Truth or Dare

Story by Experiment626 on SoFurry

, , , , , , , , , , ,

A night at home without the parents around is interrupted when Kyle (a fairly innocent bunny) has his plans for a quiet night interrupted by his older sister and her friends.


Because I'm sure no one has made a story about a game of truth or dare before or simply named their story Truth or Dare...

As with a lot of my stories, this contains watersports. As you may have noticed, it tends to be a favorite fetish of mine.

It began as such a normal night...

"Alright Kyle, it's just you and your sister for the weekend. We left some money for pizza on the counter and if you need us, the number for the lodge is on the fridge."

"Yeah, ok mom" the otter replied dismissively.

His mother walked over and put a hand on his shoulder to get his attention. "Just make sure your sister stays out of trouble. Your father and I will only be gone until tomorrow night, but you know how she can be."

Kyle knew exactly how his sister could be. At two years older than him, Cindy made Kyle feel like the older sibling because he was always more responsible. His 19-year old sister seemed to welcome trouble in everything that she did. Constant problems at school, caught smoking and partying, several boyfriends already - and none of them savory. What he didn't know is what his mom thought he could do about it - it's not like Cindy listened to him any more than their parents.

"Ok mom. I'll do my best." he said with convincing, albeit fake, enthusiasm.

"Thank you, baby!"

And with that, she turned and walked out of the room and shortly after he heard the front door close and then his parents car pull away.

Not even a half hour later, Kyle hears a knock at the front door and goes to answer it. Just as he's opening the door he hears his sister shout out "it's for me, loser." As he looks through the open door he sees Cindy's best friends (and worst influences) Yasmine and Jeannette. Jeannette was a female horse that was a bit taller than Cindy at 5'11" and was a very well-endowed woman. She was also the "muscle" of the group, and was not shy in any measurable way. Yasmine, on the other hand, was the exact opposite. She was a shy and petite bat girl standing at only 5'4" and had a slim build and modest, but not flat, chest. She was very quiet and the only one of Cindy's friends from when she was a young and nice girl who remained her friend after she developed her rebellious streak.

Cindy came into the hallway to round out the trio. She was a boisterous loudmouth and loved being the center of attention. Being a rabbit like Kyle, she had white, fluffy fur which she frequently dyed other colors and long floppy ears. She was also very slender and athletic. If it weren't for her devil-may-care attitude, she'd probably be more attractive. Although she never seemed to have trouble finding suitors so maybe Kyle was biased against her as her brother.

"Alright, you answered the door; Good boy!" Cindy said condescendingly and patted Kyle's head for extra insult. "Now go back to your room and finish playing by yourself."

"Or with yourself!" Jeannette added with a wink.

"Oh great, I was hoping you would come over and ruin my night" Kyle said looking at Jeanette. "At least you're not a bitch Yasmine, so there might be some sanity tonight" Kyle said before wandering back toward his room.

The girls went into Cindy's room, presumably to plot this evening's mayhem and smoke pot. Kyle just shrugged and closed his door.

Some amount of time later, there was a knock at Kyle's door.

"Yeah?" Kyle answered.

"Come out here!" he heard Cindy shout from the other side.

"Why would I do that?"

"Oh my god, just get your ass out here - Jesus!"

Kyle groaned and then got up and opened the door. Cindy grabbed his arm and half dragged him to her room. When he got there he saw the other two girls sitting indian style on the floor and Cindy soon plopped down with them,leaving enough room for him to join their circle.

"We're playing Truth or Dare" Cindy stated. "Sit down, it's your turn!"

"I don't think it is because I'm not playing!" Kyle said and turned to leave.

"Like hell you aren't!" she replied and then jumped up and grabbed him. "I was dared to get you to play and I never turn down a dare so sit down and stop being a pussy!" She leaned hard on his shoulders and muscled him to the floor. "Besides, it's not like any other cute girls are inviting you to hang out with them!"

