You Lose

Story by Aren19 on SoFurry

, , , , , , , , , , ,

Holy balls! This story has about 6 pages of smut! I guess it's to make up for my previous story submissions this month lacking in them, huh? Well, I hope you guys enjoy!


Hey, you Peter?

Yeah? And you are...?

James. I'm a linebacker for Stateview University. You've probably seen me.

Not really.

Wha-Anyway, I heard you're one of the best gamers.

I don't think I am.

I want to test my luck against you. I'll let you do anything you want to me.

GULP! I-I-How-

Come by my dorm later, room 224 and we'll play. See you!

That was almost three months ago. Peter and James have been playing one match a day. They've been switching between James's dorm room and Peter's parents' house. Today, the match is at Peter's house, a simple suburban house with a swanky living room, leather couch, and 49 inch TV.

At the moment, James has 49 straight losses; he has yet to beat Peter once. "Fuck!" The black wolf throws his controller at the wall beside the TV. The controller makes a slight dent.

"Hey!" The grey rabbit turns towards the wolf slouching on his couch. "I told you no more throwing your controller, James! My parents will kill me."

"Peter, relax. I barely threw it that time. If I wanted to make a dent, I would."

"Not exactly comforting to hear." Peter pulls his phone out and looks over his notes. "So that makes fifty straight losses. You owe me one blowjob."

James sinks further in the couch. His white tank top bunches up in the back and his black jeans get pulled up. He puts a paw over his face and rubs his eyes. "And after that is you fucking me, right?" James points at Peter and then back at himself.

Peter scrolls down in his notes. "Not quite. That's 100 losses. At 75 the loser rims the winner. I wouldn't worry too much; there's still plenty of time to make a comeback."

James picks himself up. "I appreciate the vote of confidence, but I haven't beaten you once at Road Beater V at all. I give up."

Peter's ears perked up, snapping the ponytail he uses for his ears in half. "You know what that means, right?"

James looks at Peter and raises an eyebrow. "No? It's been months since we made this bet and we only get to play this once a day."

Peter giggles and climbs over the wolf. He grabs James's chin, tilts him up to the rabbit, and leans into him. "Our forfeit rules state that you have to suffer through everything again AND I get to fuck you." Peter kisses James.

"What!" James grabs Peter and throws him on the couch. He grabs the rabbit's phone and looks over the notes. The forfeit rule was on the bottom, past the fucking condition. "No no no no! I don't want to go through that again!"

"Well, you have to. We signed it on the bottom." Peter presses his body against James and scrolls past the forfeit rule to their signatures.

"Fuck me."

"Not yet." Peter pokes the wolf's nose. "First there's kissing, then nipple play. paw job, foot job, frotting, blow job, rim job, and then fucking. You're my plaything to please me."

James buries his face in his paws, hiding his blush. "Arrrrrrrgh!"

Peter places his paw on James's back and rubs it. "Don't worry. As I said, no one at school will know." Peter kisses James's cheek.

James raises his head and turns towards Peter. He leans in and Peter leans forward. Their lips lock and Peter snakes his tongue into James's mouth. He feels over each sharp fang with his tongue. The rabbit rubs over James's chest. James tries scooting away, but the rabbit keeps him in place with his paw. Peter breaks away from the kiss and the two stare in each other's eyes.

"First loss - A kiss from the winner." Peter pushes James down onto the couch and straddles him. Peter takes off his red polo shirt and scoots closer to James, sitting on his chest. "Five losses - Play with the winner's nipples."

James gulps and stares at Peter's perky nips. The pink nubs are surrounded by grey fur. James closes his eyes. Just imagine him as a girl, like before. He reaches up, his paws shaking, and rubs Peter's pecs. The rabbit squirms in the wolf's embrace. His khaki pants tent up from the slight play. James pinches Peter's nipples and twists them. Peter closes his eyes.

"Ahhhhh~ Okay, James, that's enough." James doesn't listen and shuts his eyes tighter. He twists them some more. He twists in the other direction. Peter opens his mouth. "Ahhh, GAME OVER!"

James stops, opens his eyes and moves his paws away. "Peter, are you okay? I'm so sorry!"

Peter gasps and pants. He places his paws on James's chest to support himself. "I'm glad we put in a safe word. I'm ready to move on, you remember what it was, right?"

"Yeah, yeah." James travels down Peter's chest to his stomach and stops at the button and zipper of the khakis. "Ten losses - Give the winner a paw job." James can hear his heartbeat in his ears. It won't be easy to imagine Peter as a girl for much longer. He unzips the rabbit's pants and fishes out his cock. James blushes, his heart beating harder and faster. He wraps his hands around the seven-inch meat and strokes it. He can feel his face turn red.

