock pummeling her backdoor was forcing her breath from her lungs. More disturbingly than being buttfucked by a big married bear was the fact it was starting to feel good, too good in fact. Belinda groaned as she tried to fight off the feeling, she wasn't the sort of bunny to enjoy such things, was she? This was so wrong, and yet...

"Quit squeezing so hard or you'll pinch my dick off!" Bill grumbled down at her as she squirmed against him. He almost couldn't believe it; the little cute pink bunny was actually cumming from being fucked in the ass by him!

"Eat a bag of dicks, dill hole..." Belinda whined, suddenly biting down on her bottom lip almost hard enough to break skin and draw blood when her next climax tore through her. Suddenly she was glad for the strong grip Bill had on her, the way she jerked and bucked, anyone smaller no doubt would've dropped her.

"Goddamn, tight fairy asshole!" Bill snarled as the tight pucker wrapped about his cock clenched even tighter still, making it almost impossible for him to move in and out of her even a quarter of an inch. The more she bucked and squirmed however, the closer he got to his own release as well. After a few moments of her bucking and squirming through her own climax, eventually Bill couldn't hold back his own pleasure any longer either. With a firm bite down at the side of her neck, the bear let loose. Finally, he began firing off his final climax up Belinda's snug little pink backdoor, before collapsing back onto the bed and panting heavily. As sleep finally claimed him, Bill smiled as he heard the rabbit muttering and cursing his name, while she awkwardly lifted herself off his cock with a lewd wet sound, before she headed for the window to make her escape.

*************************************************************************************

Bill awoke with a heavy yawn early the next morning, licking his chops and rubbing his eyes, only vaguely remembering his erotic dream of the bunny Tooth Fairy. Still yawning as he reached down to adjust his morning wood with one hand, the other shifting under the pillow his head rested upon, feeling a hard pebble beneath. Curiously he withdrew the object, blinking as his eyes adjusted to the morning light to see he was holding his daughter's tooth. With a frown he got to his feet and stumbled toward the bedroom door in search of the bathroom, nature had begun calling incessantly, like a telephone marketer buzzing his bladder.

"Ow, fuck! Goddamn Legos..." Bill winced when he stood on something sharp. But as he reached the doorway, he suddenly realized that his daughter didn't own any Legos. Turning about and looking at the floor, Bill spotted a curious looking glowing golden star perched atop a narrow silver intricately carved rod. His lips curled into a grin as he looked down at the tooth in his hand, for once he hoped his daughter would ask to sleep in their bed again later that night.