"Wait, there are cute girls here? Where?!" Kyle said and then emphatically looked around as if there were someone else hiding in the room.

"Haha, yeah. So funny..." Jeanette said. "But your sister finished her dare and now it's your turn - so, truth or dare?"

"Truth, I guess." Kyle responded.

"Alright then..." Cindy started and then trailed off. She stared at her friends for a minute and then turned her attention to him. "Which of my friends would you rather sleep with?"

"What the fuck?" Kyle exclaimed, instantly blushing. "This is why I don't want to play with you!"

Kyle started to move to leave but Cindy grabbed him and held him down. "Oh my god, just answer the question. Stop being a drama queen about everything. You're basically an adult now, you can admit to finding people attractive. It isn't the end of the world, Princess!"

"Fine!" Kyle said, annoyed that she constantly belittled and challenged him like that. He hesitated for a moment at the awkward pressure of the situation but then answered "Yasmine" quietly.

The bat took her turn to blush, which Kyle would have found cute if he weren't currently trying to avert his eyes from any member of the trio. Jeanette of course made the situation worse by chiming in with "Ha! I knew it! That's ok, you couldn't handle all this horsepower anyway!"

Kyle groaned and wondered how many times she'd used that cheesy line before to have it come to her so quickly.

"Alright Kyle, your turn - pick someone and then they'll pick truth or dare." Jeanette explained.

"Yes Jeanette, I do actually know how the game works. It's all kind of right there in the title. And since you're so eager to jump in and explain, why don't you go?"

"Alright short stuff, truth!" the horse responded.

Kyle hated when she called him that. He was only an inch shorter than the horse, and taller by a few inches than either other girl. "So just how many guys have you slept with at this point?" he asked, hoping to shut her up or at least make her uneasy.

Jeanette surprised him by instantly replying "12, and two girls!"

"You whore!" Cindy exclaimed with a laugh while failing to maintain a fake look of indignance. She then squirmed a little and settled back into position.

"Oh yeah, then it's your turn again - truth or dare?" Jeanette responded to Cindy.

"Hit me with another dare! I'm not scared of you!"

"Ok fine. But it's gotta be something good!" Jeanette replies and then ponders for a second as Cindy squirms in place again. "Ok, since you obviously have to pee, why not do it here? You can use the glass Yasmine was drinking out of!" Jeanette says before snatching up the glass and handing it to Cindy.

"Hey!" Yasmine protests.

"Ew, what?!" Kyle replies to Jeanette's preposterous dare.

Cindy shoots him a glance and then stands up and deftly yanks down her pajama pants.

"Woah, seriously?" Kyle says in disbelief. "You're piss in front of everybody? In a glass that people drink from?!"

"Relax, the glass can get washed, baby! And I'm not refusing a dare so just deal with it!" She didn't pause any longer before holding the glass to her mound. She spread her lips open with her free hand and almost immediately a yellow stream burst out of her and started filling the glass.

Despite his initial objections, Kyle found himself unable to look away as his sister peed into the glass. He'd seen her naked plenty of times since she was a bit of a partier and always seemed to be drunk or high - both of which tended to end up in her naked. And she was never too shy about just walking around the house in the nude whenever her parents were out. Luckily both other girls also seemed to be too distracted by the show to notice his staring so no one called him out on it.

Cindy continued filling the glass and then cut off her stream as it was nearly full. As she moved the glass away a stray couple drops dribbled from her lips and soaked into the surrounding fur. Kyle noticed from the too close position he was in that the pee didn't seem to be the only source of wetness for his sister. It seemed like she enjoyed putting on the show.

"I still have to go but this is just about full so I'll hold the rest for now." Cindy stated as she set the glass down. She didn't even waste time pulling her pants back up before turning to Jeanette "your turn again, bitch!" she shot out with a devious smile.

Yasmine made a noise of discontent and Kyle assumed she had been mostly ignored in this game even before he came in. "Yeah, it's fine - you two just play the game and Yasmine and I can sit here and be bored and disgusted by you!" he teased.