"Aww, look at you." Peter reaches down and rubs James's head, messing up his short, red hair. James closes his eyes and Peter takes his hand away. Peter leans back, his cock expanding from his pants and giving James more room to work with.

Just imagine it's yours, minus the knot. James grips Peter's dick and moves his paws up and down. He wiggles his fingers around, giving Peter the sensation that multiple people are working on his member. This always works on me. Maybe it'll work on him. Peter leans back further, grabbing onto James's thighs. The rabbit moves his hands up and touches James through his clothes. James's eyes shoot open. "Game over!"

Peter moves his hands away from James's crotch and puts them in the air. "Sorry, I thought you wanted to feel good too." Peter looks down at James. His face is bright red. James releases Peter's dick and buries his face. Peter leans down and rubs James's face, but he moves away.

James takes a deep breath and moves his hands back to Peter's cock. "I'm sorry, let's keep going." He closes his eyes. Fuck! I can't do this! James's ears twitch. He hears and feels his pants unzipping. He opens his eyes and sees Peter fish out his sheath, balls, and semi-hard red dick.

Peter looks back at James and gets up. "So you're not so cramped. Just in case, anyway. Besides, I think I'm done with your paws. Let's use your feet! Remember: 20 losses - Give the winner a foot job." Peter sits on the far end of the couch and grabs James's feet. He pulls them towards his hard, leaking dick and places them both in between it.

God this was so awkward the first time. James sandwiches his feet together and rubs the leaking member up and down. Peter winces and tenses up. "Peter? You okay?"

"Grahh! It's a little rough, but so was your first time doing it. I'm okay, keep going." Despite what he says, James can feel Peter's dick getting limp. He moves his feet in one direction, but his feet respond by going in opposite directions. Peter shut his eyes tight. James moves his feet away. "James? I didn't say Game Over. Keep going."

"You're not getting pleased. Besides, um, I think I'm ready to move on." James looks away. Seeing Peter laid all out in front of him has gotten him excited. His dick is halfway out of his sheath. Peter looks at it, drooling a bit. It's the first time he's ever seen James's cock.

"Um, yeah, we can definitely move on. What was next?" Peter swings his legs behind him and crawls towards James. James blushes and looks around the room, avoiding Peter's hungry gaze. Without thinking, Peter reaches out for James's cock and grips it. James gasps and closes his eyes.

"Mmmph, um, frottage, I think?" It's hard for James to speak with his junk being handled with such gentle hands. Peter pulls his hands away from James. "Why did you stop?"

Peter scoots closer to James until their dicks touch. He looks at James in the eyes while James looks away again. "Because I didn't lose." Peter grabs James's paw and places it along with their dicks. He helps James move his paw along their shafts. James closes his eyes.

"Awoooo!" James lets go of their dicks and clasps his mouth. He's never howled like that before. Peter laughs. "I-it's not funny!"

"I'm sorry! I just found that incredibly cute." Peter grabs James's paws and holds them over their pulsing dicks.

James finally looks into Peter's eyes. He leans forward and presses his forehead on Peter's. Peter blushes. "No one has ever made me do that before." Peter shivers. He wraps his arms around the big wolf and hugs him right. This doesn't feel too bad. Feels almost right. James moves his head and looks down at his dick. He can already see the knot forming. He's enjoying this.

James takes a deep breath and resumes his duty. He wraps his paw around both dicks and moves his paw. He massages the heads with his thumb and uses his other paw to fondle Peter's balls. Peter leans back and releases James from his hug. James swiftly moves his ball fondling paw and catches Peter's back. He pulls the rabbit into a kiss and forces his tongue into Peter's mouth.

Caught off guard, Peter opens his eyes wide and moans into the kiss. The two made out while James's paw moves down their shafts. His paw bumps against his knot, he's close. He could tell James is close too with how hard his heartbeat was going through his cock. Peter pulls away from James. "G-g-game over."

James struggles to move his paw away from the two members. He lets go of them, but keeps his paw near the two cocks, feeling the heat coming off them. "Too much?"

Peter shakes his head. "Not really, but I don't want to cum yet. We still have a lot to go through. We're about to approach unfamiliar territory. Are you ready?"

James looks down. His cock bobs with his heartbeat and James's bobs opposite of his. His dick is going to be in my mouth. James keeps staring at Peter's seven-inch length.

Peter scoots back on the couch, panting. James's gaze follows the bouncing cock. "Just give me a few, James." James nods and leans forward. He lays down on the couch and puts his legs behind him. His vision completely surrounded by Peter's cock. James sticks his tongue out and licks the underside of Peter's cock. Peter gasps and looks down at James.

