Blank Verse Essay On the Treachery of Hope

Story by Rob MacWolf on SoFurry

, , , ,

#44 of poetry

I do not say, do not Hope, for hope is a needful thing. I say, do not believe that you need to hope at all costs, that you must remain in a place where there is no hope in order to hope there nonetheless.

For they who hope instead of living will lose both their life and their hope. But they who choose life instead of hope may live to hope another day.

And I will derive joy, in the meantime, from things other than hope. Such as the fact that I got to use "Homoousion" and "Anthropocene" in the same poem!


You must learn how to live and not to hope

For hope will be a luxury ere long.

For hope can be both manacle and chain.

For hope can keep you too spellbound to run

Until the waters rise too high, and boil.

You would not be the first. In ages past

'What princes do' was homoousion

With earthquakes, famines, floods, and funnel clouds:

Unstoppable and unaccountable.

Why should you think yourselves exceptioned out

From this, save for the easy lies of hope?

That keep you in your place, to take the blame

For those you did not speak for, and who shall

Not ever speak for you. Soon all the wheels

Of false republic fall, they always do,

And prove themselves unfixed from any thing,

Turning and turning in the widening gyre,

Cosmetic, and entirely functionless.

Now hope says "Lift them into place again,"

Are you a fool enough to heed its voice?

We've had the long semester's first exam.

Coronavirus was the first real test

Of governments, of principalities,

On whether in a climate crisis they

Can see priorities. Can place the lives

Of living people over lifeless gold

Which will be worthless should the people die.

I do not know of one that did not fail

At this, the first, the easiest of the tests.

There's going to be more. They will be worse.

There will be wildfires on suburban lawns.

There will be floods befouling farm and fen.

There will be hurricanes upon our heads.

I say 'there will be.' There already are.

Vanilla, Chocolate, and Coffee all

Will likely be extinct within your life,

And that will seem a mere frivolity.

The irony of ironies is that

The moment that proud humankind ascends--

In power, in wisdom, elements to grasp,

To harness to an age anthropocene--

Whatever humans hold the harness lose

All trace of their humanity. We lift

A man into the seat where he controls

The earthquakes, famines, floods, and funnel clouds,

But those become not one whit more controlled.

Rather the man controlling them becomes

As uncontrolled, as unaccountable

As earthquake, famine, flood, and funnel cloud,

As Old Thin God-Kings on their ziggurats.

So you must learn to live and not to hope.

For you will not have hope, and yet somehow

Must live. I bid you look you unto us.

We've lived the lesson all the world now needs.

We know well how to live, and not to hope.

I do not say that none of us have hope.

I do not say that all of us despair.

Hope is not Joy. Hope is not love. Hope is

Not fun, frivolity, ferocity,

Nor life, nor lust, nor laughter. All of these

We have instead of hope. I can but speak

For me, but I remember well the night

When truth of what I was wore no more mask,

When faith became a succubus above

My sleep paralysis, and sealed my lips,

To drain my lungs, to drink away my hope.

Three times I tried in vain to draw it back.

I heard it laugh "Too late," and then depart.

And I would wager many, if not all,

Of these my people of the conquering cold,

The sunset, and the many-colored flame,

Could tell a tale to harmonize with this.

We learned the lesson young. What kind of hope

Was ever there, for people such as us?

And yet, Behold: We did not waste away.

We did not die without it, and we will

Another sunrise see without it, too.

If you would live--and we would have you live--

Then this, my friend, is what you have to do.

And aye, it may be on the other side

When you have ceased to look for it, you will

Find hope again. Abandoned on the road.

Where many of my tribe of conquering cold,

Of sunset, and of many colored flame

Have found it, when they looked for it no more.

And then may you, with sober eyes and clear,

Decide if it's worth picking up again.