A Sandwich for Annabelle

Story by Jeeves on SoFurry

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

After spending a night with Annabelle, the following morning only gets even more incredible for Snap and his new tigress lover.


This story was written for Burgabandit as part of my Patreon request days for July. This story contains sexual acts between a trio of consenting adults, a male, a female and a herm. :3

A Sandwich for Annabelle

"Oh god. I'm... A-Annabelle... I'm gonna cum..."

The were-donkey stroked the tigress' ears as delicately as his trembling fingers would allow while he watched her toothy maw bob up and down along the length of his cock. After last night, having made the herm tigress cum with his hands, his mouth, and of course his cock so many times, Snap probably shouldn't have been surprised when he woke up that morning to feel the tigress' thick cock rubbing up against his own. He had however been rather shocked when she whispered to him that this morning was all about him, and more so when she had followed it up by... well, by doing this. For almost half an hour now she had bee devotedly suckling his cock. Bringing him to the brink and then easing off. Getting him more and more worked up, more and more out of his mind with pleasure. But now there seemed to be no restraint in her suckling. Now it truly felt like the tigress wasn't trying to tease him, but at long last was seeking to make Snap cum.

"Ah! Aaahhh! Oh god. O-ohhhh... yes... I'm... I'm g-gonna..."

The doorbell rang, and Snap almost wailed loud enough that whoever was downstairs would surely hear when in an instant the tigress pulled back from his member with a giggle and instantly sprang from the bed. She grabbed a robe from a hook on the back of the door and was out of it before Snap could say another word, though she did stick her head back into the room a moment later to regard the were-donkey sternly.

"Don't you dare jerk off while I'm away, Snap. That cum... that cock, I want it inside me, nowhere else."

Then she was gone. The sounds of her heavy footsteps thundering away down the hallway, down the stairs, and then... then a distant burst of giggles, of squealing laughter and chattering voices that the were-donkey instantly recognised to his mutual dismay and suddenly renewed, overwhelmed excitement. In mere moments he could hear them getting closer again. Footsteps and voices hurriedly making their way back up the stairs and towards the room in which he lay. He made no attempt to cover himself. No attempt to cover his glistening cock as Annabelle slipped back inside, for the woman who followed the tigress was none other than the one responsible for him being here in the first place. His actual girlfriend, the one who had loaned him to Annabelle for the night and thus put him through all of this most delicious torment at her hands.

"H-hi, Kate..."

The were-donkey looked bashfully up at the smaller, plump equine as she strolled into the room behind the tigress, Annabelle's huge cock sticking out through the only loosely tied front of her robe along with one plump breast.

"Hi Snappy. I hear you've been good? Given Annabelle all that I told her you'd be able to, and then some?"

Shuddering as he closed his eyes for a moment and recalled the previous night, much of it spent with his face sandwiched between the tigress' strong thighs, Snap nodded.

"So, did you enjoy being her pet for the night?"

The were-donkey gave a not so subtle whimper as his eyes fluttered open and he saw that Kate was no longer simply standing near the doorway, but instead was beginning to undress. Already Annabelle was nude once more, and stroking her thick cock slowly as she watched the female donkey remove her clothing.

"I... y-yeah, it was fun."

Kate giggled as she looked between the two naked figurs sharing this space with her, quickening her pace and soon rendering herself wholly nude too. The plump female donkey walked over to the bed and scrambled up onto it, and before Snap knew it she was straddling him, not slipping his cock into her but resting over the length of his member, pinning it between them and slowly rocking herself back and forth along it.

"Fun, hmm? So... does that mean you'd rather obey her rules than mine?"

Snap gasped and shook his head, but then saw the tigress standing close by with an eyebrow cocked and her arms folded, cock throbbing hungrily as she licked her lips. Lips which until so very recently had been wrapped around his cock.

"I... n-no. I mean... I'm still your, b-but... I'd spend another night here if... i-if it was okay. You're both so beautiful, a-and..."

He fell silent, ceasing his stammering attempts to explain himself only when Kate pressed a finger to his muzzle. She grinned, looked from him to Annabelle, then back again.

"Well, if you think we're both so awesome, how about this for an idea. How about you obey me... when I tell you to do something to her?"

Annabelle blushed and growled in delight. Snap did much the same, though with much more blushing and much softer moaning. They both nodded, and Kate giggled as she rolled off of the larger, more powerful donkey to lie nude and exposed beside him.

"Then... how about you join us, Annabelle. Both of us. Come and show Snap what it looks like to see his girlfriend getting filled with tiger cock, and then... once he's got such an eyeful he won't be able to think or dream of anything else for days... he makes use of that beautiful herm body of yours, and fucks you while you're fucking me."

She looked at the two others, the were-donkey and tigress, and as they looked at each other alongside her Snap in particular was surprised to see that Annabelle looked every bit as stunned and overwhelmed by that latter part of the plan as he did. Sure enough, even as Annabelle crawled onto the bed and placed herself between Kate's legs, the once oh so confident and eager tigress let loose a nervous, mewling whimper.