"Oh don't worry Yasmine, you'll be next! And go ahead and dare me - I guess you earned it with that." Jeanette responded to Cindy.

"Good! Then why don't you strip down and have a piss right here too!" Cindy said with a grin.

"Wow, way to be original! Really thought outside the box on that one." Jeanette replied and then stood up and started stripping.

She pulled her shirt off over her head as Yasmine chimed in "Well you shouldn't dish it out if you can't take it!"

Jeanette looked down at the still seated bat who was now sticking her tongue out. "I don't need lip from the peanut gallery!" She then undid and removed her pants and panties.

She then stood with her legs spread and before anyone knew what was happening, a stream of urine started shooting out from the horses's slit.

"Holy shit, Jeanette - there are more glasses." Cindy replied, her fake annoyance quickly being exposed as she started to laugh.

"Hey, you just said to piss here - this is your fault!" some of the stream was trickled down Jeanette's pale brown leg fur as the main flow streamed straight down and splattered on the carpet, created a puddle and sending droplets bouncing off the floor. Kyle and Yasmine both backed up slightly to avoid the spray while Cindy stayed planted where she was, grinning and making defiant eye contact with the horse.

"Oh, don't mind getting a little wet and dirty?" With that the horse didn't even wait for a reply and used her fingers to quickly spread her lips and then pull her splayed opening up, aiming her stream right at Cindy.

The rabbit didn't even flinch as the stream moved up and hit her in the chest, streaming down the front of her shirt and pooling on the floor beneath her own exposed crotch and bare legs.

"This is getting weird" Kyle said out loud.

In truth, he actually couldn't stop watching the girl pee. Watching his sister piss was a bit of a turn on, despite it being his sister, but watching this other girl piss in front of him - and onto another woman to boot - well he couldn't really contain how much he was getting turned on. He had never seen anything like this, not even in the little bit of porn he had watched in his past, and now to witness it all only a few feet from him - it was insane. And moreso, it was HOT!

As his sister continued to sit right in front of Jeanette's relentless stream, her shirt became so drenched that the thin white material became basically transparent and her erect nipples were visible and obvious underneath the material. What's more, as the stream started to subside, Cindy reached up and put her hand in the path of the stream. When it slowed to a trickle and then stopped entirely, Cindy rubbed Jeanette's wet slit and then quickly stuck her wet finger in her mouth.

"Ok, this is nuts. I'm out!" Kyle exclaimed, hoping he sounded convincing so he could excuse himself from the room before his growing erection became obvious to the girls. He quickly stood up and turned toward the door hoping they wouldn't notice the tent in his shorts.

"Are you sure?" Jeanette said slowly "it's Yasmine's turn now. Don't you want to see what happens to your girlfriend?"

"Ugh..." Kyle responded. He wanted to leave but he really did find the bat girl cute and if there was a chance she'd be putting on a similar show he had to see that. He wasn't sure how everyone was going to react when they saw his current condition but he decided it would be worth it to possibly get an erotic show from Yasmine. Besides, how could that be worse than getting pissed on by your friend?

"Fine!" Kyle says in mock protest and turns around and tries to quickly sit down but Jeanette of course sees his erection.

"Oh, enjoying the show are you? Or are you excited at the thought of Yasmine peeing too?" the horse asked with a grin on her face.

"Yeah, big shocker - naked girls make guys hard. What a discovery Jeanette!" Kyle replied trying to make light of the situation.

"'Girls' as in plural?" Cindy chimes in. "So I'm making you horny too, Kyle? Me your sweet and innocent sister?" She says while coyly running her hand along his leg and up to his thigh.

"God you're weird!" he replies and pushes her hand away. "Can we just get on with your game?"

"Fine!" Jeanette interjects. "Yasmine, I dare you to strip naked too - wouldn't want Mr. fluffy buns here to get blueballed!"

