One Too Many

Story by TyrsBackalley on SoFurry

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Read the tags before continuing. This is the only warning you will receive.


Bruce - Mostly straight shark. Loves manly guys but hates looking at or touching dicks. Was a ladies man until he met henry who loves having his sheath fucked. Is pissed that he can't get both of his dicks inside the submissive wolf at once so decides to get rid of the obstruction. Unwillingly mind you.

Henry - Gay muscular wolf who's in love with bruce. Tolerates having his sheath fucked by him as he knows he gets off on treating him like a bit of a girl only doesn't realize how much.

"Damn it Bruce. I can't take both of them at once yet. You said you weren't going to try that again." He always fucking does this. Right in the middle of the most intense sex and that's when my boyfriend tries this shit. See Bruce is a shark. A particularly well-hung shark as well with those hemipenes of his and he's right now trying to shove both of them into my sheath again.

"I just want them in your cunt girl. If it didn't already have that doggy dick in there I would be able to get them both in easy. Now come on bitch just let me give it a go again. I have a good feeling about this time."

I push him off of me quite easily yelling, "Fucking stop it alright Bruce? I can't fucking take that. We've tried and it always ends with me getting torn. I know you like pretending I'm a fucking girl but enoughs enough. Please stop this shit." Still swearing I storm out of the room picking up my shorts on the way before heading outside.

I'm running for almost 2 hours before I cool down enough to even think. Recognizing where I am I begin a slow trot back to our place trying to go over my relationship issues in my head. I know Bruce is straight and all but I thought he would have come to terms with this side of him by now. I know he fucking loves me as he's never loved a chick before and I do like having my sheath fucked by him but both of his dicks? Just one of his is larger than mine if I don't count my knot. It took like 3 months to get one fully inside me.

He's driving me fucking mad with this. I don't care one bit about him fucking my sheath like I'm a girl and treating me like one sometimes. Hell as big as I am I encourage it a little which is embarrassing to admit but I don't like dealing with pain like that. I'm slowly learning to take him and I've been practising to take both but he has to give me more time. I know I'm going to have to have another chat with him when I get home about this and I really don't want to.

Damn it I just wish he'd relax a little about being gay. He hates that even his friends now say he is. He's been dating me for a year and he still doesn't accept that he's gay and can't stand looking at dicks. I've tried to tell him so many times that I couldn't care less about showing mine. I just want it there to occasionally tie a guy on a random hook ups or in a threesome. God those have driven Bruce wild as he fucks my ass with both of those dicks of his. That I love taking if only he'd relax when he's on top of me.

When I make it home my thoughts are just as unclear as ever so when I see Bruce sitting on the couch waiting for me looking guilty as hell the words leave me. "I'm sorry about earlier Henry. I got carried away again like usual, just being on top of you like that feels so good and I just lose it. That hole feels so good on my dick that I just want to have both in there and it reminds me of a girls cunt. Again I'm sorry love."

For a guy whose mouth stretches from one side of his to the other he can put on a hell of a frown. "I'm sorry to Bruce. I really have been trying to get that hole loose enough for you just well my dick keeps getting in the way of it. I'll try even harder from now though I promise."

"No you've done plenty enough to accommodate me and my fantasies in letting me treat you like a girl. I think it's about time I tried to get over things and did the work for a change Henry."

I can't believe my ears. Is he actually compromising with me? He's never done this before in all the time I've known him. "Ohh, okay. Umm did you have something particular in mind then Bruce?"

Shaking his finned head he says, "Nah, nothing concrete yet just can you give me a day to clear my head?" Nodding I agree to that. "Then tomorrow night I promise I'll have a surprise for you so that I can finally come to terms with all this. It's taken me way to long to get to this point and I'm sorry for that love. From tomorrow onwards, I promise I'll be with you all the way."

After saying probably the most romantic thing I've ever heard he just up and walks out the door not even waiting for a response. I don't know what to make of it so I just wind up going to bed.