"K-Kate... you know what that does to me. I... o-oh god..."

The tigress shuddered as Kate leaned up from where she was lying to kiss her tenderly upon the muzzle. Without breaking that kiss, still face to face, eye to eye with the feline, she nodded.

"I do know. And I want Snap to see that. To feel it. So that next time you borrow him as your pet... he won't be able to look at you without seeing the same squirming, helpless ball of lust that you probably turned him into last night."

Snap blushed as he heard all of this, and as he was ushered into place behind the tigress, shuddering and moaning as he watched Kate's eyes bulge when Annabelle's cock began to slide deep into her, he couldn't help but moan a final question to the donkey who was now very much in control of them both.

"What you said... a-about Annabelle losing control... about her being like... l-like me? How much like me?"

Kate giggled over the shoulder of the herm they were discussing, and she gestured to the tigress' backside as Annabelle growled lustily.

"There's only one way to know for sure. Slip inside, Snap. Put your cock inside her. Fuck her... and find out."

***********

"Oh god!"

Snap had seen, heard and felt a lot since his first time with Kate. He had enjoyed the last few months of his adult life more than all the time that had come before, and selfish or greedy as it sounded at times, a lot of that had to do with the time that he had the donkey had spent together in the throes of carnal passion. He had learned so much of not only himself but of how to pleasure and satisfy others, and he had seen extremes of ecstasy and desire burst forth from himself and his lover that he would never have believed possible before meeting Kate.

That being said, he had never seen anyone react in the way that Annabelle did the very moment he pressed his thick equine cock into her.

"Don't stop! More. More. God yes god yes yes yes oh my fucking god. yes!"

She had already seemed insatiable the night before, but this... half the time Snap couldn't tell whether she was demanding or begging. Commanding or pleading. She was driving Kate crazy, fucking the donkey at such speed and with such force that he had already watched the woman he loved cum twice, but at the same time she had been begging Snap to fuck her harder in turn all the while. Already Snap had been having a hard time imagining what it would be like to be a herm, to have two sets of genitalia and potentially having them both stimulated at the same time. Now though, whether this was unique to Annabelle or something all herms experienced, he was almost terrified at the idea of such intense and overwhelming bliss.

"_Nnnhnhaa aaahhhhhhhhhgod _!"

As the tigress roared and thrashed between them, pussy convulsing, cock throbbing, cum pouring from both portions of her sexually overwhelmed form into and around those responsible for that total overload of her senses, Snap could still see his girlfriend grinning through her own bliss over one of the tigress' shoulders. Occasionally, between the more fevered and wild bouts of Annabelle's thrashing when she lay limp and giddy with lust between them, letting Snap hump her and allowing his motion to drive her own thrusts into Kate, the donkey would address them. Indeed as soon as Annabelle's pleasure tapered off once again, her frantic, fatigued but still desperate whimpers were replaced by Kate's thick moans. She wasn't addressing him this time though. She was staring at him but speaking to the tigress.

"Whose pet are you?"

Annabelle mewled desperately.

"Y-yours."

Kate giggled, huffing in pleasure as Annabelle's unabated erection flexed inside her once again.

"Just... ah, just mine?"

The tigress whined and shook her head.

"Yours, K-Kate... and... Snap's, too."

The donkey giggled, and the were-donkey groaned in wonder.

"What would you do for us? For Snap, if he asked you, right now?"

Annabelle shuddered and craned her neck round so that she too could look at the blushing, shuddering were-donkey. Her eyes were wide and glazed as she gasped a single word.

"Anything."

Kate grinned.

"And Snap... if your sweet, slutty little pet here were to do whatever you wanted... what would it be that you'd ask her to do? What would be your command for Annabelle to obey... right here, right now."

Snap's head span. He could ask her to do anything. Anything, and he sincerely believed that if she could, she'd do it, or at least try. That thought excited him. It emboldened him in a way nothing short of Kate's loving stare could even come close to replicating. And then it occurred to him. The most simple, wonderful command he could give.

The buff were-donkey snorted. He pulled himself more steadily upright upon his knees where he lay, grabbed the base of the tigress' tail in one thick hand, and began to fuck her faster. Harder. So much faster that in a matter of seconds his thighs and his heavy balls were slapping loudly against the herm's own, and the slurping wetness of his cock sliding in and out of her already sodden pussy almost rang out louder than the combination of Annabelle's suddenly mindless, piercing cries of ecstasy, and his own simple, commanding cry.

"Make Kate cum."

Kate's eyes bulged. Her face burned scarlet, and the female donkey let loose an uncharacteristically nervous moan.

"Make her cum... and don't stop until I've stopped doing the same to you."

By Jeeves

Like my stories? Want access to a whole host of writing weeks or even months before it appears on other sites as well as exclusive request days to get stuff written for yourself? Consider supporting me on patreon with rewards from as low as $5 per month! https://www.patreon.com/jeevesroo :D Alternatively, you can throw me a few bucks through my Ko-Fi page.