"She didn't even choose dare!" Kyle protested more out of reflex than anything. He regretted instantly that he just fought to have Yasmine not remove her clothes.

"It's all good." she replied, acting less shy than usual. Kyle suspected the few presumably empty cans of alcohol near where she was sitting were responsible for that. "I would have picked dare anyway."

With that the bat stood up. She wasted no time in drawing her shirt up over her head. Despite being on the smaller side, Kyle loved the way her breasts looked and seeing them now fully uncovered was just too much. They looked so firm that he was just dying to touch them. He was so entranced by them that he didn't even avert his gaze when she finished taking off her shirt. She giggled and then undid and removed her pants. Unlike Jeanette, she had no panties to remove and as soon as her pants came down Kyle saw her beautiful slit surrounded by very short black fur and it was all he could do to not leap across the room. He wanted so badly to touch it and lick it and fuck it. He didn't even have to look down to know that his cock was fully erect and most obvious by now.

"Well Kyle, since you saw me. I think it's only fair that you strip too now!" Yasmine says with a laugh.

Kyle snaps out of his trance instantly at that.

"Hell, we already know you're hard, may as well let us see what you're packing!" Jeanette chimes in.

"Classy as always, Jeanette" Cindy adds with a roll of her eyes. "Well, go on! We used to skinnydip in the river in the woods all the time - not like I haven't seen it before!"

Kyle made a scoffing sound at his sister and shot back "that was five years ago!" before then turning his gaze away from Yasmine and pulling off his shirt and shorts. He knew the cute bat was probably staring at him but feeling now suddenly exposed his libido took a hit and he couldn't bring himself to look her in the eye.

"Damn!" he then heard her exclaim.

"Yeah" Jeanette agreed. "Cindy, your brother is fucking hung!"

Cindy replied "good for him" while trying to sound disinterested. But Kyle did notice that she was staring the same place he assumed the other girls were.

When he looked up he saw that the two other girls were also both staring at the huge rod between his legs.

Suddenly Yasmine takes a bold step forward and tells the other girls to hold him down. They quickly agree while laughing and grab him and pull him to the floor.

Yasmine then stands over him, one leg on either side of his body, and Kyle stares up with an amazing view of perfect crotch. His erection is achingly hard as she moves her hand down and starts rubbing her clit and sliding her fingers between her lips. She then pushes two fingers inside and starts masturbating while he looks on ravenously.

Then she removed her hand and in what was, but should not have been, a surprise - she started peeing. Kyle instantly felt a wet warmth as her stream landed on his thighs and stiffened member. The feeling was incredible and he couldn't believe that the girl he had been wanting to fuck for quite some time was now strandling him naked and pissing on him. She stepped forward and her stream of urine moved up his body and was now hitting him in the chest and running down his sides.

His sister and Jeanette were both giggling to themselves as the yellow liquid ran in rivers down his fur, leaving yellow streaks staining his sides.

Yasmine then stepped forward again and her stream now started hitting Kyle in the neck. Without hesitating to think, Kyle opened his mouth and tilted his head down so that Yasmine was pissing straight into his mouth. He no longer cared what the other girls would think. The taste was slightly bitter and acrid, but also wonderful and incredibly sexy. The warmth of her piss filling his mouth was an amazing feeling and before he started to gag he closed his mouth and swallowed what had pooled there. With his mouth now closed Yasmine's stream, still going strong, bounced off his face, splashing in all directions around him and soaking all the white fur of his face.

It was at that time that Jeanette seemed to be confident that Kyle no longer needed to be restrained. She let go of his arm and then moved herself down his body. Kyle couldn't see her but suddenly knew exactly where she was as she took his entire cock down to the base in her mouth.

She let out a soft moan as she sucked and licked all the piss and precum from his shaft.