I'm beside myself at work and by the time I get home I'm wringing my hands trying to figure things out in my head. Bruce hasn't responded to any of my texts or calls all day and he didn't come home this morning. Beside myself with worry I drop everything when I scent him inside the house. "Ohh, thank god Bruce you okay?"

"Yeah, I said I'd be back tonight. You didn't have reason to worry."

Breathing a sigh of relief I head to that voice, "I know but you could've responded just once- What the?" He's sitting on our couch completely naked and has rearranged the whole room leaving the centre blank except for the massage table. "Umm, what's this Bruce?"

"This is what I was saying yesterday. You want me to be comfortable with you as my partner so that's what I'm going to do today. For this is the only way I realized I'm going to be comfortable is if we have my girl completely bound to the bench otherwise I'm not going to be able to go through with it. I hope that's okay girl?"

Looking at the table and the ropes that he's got laid out I see that he's thought whatever he has planned all the way through. Now we've done a little bondage before. You know, my paws and hands but to be left completely bound by him? Do I trust him enough for that? "Okay so long as you give me your word that there will only be two dicks in my sheathe."

"I promise Love just like I did yesterday. This is all about getting me comfortable with you entirely girl. This I swear isn't only going to be for me. This is for our future together okay girl?" He doesn't look like he's lying at all. He only looks super excited for whatever it is he has planned.

"Well then how can your girl refuse you Bruce. So how did you want me set up?"

"That's the spirit. Now how about you get up on here and spread those muscled legs over the edge showing off that beautiful cunt of yours girl." Seeing him so excited with those twin throbbing dicks of his waving about I strip down to the panties he has me wear. Just as I'm about to lower those he changes his mind a little, "Hmm, actually keep those on. The red looks sexy as fuck against your white fur girl."

Giggling I do as he says, "You like them on me? They're new and I wore them just for you to see tonight love." Hooking my legs over the massage table I lie down so my full package is on display and try to settle down for this. "I'm really glad you like them as they hold my balls really well."

"Well, it'll be a shame to rip them off you but so worth it. Now let's get you tied down girl so I can get started on making a new life for us." The first thing he grabs is a set of handcuffs which he uses to cuff my paws under the table. We both know this one from experience, that just this makes it impossible for me to get out from. "Hmm, I always have loved seeing you shiver when I start binding you girl. Now for the legs."

"Yes make sure they're spread so you can see my cunt Bruce." I know he likes it when I call my sheath that. Even now it has him dripping as he loops rope over my paws and ties them together. Another length goes between my hands and feet and pulled tight I get hogtied to the bench stopping me from moving anywhere now.

"Hmmph, funny you should say that. I always thought I'd like you more with a cunt but right now I want to see your dick Henry. Get it hard for me would you? Knot and all."

"What you actually want to see it?" It's been so long since I got hard like that. "Umm, I'll try it's just been a while." Thinking about having his dicks in my ass is about the only thing that does it. Tied up like I am, it's not an issue thinking about him getting rough with me either which is a pretty good turn on too.

"Goood, that's a good bitch. Get hard for your boyfriend ya little fag." Ohh damn. He always starts calling me a fag when he sees it and fuck that makes me throb and leak like a damned faucet. Fully hard now all it takes is a single push on my sheath for that knot to pop out into the open. "I never got why you were a bottom bitch with a dick like this. The guys are gonna all cry when I tell them about it."

I don't know what he's thinking about as he starts stroking my dick but it feels so fucking good having him touch me like this that I'm about to blow already. Letting go just as my knot starts to grow he grabs another couple of lengths of rope. "Well, no way I'm taking that thing without tying you right down to the bench. Can't have you bucking while I do this."

Wait take it? "Are you-? Are you actually going to take my dick to get comfortable with it Bruce?" I can't believe he's going to actually bottom for me. That-that's like the most amazing turn of events ever.

Giving me that toothy grin all sharks have he says, "What other way do I have left to me fag? I don't want to lose you and as it is, I still can't stand the fucking sight of it. Can hardly believe I let my fin touch the fucking thing so I have no choice but to try this. I just hope we still love each other afterwards because you have to know I love you Henry. That's the only reason I'm considering doing this." Giving one more stroke of my dick he adds, "For us. All for us girl."