"I, I'm ready if you are." Peter nods. What the hell do I do now? I guess what all my exes used to do? James sniffs Peter's balls and licks them. He opens his big mouth and takes the orbs inside. He licks all over them, getting a good taste for them, and rolling them around with his tongue.

Peter curls his toes. He's never played with his balls before and neither has anyone else. He reaches down and pets James's head, playing with his ears. James releases Peter's balls and gives each one a kiss. He travels up the side of Peter's cock, giving it kisses along the way to the tip. He licks the pool of precum forming in the slit. He coughs a bit, it's bitter! Peter giggles. "On the bright side, I don't want to cum in your mouth."

"Wonderful." James opens his mouth and takes the head of Peter's shaft inside. 50 losses - a blowjob from the loser. He closes his mouth around the head and sucks on it. He cups his tongue and licks the underside. Peter moves his paws from James's ears towards the top of his head. He pushes James down, making the wolf take more than what he was ready for. James coughs and spits the dick out.

"Are you okay?" Peter looks down at James, who meets him eye to eye.

"I've never sucked a dick before, Peter. So let me go at my own pace, please." James coughs again, swallowing any spit that might have gotten caught.

"I know, sorry. It's just, with that tongue, it's making me think you've done it before." Peter rubs the top of James's head. James dives back towards Peter's cock and takes the head back in his mouth. He licks around the whole head and takes more of Peter's shaft in his mouth, sucking every inch that went inside.

Peter closes his eyes, still rubbing James's head. His cock pulses in James's mouth, leaking precum inside it. James swallows on instinct. This isn't as bad as it was before. Am I liking this? James reaches down to his own cock and grips it. He moans around Peter's cock and moves his paw along his shaft, squeezing the expanding knot.

"Game over!" Peter shouts. James takes the rabbit's cock out of his mouth, coughing slightly. His hand is still on his dick, fapping fast and away at it. Peter pants and looks down at James's throbbing member. It takes all of his current strength to knock James's big, furry paw away.

"Were you about to cum?" James looks at Peter. Peter's cock wasn't throbbing nearly as hard as last time. Peter points down at James's cock and James sees his cock pulse, a bead of cum slips through the head.

"No, but you were. I want us to cum at the same time and we have to wait with one more position before we fuck." Peter scoots forward and lays on his back. He lifts his legs in the air, his cheeks spreading out for James. "75th loss - the loser has to rim the winner. No touching yourself this time."

James nods and looks at the expanding and retracting hole. Peter is ready for dick, but that's not his job. It's just like eating a girl out. James lays on his stomach. "Ahhh~" He blushes and buries his face in Peter's crack to hide his face.

Peter laughs. "Is your dick too sensitive? My couch is a good boyfriend to-AHHH!" James sneaks his tongue into Peter's rear end. Peter gasps as his ass is invaded. James licks around inside the hole. He inches his face closer as his tongue dives deeper inside.

Peter reaches down to his dick but stops as he feels the heat coming off it. He wants this to last as long as he can. He knows that this will never happen again. James's tongue is making it hard to ignore his twitching member, drooling pre down the length. He looks at James. He only sees the top of his head but notices his ass moving against the couch.

Peter watches it move and jiggle with each thrust James gives the couch. He blushes, he wants that to be him. Peter sighs and leans back against the couch's arm. James retreats from Peter's ass and gives the pucker one final lick. "Peter?

"Hmm?" Peter raises his head and looks at James.

"I...I'm ready for you to take me." James stands up and takes his shirt off. He unbuttons his pants and pushes his pants and underwear slightly down past his balls. His ripped body glistens in the room. James lifts his arms up and flexes his body. Peter sits straight up and his jaw drops. "Do...do you like this?" James blushes and looks away from Peter.

Peter nods. "I think I'd like it even better without your pants on." James turns around and pushes his pants down past his butt. He wiggles it at Peter, flicking his tail from side to side. He bends over and pushes his pants and underwear fully off. He flexes his butt at Peter and turns back around. James walks back and sits on the couch.

"So, how're we doing this? The big 100th loss special, the winner fucks the loser." James asks.

Peter pushes James on his back. "I want to look into your eyes." Peter lifts James's legs onto his shoulders and inches his dick towards his back door. He rubs his dick against James and pushes it against his hole.

James shuts his eyes. It's just like a shot, only it'll last longer. His pucker closes shut as James tries to get past his tight ring.