Kyle opened his mouth again and exhaled sharply in surprise and pleasure at Jeanette's action - only to be greeted by Yasmine's hot piss again. Her stream started to slow so Yasmine squatted down, allowing her to be sure that none of the rest of her fluids went anywhere but Kyle's mouth.

Kyle took this as the invitation he was hoping for and moved his head up and forced his tongue into Yasmine's mound. She grabbed his head with both hands and made grinding moves as he sucked down the last of her piss and then began licking every last drop of pee from her. He then pushed his tongue inside her and tasted a different flavor - the other fluids her body produced, letting him know that she was as turned on as he was.

He started then focusing his licking on her clit and she grabbed his head harder, using his long ears to tug him in the direction she wanted him to go as he sucked, licked, and gently bit her button.

All the while, Jeanette continued expertly sucking off Kyle's huge member.

He worked quickly and relentlessly to bring Yasmine to a climax and soon her heavy breathing became a sharp inhale and then a loud shriek as she came hard. More juices flowed from her as the bat's claws dug into the rabbit's ears and she grinded his face and tongue. Her orgasm was more than enough to push Kyle over the top and without being able to utter a warning, he bucked his hips up, thrusting himself entirely into the horse's eager maw and came down her throat. She gagged but welcomed his seed and withdrew only enough to grab the base of his dick with her hand while she suckled his cock, not spilling a single drop of his cum.

After Jeanette stopped, Yasmine stood up from Kyle's face. She turned to her horse friend and said "let me taste that bunny cum" and then kissed her hungrily, forcing her tongue into Jeanette's mouth.

After enjoying the kiss for a minute, Jeanette pulled her head away and replied "no, since you got your chance from the bunny, I think you need to give me my turn now!" and then laid on her back on the carpet that was now thoroughly soaked.

Yasmine didn't hesitate at all before getting on her knees and leaning down, quickly using her tongue to lick the horse between her legs.

Kyle saw the bat in front of him with her cute butt up in the air and both her holes completely exposed. He started to get hard again at the sight.

"Before that brother" Cindy started from behind him "why don't you return the favor to Yasmine? You are the only one who hasn't pissed yet and I'm sure you have to."

Kyle hadn't even thought about his own bladder with the constant show the girls were putting on but he realized that he had drank a bit earlier and hadn't gone in a while and could certainly relieve himself now.

Kyle got up on his knees and moved to the side of the two girls. He grabbed his cock in his hand and was about to start peeing when Cindy came over and knelt behind him.

"Here, let me help!" she said before reaching around and grabbing his member, pushing his hand away.

Kyle no longer cared about the depravity of his sister holding his dick and he relaxed himself, letting loose a sudden spray of piss.

At first his stream fell short and started soaking the carpet but Cindy adjusted her aim so that the horse received a good soaking on her large breasts. With her hands free, Jeanette started massaging her own breasts and pinching and teasing her nipples as Kyle's strong stream washed over her.

She continued to tease herself as Cindy pointed her brother's cock away and down at the girl's pelvis, soaking her crotch and Yasmine's face fur.

The bat never stopped nibbling the horse's clit as the urine began to run over her twat and into the bat's open mouth. Yasmine used her tongue to lick up some of Kyle's piss and then stuck it deep inside Jeanette's winking, wet pussy.

The horse let out an excited whinny and Cindy giggled before pointing Kyle in one last direction. She arced his stream up and into Jeanette's open mouth.

The horse happily drank down the salty mouthfuls of piss as she started to buck her hips. The bat dug her claws in and grabbed the horse's sides hard as she moved her head with her, not withdrawing her tongue from Jeanette's hole.

Finally the horse came and squirted a spray of milky girlcum onto Yasmine's tongue and face.

Yasmine, satisfied with her work, then turned to the rabbits. As Kyle's stream started to slow she grabbed Cindy's hand and pointed Kyle's cock at her own mouth. She took his member into his mouth and drank down the last of his piss. When his stream stopped completely, she released him and said "enough games - I want you to fuck me!" and then laid down in front of him.