I can't help moaning as I feel that fin o his stroke over my dick. "I love you too but you don't have to do this to prove that. I don't want you to have to suffer something you hate for me." I really don't want that.

Cinching the rope about my waist he binds me to the bench until I can't move a bloody inch. For what he has planned however I'm not concerned. I'd rather he be as comfortable as possible if he really plans to take me. He looks slightly confused though at my words. "Me suffer? I thought you'd be more worried about your own suffering. Still I'm glad you're willing to go with me on this fag. To think after tonight I won't ever be able to call you that again."

"Are you going to lube it up for me love? It'll be easier for you to take if you do. A lot easier."

"Wait what?" He looks really confused at that trying to process what I mean. "Wait you didn't think... You didn't actually think I meant taking your dick up my... Fuck me girl you're thick sometimes. I'd never even think of doing something so fucking sick."

"What? What do you mean then?" I ask going from intoxicated by lust to stone cold sober in less than a second. Then when he pulls a pair of loppers up from next to the lounge that sobriety turns to a bone chilling fear. "OH, FUCK NO! GET THOSE FUCKING THINGS AWAY FROM ME!"

"Shhh, shhh, shhh Girl. It's all gonna be alright." He whispers as I keep screaming trying anything to loosen the binding. "FUCK NO IT'S NOT. IF YOU DON'T STOP I'M GONNA KILL YOU BRUCE. WE'RE DONE, OVER, FINISHED NOW GET THE FUCK AWAY FROM ME!"

I don't know what the fuck he could possibly be thinking as he sits them around my shaft under my knot. "Shh, Girl. I promise without this disgusting twig of yours we'll both be happier. I've even got a jar to preserve it in so we can make a dildo for you afterwards."

"ARE YOU FUCKING SICK? BRUCE LET ME FUCKING GO!"

"It's okay girl. We're both about to get the cunt we deserve. I know you want that deep down just like I do."

Putting two fins on the long handles I see it all happening in my mind before he even presses on those handles and I try one last time to convince him to not go through with this. "Please Bruce. Don't do this. You can tear my sheath open to get in from now on just please don't cut my dick off."

Shaking his head the shark's shoulders tense as he finalises my fate. "No girl. I don't want to hurt you. I love you too much for that so we both need a cunt between your legs not a filthy faggy dick. Say goodbye to it bitch. I'll put it back in you later though."

"No stop Bruce- AAARRRRRRROOOOOOOO!!!" Howling I feel those blades cut into my most sensitive of areas and watching those shoulders tense when they hit bone I begin to gag. Gagging like I never have I feel them get removed and sink lower into my sheath and start again. They start right under my penile bone and with a wet crunching noise I feel him shatter tendons and muscle.

He looks so fucking happy doing it too as blood begins to pour from my sheathe about my still, if barely attached dick ,as it flops around when he removes those shears. I howl again when a serrated blade gets shoved inside my sheath and with a burning cut I feel him slice the last flaps of skin and muscles away. "YES! See now you'll make a perfect girl for me Henry."

Looking up I can hardly believe that he'd wag that dripping bloody thing in front of me right now. Still knotted up it seems to pulse it's own last few seconds of life in front of my eyes before he takes it away while I howl and cry at my loss. Climbing up on top of the bench the shark has hold of both his dicks only to kiss me.

I'm so lost to the agony that I don't register for a few seconds that I'm naturally kissing him back like I always do until he pulls away. Looking down he lines up both of his dicks with my still bleeding sheath. "Never let a period stop me before girl and I did promise only two dicks would be in your cunt. We just had to make room for me." Sinking both shafts in I hear it but don't believe my ears. "Happy birthday girl." My ears hear those moans I make as he enters and to think I thought he forgot my birthday.

"Now we can both be happy forever." He says as his balls hit right into mine and I'm actually thankful that he at least left me with those as they tense up. Mind blown I moan louder than before as those shafts fill me and I experience the best orgasm of my entire life.

Okay maybe being a cuntboy won't be so bad if he lets me keep those at least.