"James, you've got to calm down and relax. It'll hurt a lot if you're tense." He places a paw on James's cheek and leans down, kissing him. James opens his eyes and closes them gently again. He holds Peter's face as they kiss. Peter feels James loosen up his pucker and pushes his cock inside.

James winces but groans into the kiss. It was something he wasn't familiar with. He'd been with plenty of girls, being on the football team would do that, but there was something about Peter's dick head inside him that felt...right. He keeps kissing Peter.

Peter keeps pushing forward. He was about halfway in, panting into James's mouth. He breaks the kiss and rests on James's chest. This is all so unreal. He's halfway into a member of the football team, something he didn't think would happen, and he doesn't want it to end. He nuzzles into James's chest. James places his paw on Peter's back and reaches down to Peter's rump, giving it a push.

Peter looks up at James, their noses touch. "James?"

Blushing, James looks into Peter's eyes. "Give it to me, Peter."

Peter nods and pushes against James's chest. He thrusts forward, going balls deep in the wolf. James winces. God, I feel so full! James reaches down to his stomach and holds it. He bumps his dick and moans. He looks up at Peter, who nods. James grasps his knot and squeezes. His hole squeezes down on Peter.

"Ah hah!~ All that teasing earlier..." Peter pants and moans. He was finding it hard to breathe.

"You too, huh Peter?" James was panting just as hard as Peter.

"James, I don't want this to end." Peter pulls his cock out and thrusts it back in all at once. He reaches out and grasps James's knot, giving it a good, tight squeeze

"Oh fuck!" James throws his head back and shoots a strand of cum over his head, hitting the wall. His body spasms and keeps shooting cum along his body. His stream hits his cheek, chest twice, and belly three times before oozing out and dribbling the remaining out of his cock.

James's hole clenches down on Peter's cock tight. "Fuck!" Peter lunges forward, burying his head in James's chest and planting his seed in James. His cock throbs and shoots a torrential amount of cum inside the wolf. One shot turns into three, which turns into six. Peter loses count how many times he shoots into James, but he is done and spent. Peter wraps his arms around James and nuzzles into the cum stained chest.

James pets over the rabbit's head. Peter looks up at James and smiles. The wolf blushes and looks away. He coughs. "We should probably clean up."

"Oh, right." Peter lowers his ears and pulls his cock out of James. He gets up and extends his paw to James. "I'll show you the bathroom."

James and Peter gather their clothes and Peter leads James to the bathroom connected to his bedroom. It's a standard white tile white wallpaper room with a glass door shower. Peter turns the water on and they climb in. Neither talked during the shower, lost in their own thoughts and looking away from each other.

Maybe this was a mistake, thought Peter, he's not even looking at me.

Why did I enjoy that?_Thought James. _I'm straight, right?

James puts his clothes on quick while Peter takes his time. Peter catches up to James just before he leaves the house. "Leaving already?"

James turns around. "Well, we finished our bet. No real reason for me to stick around is there?" He grabs the knob and twists it. "I didn't want it to end either," he whispers. James opens the door and closes it behind him. Peter puts his paw on the door. On the other side, James leans against the door. James turns around and reaches for the knob, but hesitates and leaves Peter's house.


The next day, James is with his football friends. Peter walks by and is stopped by the giant alligator. "Say, James, how is that bet going?"

"Um, well-"

"Oh you know he's sucked a dick by now, Thom," said the lion

"You see, Thom, Jaime-"

"I forfeited the bet." All eyes, even James, focus on Peter. "He's just too good. My 50thloss was yesterday and I just saw no hope in winning. Good game, James." Peter extends his hand.

James shakes it. "Yeah, good game." Peter walks away from the group.

"So, James, how was his ass then?" asked Thom. "Was it as tight as any girl?" James fell silent.

"Listen, I'll catch up with you guys later." James runs after Peter. The rabbit was about to enter his next class. "Peter! Wait!"

Peter turns towards James. The wolf stops and leans over, panting. "James? What is it?" James looks at the rabbit and grabs him. He pulls Peter towards himself and kisses him. Peter's eyes widen and he looks around. The two got some glances from wondering classmates. They start whispering about James kissing a boy. Even the alligator and lion from before followed James and let their jaws drop to the floor. James breaks the kiss between him and Peter. James presses his forehead against Peter's. "I thought you didn't want anyone to find out."

"I don't care. Peter, I like you." Peter blushes and looks away. "This whole stupid bet, I really did want to try being with a guy. What I've come to learn is that I like it, a lot. No one has ever made me feel this way before. I'd like to give this a go. What do you say?"

Peter looks back at James. His eyes, they're so sincere. Peter wraps his arms around James. "I'd love to!"