Kyle needed no further instruction and immediately forced himself into Yasmine's already wet slit. As he did, her insides felt tight and hot and amazing and he had to focus hard to not cum right away after only his first thrust.

Cindy then came around and stood over the bat. "I've been left out so far, so since you're fucking my two best friends, you need to let me try that tongue of yours, brother!"

Her calling him brother someone made the invitation even more perverted and naughty and in this context, that only turned Kyle on more so he leaned forward and started to go to work with his mouth on Cindy's snatch.

As he did, she released the rest of her bladder from earlier and pissed into her brother mouth.

He was glad to have Cindy as a distraction and he tried to devote his attention to working her with his tongue while he thrust himself into the petite, horny bat beneath him. Cindy's piss was flowing out of his mouth and down his chin, dribbling onto his chest and Yasmine's pelvis, lubricating her even more and adding a bit of extra warmth to his cock every time Kyle's pulled back to thrust again.

"This is so hot, let me in!" Jeanette cried before kneeling over Yasmine's face. The bat once again starting licking the horse, who in turn leaned forward and stuck her tongue unexpectedly against Cindy's tailhole.

Cindy let out a squeak and jumped slightly at this intrusion, but then reached back with a hand and grabbed the back of the horse's head as she continued to lick her ass.

Kyle's tongue flicked against Jeanette's as he ate out his sister. In his mind he tried to picture the scene from someone else's point of view - all three girls and him tangled up in an orgy of piss and sex, all of them soaked and smelly and horny. He let go of Yasmine with one hand and used it to stick two fingers into Cindy's pussy.

The bunny girl squeaked again and Jeanette, seeing Kyle, did the same but forcing her fingers instead up the rabbit's tailhole, all the while still licking around her opening.

As Cindy started to bounce up and down, working the fingers in and out of her openings, she started to squeal with each thrust and soon cried out in ecstasy as she had a powerful orgasm.

Kyle then decided to stop putting it off and grabbed Yasmine's hips with both hands. He pushed deep into the bat, who let out a soft moan from under the horse's ass.

He was about to cum when he had second thoughts and quickly pulled out. He then lifted the bat up slightly and forced himself instead into her tailhole. Yasmine let out a small cry of pain, followed by a sighing moan of pleasure as Kyle filled her ass with his meat. He used the thumb on his right hand the tease her clit as he thrusted quickly a few times and then pushed himself deep into the rabbit's hind end and came once more.

Jets of seed spewed from him, coating the inside of the bat girl's ass as she continued to lick feverishly at the horse still sitting on her face. In unison Jeanette and Yasmine both then started to cry out in moans of pleasure as they each came from the stimulation they were receiving.

Soon all four off the teen furs collapsed onto the floor, covered in sweat, piss, and cum. They all lay in a pile for a moment, each of them feeling too content to move when finally Cindy sat upright first.

"I can't believe that all just happened" Kyle muttered aloud.

"I can't believe Yasmine and I waited this long to fuck you." Jeanette responded. "You could have told us he was hung like..." she trailed off.

"Like a horse!" Yasmine finished with a laugh.

"I didn't really realize" Cindy replied "or else I probably would have just fucked him instead of half those losers at school!"

Kyle was somehow still surprised as the brashness of his sister and something caught her attention and she started to laugh.

The other three looked over as Cindy picked up the glass containing some of her piss from earlier.

"Oh, we better clean this glass Kyle - wouldn't want to gross you out!" she said teasingly.

Kyle grabbed the glass from her and quickly poured all its contents into his mouth. He then grabbed Cindy and pushed his mouth to hers, kissing her and spitting half the liquid back into her mouth.

He then swallowed what was left in his maw before replying "you're plenty gross enough, I don't think that glass will bother me!" with a laugh and a grin.

"Ok" Jeanette started as she and Yasmine sat up as well. "So what do we do now?" she asked, followed by a devilish grin spreading on everyone's face.